Survivor 51's Lewis Says His Biggest Regret Is Not Giving Up His Necklace For Kilby (exclusive)
Lewis Kelly bet his Survivor 51 game on a coin flip and lost. His ally Carter Krull had won immunity, and most of the tribe wanted him gone after a string of challenge wins. So the Dublin native volunteered for Wednesday’s million-dollar coin flip, which didn’t go his way and he became the third member of the jury. The extra $1 million now carries over to Season 52.
Lewis was in good spirits about his decision when he spoke to Men’s Journal the morning after. His bigger regret came a week earlier, at the double elimination Tribal that sent Danny “Kilby” Kilby and Kristin Flickinger home. Lewis and his partner, Sharonda Cox, were wearing immunity necklaces that night. Kilby and Kristin later said they’d thought about asking the pair to hand them over, so Kristin could play her Tethered Idol on Lewis and Sharonda instead, and keep them all safe. Lewis says he would have done it, since he didn’t think anyone was coming after Sharonda anyway. “I wish I did that, was give up that necklace,” he said. “Just send it, stand on business for Kilby the way he stood on business for me.”
Lewis also explains how his pitch to target Maggie Nestor got back to Thien An Nguyen within 10 minutes, whether Devin Way ever really wanted to flip the coin, where the Salt Alliance fell short, and how he dreamed up the fake Blood Ring during three days on Exile.
Scroll down for the full conversation with Lewis.
Men’s Journal: Good morning! Where do we start, Lewis? How are you feeling after watching the episode?
Lewis Kelly: I am honored to have been considered such a big threat, honestly. I’m glad I flipped the coin, having that precedent, for the sake of flipping it. I’m glad that people were going for me. So it’s kind of an honor to go out in a big way, kind of the way I entered this game. So I can’t really be upset.
Men’s Journal: Any regrets? Looking back, did you feel like, had you not flipped the coin, you were pretty much going to get voted out anyway? Talk to me about that.
Lewis Kelly: I felt like, coming in from Exile, I didn’t really have as close connections as a lot of other people. I was like, “Guys, I know you aren’t going to go to rocks for me realistically,” especially not Cristian [Chavez] or Carter, and I love Carter. I don’t think they would have gone to rocks with me. But I was like, “Guys, we could at least send me out banging. Let’s threaten rocks. Let’s see what happens.”
I was actually pitching, too. I was like, “Guys, I don’t see a way out of this game.” I knew Sharonda was really well tied in there, and I pitched Maggie to Devin and Sharonda. I was like, “Listen, Dev, I’m a big threat now. You’re perceived as a big threat now. Why don’t we take a big shot? Let’s go for Maggie. Let’s do this.” I really wanted to play a very flexible game, to be honest, to blow things up, flip things on their side. But then 10 minutes later, Thien An strolls over to me, and she’s like, “Are you pitching Maggie?” So when Devin’s saying, “Come up with a plan,” I gave you a plan. It was Maggie. And then 10 minutes later, Thien An comes strolling over.
I think where I went wrong was thinking people were willing to play as flexible and as chaotic as I was. It didn’t make sense for people to betray their alliances. Whereas I wasn’t anyone’s number one, so I could play freely. And I kind of thought, it’s Season 51, other people will be willing to make any f–king move. Go balls to the wall. Send it. That wasn’t the case, unfortunately.
Men’s Journal: Talk to me about Devin. Did you feel like he actually wanted to flip the coin? Was he trying to steer you to do it?
Lewis Kelly: So the thing is, Devin had been talking all season about flipping the coin, so he had this precedent. You can’t really back out when you’ve been pitching yourself all season to flip this coin. Do I think he wanted to flip the coin? No, because then he would have said no to me flipping it, right? I actually threatened for a second to send everyone to rocks for that coin. I was like, “I’ll send everyone to rocks.” They almost murdered me. Oh my God, you should have seen the looks. They all gave me the biggest dagger eyes. They’re like, “Don’t you dare!” And I’m like, “I won’t do it.” I think in theory, he likes the idea. I just think if he wanted to do it, he would have done it. And I was taking my time. I was taking my sweet time.
Men’s Journal: The Salt Alliance didn’t really go anywhere. Carter was worried that if you go out, he’d be next. Do you think he was fighting for you enough? Did that alliance do anything to try and save you?
Lewis Kelly: That’s the thing. Going to Exile, coming in, I just couldn’t form relationships as tight-knit as people had from day one. I would say that’s the con to going to Exile. I’m not complaining, because I made it pretty far. But was Carter willing to go out of his way and push his own game to save me? I don’t necessarily think so. I would have loved that, because I trusted Carter with my life. I knew I wasn’t his number one, but I needed someone to hold my cards. I just don’t think he would.
Men’s Journal: I want to ask about last week because Kristin and Kilby told me they thought about you and Sharonda giving up your necklaces for them, and they would have played the idol. Would you have gone with that plan?
Lewis Kelly: Oh, I was right there. I picked Sharonda because I knew no one wanted her out. I had a feeling, win or lose, I’m safe. So this necklace didn’t really mean to me what it meant to other people. I would have been like, “I will give my necklace up. I will make this crazy move,” because I felt like Sharonda would have made it regardless. That’s probably my biggest regret. I wish I did that, was give up that necklace. Just send it, stand on business for Kilby the way he stood on business for me.
Men’s Journal: Wow, what a missed opportunity. Talk to me about the Blood Ring too. Where did this idea come from? Did you have a bunch of ideas going into the game?
Lewis Kelly: I mean, I was on Exile for f–king years. I had three full days there, and I was just concocting so many different schemes, and plots out of delusion. And actually, I had already pulled off a successful blood idol. When I came into Toka, I got a lay of the camp. Who’s running it? Who’s the mob boss? It was Brady [Booker]. And I told him our lives were tied, that if I lost, he’d go with me. So Brady was like, “I’ll protect you. I’ll stand by you.” And I was like, “Yeah, I’ll protect you too.” I didn’t really need it, because it was chaotic over there and people were already going for each other, but I had a successful play once, and I thought I could do it a second time. My luck ran out a little bit. I was teeter-tottering on my luck. It was here and there.
Men’s Journal: What’s the most surprising thing you’ve learned from watching the show?
Lewis Kelly: Oh, what surprised me? Holy mackerel! There’s so much chaos going on. I’m surprised more of the chaotic relationships weren’t shown. There were a lot of people gunning for each other. Our guys were crazy. Our guys were f–king lunatics. So I’m just surprised some more of those elements weren’t shown. But you never know what to expect out there, so I’m not really fazed by the things that happened.
Men’s Journal: I’ve already seen a ton of people saying they want you back. Would you play Survivor again? Did you have fun out there?
Lewis Kelly: Oh, that was the most fun I ever had in my life. I would do it again in a million years. I need to flip a coin again. I need to have redemption. So I would easily go back. It was such good craic.
This interview has been edited and condensed for clarity.
Related: CBS Sets ‘Survivor 52’ Premiere Date — and Every Episode Will Run Two Hours