Jobs Can Be A Lifeline For Care Leavers. Does The Milburn Review Do Enough For Them?
Alan Milburn’s review into youth unemployment and the number of young people not in education, employment or training (NEET) has summarised systemic failure that requires a complete system reset.
For anyone connected with educating, training, caring for or supporting young people this comes as no surprise whatsoever. The issue has always been that achieving improved employment outcomes goes well beyond employment support, into the leviathans of education, health, and social care.
There are very few young people more negatively impacted through failings in the current system than those that have been looked after by children’s social care – care-experienced young people. In what are probably the most formative periods of their lives, many of these young people have experienced trauma, placement moves, disrupted education, and a lack of consistent and trusted adult support.
Read more:
- The enormous Birmingham charity shop which is helping solve Britain’s NEETs crisis
- Milburn Review: Young people should have legal right to work to address Britain’s NEETs crisis
- Milburn Review: Could disability benefit cuts for young people cost the government more than it saves?
The consequence of this is an already vulnerable group of young people for whom there are lower educational outcomes, an increased likelihood of being homeless, an over representation within the criminal justice system, and, very sadly, an increased likelihood of dying in their youth, compared to their peers.
It is clear that the barriers to work that care-experienced young people face go well beyond a lack of work opportunities. That is often the final part of a very difficult journey. But having successfully navigated so many systemic barriers, the final kick in the teeth comes from a lack of appropriate support and opportunities to enter the word of work.
This is where Milburn’s recommendations are to be welcomed.
They recognise that changes are required from education, health and social care, whilst at the same time, through the Youth Opportunities Service, suggest an employment support model based on consistent and trusted adult engagement, centered around the needs of the young person – a similar model to Drive Forward’s approach.
There is one clear distinction that must be made – that supporting a young person into a job is not the same as helping them build a sustainable career. For far too long there have been significant initiatives that focus entirely on achieving a ‘job outcome’ – any outcome. Not the job the young person wants, not the sector that they aspire to work in, and not the job that is sustainable for their future.
Keep reading the journalism that powers our mission
Register free to continue and learn more about the stories, campaigns and the support we provide, helping people facing poverty across the UK.
In looking ahead to the possibilities of the Youth Opportunities Service we must not fall into the trap of defining success purely on the basis of the number of job outcomes achieved. This approach has not made a dent in youth unemployment and NEET rates for many years and encourages a transactional approach to how we support young people.
Instead, we should be encouraging the building of enduring and trusted adult relationships where young people feel heard and valued, and a model that continues to connect with young people even once an outcome has been secured, providing a support net if things don’t go as planned.
Of course, for the Youth Opportunities Service to fulfil Milburn’s ambitions, there must be a significant increase in the volume of quality work opportunities available. A range of employer incentives in the form of financial carrots are recommended in the report to drive this volume. Great if this has the desired effect, however maybe we should also be showcasing to employers some of the incredible, and in some case unconventional, talent they are currently missing out on. This is particularly so for care-experienced young people, who often bring a unique perspective and lived experience into a workplace.
One solution to more effectively securing work for care-experienced young people is to have a dedicated Care Leaver Job Guarantee. As a care leaver, often living independently, it is detrimental to have to wait 12 months on universal credit before being able to take advantage of the existing Job Guarantee. They should be entitled to immediate access in order to rectify the poor outcomes achieved under the care of the state.
As corporate parenting duties extend, I’d also be very keen to see more public and private bodies replicating schemes dedicated to care-experienced young people in the way that the Civil Service Care Leaver Internship Scheme has done successfully for many years. I occasionally hear from HR teams that they can’t ringfence opportunities just for care-experienced young people. That’s ridiculous. Their youth has not been on a level playing field with their peers, so we should absolutely adjust recruitment practices accordingly – and fortunately trailblazing employers are.
The Milburn Review has laid out a pathway towards recovering a system that has been failing young people for a very long time. A brave and bold approach was required, and I believe this is what we largely got. It now needs to be implemented in the way that Milburn intends, and not become a replica of existing, transactional, approaches that really do not have the young people at the centre.
Do you have a story to tell or opinions to share about this? Get in touch and tell us more.
Change a vendor’s life.
Buy from your local Big Issue vendor every week – and always take the magazine. It’s how vendors earn with dignity and move forward.
You can also support online:
Subscribe to the magazine or support our work with a monthly gift. Your support helps vendors earn, learn and thrive while strengthening our frontline services.
Thank you for standing with Big Issue vendors.
The post Jobs can be a lifeline for care leavers. Does the Milburn Review do enough for them? appeared first on Big Issue.