Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

The Trial That Could Upend Short Selling

Card image cap

A landmark fraud trial of legendary short seller Andrew Left began with jury selection yesterday, and the verdict could set an important precedent for pro stock bashers, aka activist short sellers, who publish damaging research about companies and profit from their shares tanking.

Federal prosecutors indicted Left in 2024, claiming he made at least $16 million by weaponizing his massive media reach to manipulate markets with dishonest commentary about stocks like Nvidia and Tesla. Left’s defense will likely argue that he shared sincere stock opinions protected by the First Amendment.

Is Left right?

In the 2010s, Left earned clout by exposing fraud at Valeant Pharmaceuticals and debt issues at China’s real estate giant Evergrande. But prosecutors claim that, in later years, he engaged in chicanery:

  • They’re accusing him of cashing in on short-term stock swings caused by his viral posts and TV appearances, while misleading investors about his exposure to those stocks.
  • Left is also charged with concealing his deals with hedge funds affected by the stock moves.

Left maintains that he’s being unfairly targeted due to his influence, and that there’s no clear requirements for prominent market commentators to disclose their trades.

Big picture: A guilty verdict could send Left to prison for up to 25 years and undermine the bread and butter of activist short sellers, a group that’s already hurting due to losses from meme stock rallies.—SK

Become smarter in just 5 minutes. Subscribe to Morning Brew today.