Is Caviar Losing Its Status As An Elite Delicacy?

You haven’t really experienced luxury until you’ve sliced open a sturgeon and smothered a potato chip in its beady little unfertilized eggs. And yet, the high-end delicacy caviar is currently facing an identity crisis, as Chinese caviar floods the wholesale market and direct-to-consumer retailers, fast food chains, and even a sweater company get their hands on the once-rare topping.

But first, some history. Caviar wasn’t always so hoity-toity. It used to be so cheap and undesirable in the US that bars in the 1800s would serve the salty morsels for free, like peanuts or popcorn. By the turn of the century, however, caviar’s luxury status in Europe and Russia started to spread to the States—and so did demand. Sturgeon, which produce the eggs used in caviar, were overfished worldwide, especially in the Caspian Sea. By 2006, bans from the US and the United Nations had effectively halted the import and export of wild-caught caviar.

The industry goes DIY

Following the ban and the depletion of wild reserves, caviar suppliers had to pivot from fishing to farming, building massive sturgeon operations. But that led to its own problem: Sturgeon can take decades to mature and produce eggs—and they’re the ultimate diva of the fish world, requiring highly specific water temperatures. Only a few producers globally could do it, making caviar even rarer and more expensive.

Along came China:

• In the 1990s, the Chinese government decided to become the ultimate purveyor of fine fish products, investing heavily in its sturgeon aquaculture setups (among other delicacies, like foie gras, cherries, and macadamia nuts).
• In 2012, China made up about 14% of the global caviar market. But by 2024, it was the largest supplier of the fancy treat, accounting for 43%, according to a Financial Times analysis of International Trade Centre data.

Enter the new guys. With massive amounts of Chinese caviar flooding the US markets, wholesale prices have dropped. That’s allowed more nontraditional vendors to start hawking the fancy treats.

Last year, for instance, McDonald’s topped McNuggets with free caviar for Valentine’s Day. A whole new crop of DTC caviar brands has popped up recently, selling tins for under $200, compared with the $500+ price tag of traditional suppliers. Per the Wall Street Journal, caviar is getting so cheap “you could serve it to a toddler.”—MM

Become smarter in just 5 minutes. Subscribe to Morning Brew today.