San Francisco Just Approved A Path To A Public Bank. Now What?
(Photo by Zetong Li / Unsplash)
San Francisco voters in November 2026 have at least one thing in common with North Dakota voters from over a century ago: Both used the ballot box to pave the way for public banks.
Riding a wave of progressive populism that had swept the country at the time, North Dakota’s Nonpartisan League used a socialist platform to win the state’s gubernatorial race in 1916 and both houses of the state legislature in 1918. A year later, the state-owned Bank of North Dakota was born.
Last week in San Francisco, voters passed Proposition B with 52.5% of the vote. The measure amends the city charter to authorize the establishment of a Municipal Finance Corporation, a non-depository precursor to a municipally-owned bank, while also setting up a governance structure meant to insulate the institution from political interference.
Modeled in part after the 107 year-old Bank of North Dakota, the proposed municipally-owned bank in San Francisco would not be set up to take deposits from the general public. Instead, it would take deposits primarily from the city and county government of San Francisco. Likewise, rather than lending on its own, it would primarily work through local private lenders to make more credit available for affordable housing, small business and green investments that currently struggle to access credit from large banks and other capital sources.
It’s still years before San Francisco’s proposed public bank will fully be realized, if that ever happens. But last week’s ballot box victory comes after years of campaigning and grappling with some of the key questions around public banks, including how they would be overseen and prevent political influence over lending.
The potential for political interference is one of the most common concerns whenever someone brings up government ownership of a bank. Skeptics have plenty of history to point to when it comes to elected officials directing funds to pet projects, sometimes overtly and sometimes covertly. The San Francisco Public Bank Coalition has had to address that concern since it was founded back in 2017.
“It’s a valid concern, but I also don’t understand how we entrust hedge fund managers and executives at Wall Street banks to make any better decisions for our livelihoods than the bankers that we’ll be hiring,” Jacqueline Fielder, who co-founded the coalition, told Next City in 2019. “The bank itself is going to be a separate corporation owned by the city but not operated by the city. Supervisors won’t have direct say about who it loans to. There are still going to be bankers running the bank.”
The coalition found allies on San Francisco’s Board of Supervisors, which passed an ordinance in 2021 creating a “Reinvestment Working Group,” consisting of the City Controller, Treasurer, and experts in financial institutions, affordable and social housing finance, small business lending, environmental justice and renewable energy. The group spent the next two years working with consultants to draft a business plan and a governance plan for a municipal finance corporation as well as a separate business plan and governance plan for a San Francisco Public Bank.
Partly informed by public banks and development banks based in other countries, the Reinvestment Working Group proposed a governance structure ensuring that no one person or body can appoint a majority of board members for either the municipal finance corporation or the proposed public bank.
The working group proposed a two-tiered approach, with a nine-member “oversight commission” providing an extra layer of oversight insulating board members from elected officials. The board of supervisors appoints four of the nine oversight commission seats, the mayor appoints two, and the treasurer-tax collector, controller and city attorney (all three are citywide elected positions) each appoint one member to the oversight commission. The oversight commission’s main role, in addition to providing advice and guidance for the bank, is to appoint the actual board members for the municipal finance corporation. Both the oversight commission and the board would expand if the institution transitioned into a full-fledged public bank holding municipal deposits.
In 2023, San Francisco’s Board of Supervisors voted unanimously to accept the governance and business plans produced by the Reinvestment Working Group.
Fielder herself won election to San Francisco’s Board of Supervisors in 2024, representing the Mission District. Public banking has been a very personal cause for her. She’s Lakota by heritage, and back in 2016 joined members of her family residing on the reservation in North Dakota to protest against the Dakota Access Pipeline. Creating a public bank became for her a way to get local tax revenues and other public dollars out of banks that were financing the pipeline.
“None of us knew anything about banking to begin with, but we haven’t let Wall Street gaslight us into thinking that this is impossible,” Fielder told Next City in 2019. “North Dakota showed a hundred years ago that it was possible, and they did it without fintech, they did it as grain farmers in arguably a very difficult era.”
Proposition B codifies the Reinvestment Working Group’s proposed governance structure into San Francisco’s city charter and authorizes the city to hire staff to implement those plans, though it does not by itself authorize or allocate any funding for implementation. Once it is funded and operational, the municipal finance corporation would start out by making loans in partnership with existing local lenders.
