Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

Ai: The Hammer That Thinks | Tim Morell | Tedxvero Beach

Card image cap

A bank that did not legally exist was about to take a man's home. Tim Morell was the man's lawyer. The bank's only witness was testifying from a laptop, and nobody had thought to cross-examine the laptop. What happened next involved one simple question, a state government website and Casper the Friendly Ghost.
In this personal, story-driven talk, the Florida trial attorney uses that case to name a mistake we are now making on a much larger scale with artificial intelligence: confusing calculation with judgment. AI can add, sort, match and predict at astonishing speed. It cannot decide what is right when the rule runs out, when the facts are incomplete, or when someone has to bear the loss. In Morell's words: "AI has calculations. It does not have a conscience."
The stakes reach well beyond the courtroom, and the talk turns sober when they do. Morell describes a teenager in crisis reaching out to a chatbot, and the families who have sued AI companies alleging that the AI's responses contributed to their child's death. To the AI, he says, it was just calculations. He also shows the other side: for many people who represent themselves in court, AI may be the only legal help they will ever have.
Morell is neither a cheerleader nor a doomsayer. He uses AI every day. A hammer can build a house or hit someone over the head. His concern is what happens when the hammer starts to think for itself and decides which one to do, and when it gives us an answer that sounds confident but is wrong in a way that feels right. He offers practical guidance for using AI when the stakes are real, and a rule of thumb for regulating it: "Regulate the courtroom. Leave the toaster alone."
He ends where he began, in that courtroom, with the most human question in the world, the one no AI can ask for us: Is this right?
Tim Morell is a Florida civil trial attorney with more than four decades of courtroom experience. His work focuses on litigation, privacy, cybersecurity and AI governance. He is a former chair of The Florida Bar's Computer Law Committee and its privacy subcommittee, helped draft Florida's identity-theft legislation, and was certified by the American Arbitration Association for The Florida Bar as a mediator and arbitrator for high-technology disputes. He serves on The Florida Bar Cybersecurity and Privacy Committee and has taught lawyers and business audiences about technology and the law for many years. A former Toastmasters Area Governor, he speaks about how to use artificial intelligence without surrendering human judgment. This talk was given at a TEDx event using the TED conference format but independently organized by a local community. Learn more at https://www.ted.com/tedx