You’re Waiting For A Sign They Like You. They’re Waiting For Yours.
There’s someone you’re into right now, or at least more curious about than usual. Maybe it’s the friend of a friend who keeps ending up next to you at things, or the person at work whose name makes you check your phone a little faster. Maybe you’ve even been on a date.
You’re intrigued, and you might even say you like them. That part you’re fairly sure about.
What’s holding you back from being more clear, more certain?
Well, them. They haven’t given you clear, unassailable evidence that they like you…at least not romantically. There are signs. You’d know, because you’ve been collecting them. They texted back fast, which seems good. They said “this was fun,” which is... fine? Then again, friendly people say that. You’ve reread the thread and done your own forensic semantic analysis, hunting for the one sentence or word that settles it, and it isn’t there.
Without that clarity, you make the only decision that sounds reasonable. You’ll wait until they make it clearer.
How clear will it need to be? You tell yourself a small sign will do. When the small sign comes, you decide it’s safer to wait for something even clearer. (This is going to take a while.)
Sometimes your patience wears thin and you want to push things. You type out “I had a really great time, I’d love to see you again.” When you see it on the screen, a little panic floods your body. You stare at it, second-guess everything that brought you to this moment, and delete it. You settle for “That was fun!” (Ironically, we all tell ourselves we won’t settle in relationships, but we do this kind of settling all the time.)
What “That Was Fun!” Looks Like on Their Phone
Few daters ever game this out from the other person’s side. They’re running the same doubts, making the same assumptions, and hoping for the same signal that removes all doubt. So when your name lights up their phone, they open it fast, hoping this is the one. Instead they get “That was fun!”
Ugh. Friendly. Friend. Friend zone.
Awkward and disappointing. Not wanting to feel any more exposed than they already do, they dial down how much interest they let you see.
You sense the shift and pull back too. Worse, you convince yourself that “That was fun!” was the exact right move because it saved you from putting yourself out there. In reality, that text is what ended this relationship before it started.
No one rejects you more than you do.
You’re Both Showing Up at 60 Percent
The moment you like someone is the moment the relationship feels a little scary. When you’re not into them, there’s nothing to lose. Now, if this doesn’t go well, it could hurt.
You protect yourself by keeping it cool, casual, deniable. That way, if they turn out not to feel it, you never technically put yourself out there and never technically got turned down. Safe.
Zoom out and you get two people sitting across from each other, both interested, both dialed down to 60 percent, each waiting for the other to send a signal clear enough to make it safe to show how they really feel.
This all feels logical and matches common advice to “match energy.”
Yet, when both people do it, it becomes a slow race to the bottom. Your 60 reads to them like a 50, so they match your 50. Their 50 feels like a 40 to you, so you match that. A few weeks of this and you’re both at 20, each convinced the other one lost interest first.
The window closes.
You both walk away thinking the other one wasn’t that into it.
If this sounds familiar in the past tense, it should. There’s probably someone you still think about more than you’d admit. Something real passed between you, and for a while it looked like it might become something. Then it cooled off and then it died. No reason or explanation. No fight. Nobody ever said no. You just thought “we just didn’t click.” It’s entirely possible they thought the same.
I gave this a name years ago because I kept watching it happen to good people: the downward spiral of disinterest. Two people who like each other, each too afraid to be the first to show it, slowly talking each other out of something real.
Clients often describe a dynamic where both partners are dropping hints, making subtle moves, circling around their interest without ever being too direct. As they both dance around their doubts, they don’t realize what they’re missing out on. If they’re lucky enough to finally have clear romantic intent revealed, it sounds something like this. One of them asks, “Why didn’t you say something sooner?” The other one exclaims, “I did! I have been!”
When it comes to showing interest, no one is as clear as they think.
The Signal You Sent vs. the One They Got
The spiral can only happen when you believe you were showing the other person your interest.
You know that you held eye contact a beat longer, laughed at the joke you didn’t really find funny, found a reason to keep the conversation going. In your head, that was a lot. You recognized your effort because it felt like you were really leaning in.
From their perspective, it barely registered. (That’s not a knock on you or your skills. Almost everyone undercooks their interest.) When we’re afraid of rejection, we badly overestimate how much interest we’re broadcasting because every little bit that we show creates vulnerability that’s painfully obvious to us. Researchers call this the signal amplification bias (Vorauer et al., 2003). Across four studies, people who were interested but held back believed their subtle overtures communicated far more romantic interest than the other person picked up on. The move that felt to you like a huge risk landed on them as friendly, or neutral, or nothing at all.
What feels momentous to you is only a fleeting moment to them.
Now stack a second bias on top. After a good conversation, most people underestimate how much the other person liked them. In other words, you’re selling yourself short. Researchers call it the liking gap, and they found it everywhere they looked: strangers in a lab, new college roommates, adults meeting at a workshop (Boothby et al., 2018). The detail that stings is that outside observers watching recordings of those same conversations could see how much the other person liked the conversation. Oddly, the two people having the conversation missed it, mostly because they were busy replaying their own awkward moments. That focus on yourself creates more negative self evaluations, which makes it even more difficult to spot how much the other person likes you. I mean, how could they like you when you said “um” three times?!?!?!