The lending partnerships would work primarily in the form of loan participations. In a loan participation, one lender originates a loan and maintains the relationship with the borrower, but behind the scenes the borrowed amount actually comes from two or more lenders, who share in the loan repayments. It’s a common way for private lenders to make loans that would be too large to make on their own or to make more loans of a particular category like small business or commercial real estate than they might otherwise be able to make.
In North Dakota, loan participations with the much larger Bank of North Dakota allow small local banks in rural areas to take the lead on financing multi-million dollar projects to build new hospitals or other community facilities that in other states would require larger lenders to take the lead. At the same time, the Bank of North Dakota participates in hundreds of small business loans of $50,000 or less every year — all of them loans originated by local lenders with the state-owned bank participating behind the scenes.
The Reinvestment Working Group’s proposed business plan projects the municipal finance corporation would receive $40 million in seed capital from the city, paid out over three years. Those dollars would serve as the bank’s initial capitalization, and, if all goes well, would not need to be repaid. These are the dollars that would come from a for-profit institution’s startup shareholders, but in this case they would come from a municipal government that plans to eventually own a bank in perpetuity. A hundred years ago in North Dakota, the state sold $2 million in bonds to raise the seed capital for its state-owned bank.
The proposed business plan also projects San Francisco’s municipal finance corporation would receive at least $50 million more in grants or low-interest loans, most of which would likely need to come from the city — although the business plan envisions it may be possible to raise some of that from state, federal or even private sources including foundations or even banks. As part of their obligations under the Community Reinvestment Act, large banks have made a habit of making loans to nonprofit loan funds that are federally-certified as community development financial institutions, or CDFIs.
After at least three years, if San Francisco’s municipal finance corporation can establish a successful lending track record and become financially self-sustaining, it would have authority to pursue a bank charter, a necessary step to eventually take deposits from the city. The Reinvestment Working Group’s proposed public bank business plan projects that the city would not be able to place deposits into the public bank until the bank itself receives a sufficient rating from a ratings agency, which may not happen until six years after commencing operations as municipal finance corporation.
In California, per the California Public Banking Act of 2019, a municipal-level public bank would require approvals from both state and federal banking regulators. Under that law, the window for municipalities in California to apply for a state banking license expires in 2029. Public advocates may have their work cut out for them if they have reason to extend that window.
Across the country, state and local governments have nearly $800 billion deposited in their various bank accounts. The top ten largest banks alone hold around $200 billion in state and local government deposits, according to quarterly data from the Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council.
Those public deposits remain a tantalizing target for public bank proponents across the country.
Philadelphia City Council passed a bill in 2022 to establish its own non-depository precursor entity to a public bank, but then-Mayor Jim Kenney who opposed the measure refused to name appointees to the entity’s board in order to begin implementing it. Current Philly Mayor Cherelle Parker — who voted for the measure as council member — has not moved to implement it so far.
Just across the Bay, in Berkeley, another public banking measure failed to pass. Known as Measure Z, it proposed a parcel tax that would have set aside an estimated $58 million in seed capital for a proposed East Bay Public Bank jointly-owned by the governments of Alameda County, Oakland, Berkeley and Richmond.
But it’s not all doom and gloom for public banks outside of San Francisco. In Richmond, newly declared Mayor-elect Claudia Jimenez previously endorsed the East Bay Public Bank proposal. Meanwhile in Los Angeles, Mayor-elect Nithya Raman also previously championed a Los Angeles public bank during her time as council member.
Oscar Perry Abello is Next City's senior economic justice correspondent and author of The Banks We Deserve: Reclaiming Community Banking for a Just Economy (Island Press). He also writes Next City's free economic justice newsletter, The Bottom Line.
Since 2011, Oscar has covered community development finance, impact investing, economic development, housing and more for media outlets such as Shelterforce, Impact Alpha, Yes! Magazine, City & State New York, The Philadelphia Inquirer, B Magazine and Fast Company. Oscar is a child of immigrants descended from the former colonial subjects of the Spanish and U.S. imperial regimes in the Philippines. He was born in New York City and raised in the inner-ring suburbs of Philadelphia. Reach Oscar anytime at oscar@nextcity.org or follow him on your favorite social media platform at @oscarthinks.