Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

Boston Considers A Public "worst Landlords" List To Help Shame Building Owners Into Fixing Chronic Problems

Card image cap

Boston's proposal does not include a bell.

ISD, which already takes troublesome landlords who don't fix major violations to court, is working with city councilors to create a system to also publicly shame them  into fixing the problems through a twice-a-year public "scofflaw list."

At a hearing today, Dion Irish, the city's chief of operations, said he agreed with the basics of a proposal by Councilor Liz Breadon (Allston/Brighton) to publicize the city's worst landlords, as New York has done for decades, that  "public shaming and reputational harm,"  might spur landlords who have been ignoring major problems to fix them, rather than just continuing to pay a series of fines. In fact, he said ISD had started work on something similar in 2019, only to get sidelined by the pandemic.

The list would rely on a point system to gauge offensive landlords, based on criteria that would include the number and type of violations and fines, with the top offenders getting shamed publicly.

Where Irish and  Breadon differ is whether to take additional steps that would outright bar the more loathsome landlords from getting zoning variances for new projects or city contracts while they're on the list.

Breadon says the prohibitions on new projects and contracts, on top of public shaming, might be enough to really get the building owners to fix longstanding problems. Irish, however, says linking things that have not traditionally been connected, such as sanitary-code violations and zoning variances, might raise legal or  constitutional issues. Still, he said, by having their names and issues made public,  the landlords might have to face tough questions from members of the zoning and planning boards should they try to expand their holdings through new development.

City officials said it would not be difficult using existing city databases to create a system for assigning shame points to landlords based on their willingness - or refusal - to fix complaints by tenants and ISD inspectors, although Irish and ISD Commissioner Tania del Rio said one possible issue is the way landlords often set up different LLCs for each building, making it a bit harder to go after them. However, they added that they already have to do that when they go into court for problems that don't get fixed, since the legal system requires a name and address to serve summonses on.

Irish and del Rio said a rough guess, based on the experience of New York and Chicago, is that maybe 100 landlords across the city might be at risk to get on a worst-landlords list.

The city has roughly 190,000 rental units.

Other councilors supported the idea, although Councilors Enrique Pepén (Hyde Park, Roslindale, Mattapan), who is himself a renter, and John FitzGerald (Dorchester), said they did not want to see small landlords with just a few apartments face the same risk of public shaming as larger landlords with lots of units, typically hidden behind multiple LLCs. Councilor Gabriela Coletta Zapata (East Boston, North End, Chinatown), said her home neighborhood of East Boston has been overrun by developers with "large property portfolios" who "cosplay as property managers" of buildings that not infrequently have "shoddy construction and serious habitability issues."

Councilor Ed Flynn (South Boston, South End, Chinatown, Downtown), however, objected to the whole idea of public embarrassment and said he would rather huddle with landlords to hear them out and work with them to get the problems fixed.

He said he spent yesterday in Chinatown dealing with some persistent trash problems and that  "I don't want to shame the business owner, I want to try to get the trash picked up."

"Is there some other way we can do it without public shaming?" he asked. "Can we work with people in a respectful manner like we always have in the city of Boston? ... During challenging economic times, we do have to support each other. I want to see how we are able come together as a city without necessarily shaming people to do the right things."

Del Rio said shaming would be the last resort, not the first. She said that ISD inspectors try to contact a landlord to talk about getting a problem resolved before the escalate to filing in court, and that the public listing would work the same way.

Flynn added that he's also concerned about out-of-control Airbnb properties, although he said he understands that that company has "political connections through their lobbyists." In 2018, Airbnb tried to smear then City Councilor Michelle Wu in an e-mail campaign as being in the pocket of Big Hotel for daring to propose an ordinance to restrict and regulate short-term rentals in the city.

Irish said that Airbnb has since become the most responsible of short-term-rental vendors and has proven quite willing to work with the city on problem Airbnb rentals in Boston. He added the city has fined roughly 300 apartment owners for improperly renting out their units for short term rentals.

Topics: 
Neighborhoods: