Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

9.3% Yield! Is This Little-known Ftse 100 Share One Of The Best Income Buys On The Market?

Card image cap

The FTSE 100 is home to plenty of well-known dividend stocks, but one lesser-known name is catching my eye. Ithaca Energy (LSE: ITH) currently offers the highest prospective dividend yield in the index, at around 9.3% for 2026. But just how sustainable is this mouth-watering monster yield?

What is Ithaca Energy?

Ithaca Energy is an independent oil and gas producer with a portfolio of assets concentrated in the UK North Sea. It explores for, develops and produces hydrocarbons, selling the oil and gas into energy markets.

It’s already a sizeable operation. In the first half of 2026, the company achieved average production of 128,000 barrels of oil equivalent per day, generating adjusted EBITDAX of $1.1bn.

Soaring energy prices enabled it to generate net cash flow of almost $1bn during the period, and beef up its guidance for shareholder returns.

The producer now expects to pay a full-year dividend of $500m-$530m. However, $255m of that has already been paid as an interim dividend. Nevertheless, its prospective yield is expected to hit 10% in 2027.

Is the dividend sustainable?

A double-digit dividend yield might look tempting, but it counts for little if the underlying business can’t keep generating the cash to fund it.

That’s a particular risk with Ithaca. Its business is heavily focused on producing oil and gas, leaving it more exposed to movements in commodity prices than the likes of BP and Shell.

Those energy giants have much more diversified operations, including refining and trading businesses. These can help cushion the blow when conditions in the oil and gas markets turn less favourable.

Ithaca doesn’t have the same breadth of operations to fall back on. So, if prices fall significantly, or production disappoints, cash generation will come under pressure. That could ultimately mean lower dividends.

In other words, investors considering the stock today are making a fairly clear bet. They need to believe energy prices will remain supportive enough for the producer to keep generating the cash needed to fund its generous payouts.

I’m betting elsewhere

There are other risks to consider too. Oil and gas production is a challenging business, and companies operating in the North Sea face an uncertain political and regulatory environment. Tax changes and shifting government policy can quickly alter the economics of projects.

BP’s decision to put its North Sea business up for sale is a reminder of these challenges. The energy giant says the assets would be better positioned under another owner, but its planned departure after 60 years in the region is hardly a ringing endorsement.

Personally, I’m more comfortable owning the oil majors. Their dividend yields are considerably smaller, but their diversified businesses offer greater resilience. And when energy prices are strong, they can still deliver attractive capital gains.

I’m bullish on energy stocks, but Ithaca isn’t quite for me. Its eye-catching yield may appeal to investors with a higher tolerance for risk. I’d rather sacrifice some income for the relative security of the majors.

Should you invest £5,000 in Ithaca Energy Plc right now?

When investing expert Mark Rogers and his team have a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the flagship Twelfth Magpie Share Advisor newsletter he has run for nearly a decade has provided thousands of paying members with top stock recommendations from the UK and US markets.

And right now, Mark thinks there are 6 standout stocks that investors should consider buying. Want to see if Ithaca Energy Plc made the list?


Andrew Mackie owns shares in BP and Shell.

The post 9.3% yield! Is this little-known FTSE 100 share one of the best income buys on the market? appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.

More reading