Books Are Magic Brings A Personal Touch To Brooklyn Bookselling
This story is part of Brooklyn Paper’s guide to the borough’s independent bookstores, published in celebration of Small Business Saturday.
When Books are Magic opened its doors in 2017, it was answering a concern familiar to many Brooklyn readers: What happens when a neighborhood loses its bookstore?
Novelist Emma Straub and her husband, Michael Fusco Straub, opened the independent bookstore after BookCourt in Cobble Hill closed, hoping to preserve a neighborhood gathering place while creating a home for authors and readers.
“Emma lives in the neighborhood, and she said, ‘I can't lose my neighborhood bookstore,’” Nicole Vasquez, the store's marketing coordinator, told Brooklyn Paper.
[caption id="attachment_252658" align="alignnone" width="449"] Straub and her husband opened the Smith Street location in 2017.Photo courtesy of Aatia Davison[/caption]Straub, who had previously worked at BookCourt, wanted to contribute to the community as an author herself while giving other writers a place to connect with readers. The result was Books Are Magic, which has since expanded to a second location on Montague Street in Brooklyn Heights.
Today, the bookstore’s identity extends beyond its shelves. Author events, children’s storytimes, book drives and fundraisers help make the stores gathering places for readers at different stages of life.
Vasquez and Yeshim Kayim-Yanko, the store’s marketing and events coordinators, said highlighting authors and creating opportunities for people to meet them are central to the business.
The stores regularly host author events, including appearances by local writers and nationally recognized names, including Virginia Evans ("The Correspondent), Ethan Hawke ("Rules for a Knight), Margaret Atwood ("The Handmaid's Tale") and Matt Dinnaman ("Dungeon Crawler Carl" series). Staff members said the events give Brooklyn readers a chance to meet authors in a smaller, neighborhood setting.
The bookstore also hosts free children’s storytimes on Tuesdays at its Smith Street location and Thursdays at its Montague Street location. Weekend programming sometimes brings in authors to read their books, with copies available for families to purchase.
The children’s section is another important part of the store’s identity. Straub’s children were young when she opened Books Are Magic, and the business has maintained a strong focus on children’s literature and literacy.
“Our kids section is incredible,” Kayim-Yanko said. “It's curated so well.”
[caption id="attachment_252656" align="alignnone" width="700"] Books Are Magic's children's section in Cobble Hill features a carefully curated selection of books for young readers.Photo by Olivia Seaman[/caption]The staff also emphasized the importance of making children’s books and programming accessible to families, particularly at a time when they said children’s literacy is a growing concern. ProLiteracy found that one in six high school students drop out each year, with illiteracy heavily contributing to their decisions. It also hypothesized that students who are behind when starting kindergarten "make up the largest portion of school dropouts."
For adults, one of the bookstore’s defining features is the personal touch booksellers bring to the shelves.
Rather than relying solely on bestseller lists or online trends, employees write individual recommendations, known affectionately as “shelf talkers,” to introduce customers to books they have read and enjoyed.
The cards offer a glimpse into the interests of the people working behind the counter, and some customers have developed favorites among the staff’s recommendations.
“I've worked at other bookstores before, and did the corporate situation with shelf talkers,” Kayim-Yanko said. “This is the only job I've been at where I've had customers come in and say, ‘I'm looking for this person's shelf talker because I love the recommendations.’”
[caption id="attachment_252654" align="alignnone" width="700"] Booksellers at Books Are Magic curate displays and handwritten recommendations to help customers discover their next favorite read.Photo by Olivia Seaman[/caption]One employee, Bex, has developed a following among customers who specifically seek out their recommendations.
The personal connection can help readers find books they might not have encountered otherwise, Kayim-Yanko said. Books Are Magic employees read different genres and bring their own interests to the store’s selection.
“We have the trendy books, but then a lot of the shelves you'll see are just us bringing in books that we think are interesting and that we're curating ourselves,” she said.
Books Are Magic staff also view social media as one way new readers discover independent shops. Viral titles and online recommendations can bring customers through the door, but the hope is that they will leave with something unexpected.
Kayim-Yanko described the process as “a foot in the door.” A customer might arrive looking for a popular title, then discover a neighborhood bookstore, browse the shelves and return for another recommendation.
The coordinators said they have renewed interest in independent bookstores in other cities, too, though they cautioned that New York and Brooklyn have their own distinct bookstore culture.
They also pointed to the growing popularity of spaces that combine bookselling with other experiences, such as cafes or bars, as businesses look for ways to bring people together.
[caption id="attachment_240686" align="alignnone" width="700"] Books Are Magic on Montague Street.File photo by Susan De Vries[/caption]For Books Are Magic, Small Business Saturday can introduce the store to people who might not otherwise stop inside. The coordinators said some visitors are surprised to learn the bookstore is in their neighborhood.
“A lot of people don't even know Books Are Magic is in Brooklyn Heights,” Vasquez said. “There are so many people who are ask, ‘When did this place open?’”
The goal is to turn those first visits into regular ones.
The store also plans special offerings for the shopping holiday, but Kayim-Yanko and Vasquez said the larger value of Small Business Saturday lies in reminding shoppers to consider independent businesses alongside major retailers.
They also pointed to Independent Bookstore Day on April 27, an annual celebration dedicated specifically to independent bookstores, as another opportunity to bring attention to local booksellers.
For Books Are Magic, the most meaningful support comes when customers keep returning — whether for a new release, a children's storytime, an author event or a recommendation from a bookseller they trust.
The store's mission, its staff said, is not simply to sell books, but to give readers a place to find their next favorite story and the people who will help them discover it.