So a stranger watching your date could have told you they liked you. But you, sitting right there, couldn’t.
Put the two biases together and you can see the whole problem. You think you’re showing a lot more interest than you are and you underestimate how much the other person likes you. What makes it worse is that they are prone to the same two biases. It’s a wonder anyone ever gets together!
That distance, between what you feel and what you transmit, and between what they transmit and what you take in, has a name: the signal gap. You live in your feelings because you feel them so acutely. However, no one on the outside has access to that level of information. They only see the signals you put out there. Those signals rarely match your feelings’ intensity.
You feel all of it. They see a fraction. Put two people like that sitting together across a table, both waiting for the other to show the rest, and it ends without anyone ever actually saying no. It just dies and leaves both people a little confused.
The parter you’re most likely to lose in that standoff is unfortunately the type of person you’d most want to end up with.
Your Caution Is Choosing Your Partners for You
There’s a lot of bad dating advice out there. One piece I particularly dislike is “don’t show interest first.” It’s a nicer version of playing hard to get (which is also a bad idea). When you insist on withholding or hiding your interest with every match, every introduction, and every promising second date, all you’re doing is shutting down opportunities before you ever get a chance to fully vet them.
Think about who makes the bold, unambiguous first move every time, with zero encouragement. Some may be secure, wonderful people. More likely, the clearest signalers are people who’ve done this a thousand times, who feel entitled to a yes, and who lead with intensity because intensity works on people waiting to be pursued. The love-bomber has no fear of rejection to overcome. The person who’s nervously, sincerely into you does.
So waiting for interest creates a terrible filter because it only lets through whoever is loudest. The thoughtful, slightly anxious, available people, the ones you say you want, get screened out. A few disappointments later you decide there’s no one good out there. There might be. Your funnel filtered them out before you ever met them.
Going First Is the Safe Move
You don’t have to become a complete extrovert or especially bold person.
You just have to be willing to be clear with the people you like. Put yourself out there. It could be the slight touch of an arm, an earned compliment, or warmly saying, “You know what? I really like you.”
Going first closes the signal gap and gives you what everyone really wants in dating: Clarity. When everyone is clearer, dating gets more efficient and we all stop wasting our time with people who will never be our person.
Clarity corrects both biases at once. The other person no longer has to guess how much you like them, and your interest finally becomes visible. Somebody has to be first. It might as well be the person who knows how the spiral works.
If they’re not interested, you got that information fast and cheap, instead of spending weeks rereading texts and inventing meanings. If someone can’t meet a warm, direct person halfway, that’s their loss.
Playing it cool is not a strategy for getting love.
It’s a strategy for making sure that if love doesn’t happen,
it won’t officially be your fault.
You deserve someone who’s relieved you said something first.
Knowing all this and still freezing in the moment is normal. What gets you past it is having the words ready before your heart starts pounding and every instinct tells you to send “That was fun!”
Paid subscribers get How to Show Interest Without Feeling Exposed: exactly what to say (and text) at four escalating levels of interest, including how to send the message you deleted, a 10-second test that tells you whether your interest is visible, how to tell a nervous yes from a soft no, and the one timing rule that keeps the window from closing on you.
This post has bonus content for paid subscribers. Upgrade to get full access.
Take Home
Two people who like each other can lose a relationship without either one doing anything wrong, simply by both doing the careful thing.
The careful thing has a cost you never see on the receipt: the nervous, interested people it screens out before you ever know they were there. The next time you catch yourself holding back, a little scared to show someone how you really feel, opt for sending the clearer signal. If they feel the same, one of you had to go first, and you end up with a relationship that otherwise may have never had a chance.
Hope this helps,
Dr. L
This is a sign…that you should subscribe to the Psychology of Relationships.
If this helped, a like, share, or restack helps more people find it.
Have a comment? Please share. I read every one.
Dating is tough. Know someone who needs a little help? Forward this to them. It might be the most useful thing you share with them this year.
Share Psychology of Relationships
Here are other ways to learn more about the Psychology of Relationships:
My podcast: Love Strategies
My website: www.PsychologyofRelationships.com
References
Boothby, E. J., Cooney, G., Sandstrom, G. M., & Clark, M. S. (2018). The liking gap in conversations: Do people like us more than we think? Psychological Science, 29(11), 1742–1756. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797618783714
Vorauer, J. D., Cameron, J. J., Holmes, J. G., & Pearce, D. G. (2003). Invisible overtures: Fears of rejection and the signal amplification bias. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 84(4), 793–812. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.84.4.793
Photo by Yuri on Pixabay
Note: Please forgive any typos or errors. Non-AI writing has its imperfections. Consider it the patina of a personal touch.
Popular Products
-
Stainless Steel Book Photo Necklace$31.99$21.78 -
Custom Projection Ring for Couples$211.99$147.78 -
Slimming Waist Trainer & Thigh Trimmer$67.56$33.78 -
Adjustable Waist Trainer Belt$44.99$30.78 -
Butt Lifting Body Shaper Shorts$95.56$47.78