Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

We Tested The Best Medical Alert Systems–here’s Our Top 9

Card image cap

We independently select all products and services. While we earn a commission from partner links, commissions do not affect our editor’s opinions or evaluations.

Advertiser Disclosure

We Tested The Best Medical Alert Systems–Here’s Our Top 9

Published: Mar 26, 2026, 4:21am




Christopher Groux

Staff Editor
Christopher Groux is an editor, writer and accessibility advocate. Before joining the Forbes Health team, he covered Accessibility at Reviewed and gaming at Inverse and Newsweek. When he’s not creating content, you can find Christopher catching up …

Christopher Groux

Staff Editor
Christopher Groux is an editor, writer and accessibility advocate. Before joining the Forbes Health team, he covered Accessibility at Reviewed and gaming at Inverse and Newsweek. When he’s not creating content, you can find Christopher catching up …
Written By
Christopher Groux

Christopher Groux

Staff Editor
Christopher Groux is an editor, writer and accessibility advocate. Before joining the Forbes Health team, he covered Accessibility at Reviewed and gaming at Inverse and Newsweek. When he’s not creating content, you can find Christopher catching up …

Christopher Groux

Staff Editor
Christopher Groux is an editor, writer and accessibility advocate. Before joining the Forbes Health team, he covered Accessibility at Reviewed and gaming at Inverse and Newsweek. When he’s not creating content, you can find Christopher catching up …
Staff Editor

Meaghan Harmon

Meaghan Harmon

Staff Editor
Meaghan is an editor and writer who also has experience practicing holistic medicine as an acupuncturist and herbalist. She’s passionate about helping individuals live full, healthy and happy lives at every age. Outside of writing and editing for For…

Meaghan Harmon

Staff Editor
Meaghan is an editor and writer who also has experience practicing holistic medicine as an acupuncturist and herbalist. She’s passionate about helping individuals live full, healthy and happy lives at every age. Outside of writing and editing for For…
Fact Checked By
Meaghan Harmon

Meaghan Harmon

Staff Editor
Meaghan is an editor and writer who also has experience practicing holistic medicine as an acupuncturist and herbalist. She’s passionate about helping individuals live full, healthy and happy lives at every age. Outside of writing and editing for For…

Meaghan Harmon

Staff Editor
Meaghan is an editor and writer who also has experience practicing holistic medicine as an acupuncturist and herbalist. She’s passionate about helping individuals live full, healthy and happy lives at every age. Outside of writing and editing for For…
Staff Editor

& other

Collapse

How we analyzed

To identify the best medical alert systems for 2026, the Forbes Health editorial team conducted extensive user testing and market analysis, evaluating 15 popular products. Read our methodology.

Testing:
15 medical alert systems tested

Fall detection:
78 real falls conducted during testing

Metrics:
44 data metrics considered

The Forbes Advisor editorial team is independent and objective. To help support our reporting work, and to continue our ability to provide this content for free to our readers, we receive payment from the companies that advertise on the Forbes Advisor site. This comes from two main sources.

First, we provide paid placements to advertisers to present their offers. The payments we receive for those placements affects how and where advertisers’ offers appear on the site. This site does not include all companies or products available within the market.

Second, we also include links to advertisers’ offers in some of our articles. These “affiliate links” may generate income for our site when you click on them. The compensation we receive from advertisers does not influence the recommendations or advice our editorial team provides in our articles or otherwise impact any of the editorial content on Forbes Advisor.

While we work hard to provide accurate and up to date information that we think you will find relevant, Forbes Advisor does not and cannot guarantee that any information provided is complete and makes no representations or warranties in connection thereto, nor to the accuracy or applicability thereof.

The comparison service on our site is provided by Runpath Regulated Services Limited on a non-advised basis. Forbes Advisor has selected Runpath Regulated Services Limited to compare a wide range of loans in a way designed to be the most helpful to the widest variety of readers.

Quick Dive

Medical alert systems can provide lifesaving assistance in an emergency event, connecting users to dispatchers who can send for help. The Forbes Health team ran the tests and crunched the stats—and bruised a few ribs—to bring you the nine best medical alert devices of the year.

How We Picked the Best Medical Alert Systems


Overview


Methodology


Our Team

How We Picked the Best Medical Alert Systems

To identify the best medical alert systems for 2026, we conducted extensive user testing—including simulated falls—and market analysis, evaluating 15 popular products across 44 data metrics including costs, features and device reliability. The Forbes Health editorial team prioritizes the accuracy and integrity of the data collected. Our ranking is based on quantitative data and is free from conflicts of interest. We carefully fact check the information featured in our ranking and are committed to producing rankings and supplemental content about medical alert systems that readers can trust. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our medical alert systems methodology for the rankings below. 

Read More

How We Evaluate the Best Medical Alert Systems

  • 15 

    Medical alert systems tested

    We evaluated the top products across 13 brands 

  • 44 

    Data metrics considered 

    Includes costs, features and user feedback 

  • 78 

    Falls simulated during product testing 

    We evaluated the device’s fall detection reliability by simulating real falls 

Methodology

To determine the best medical alert systems of 2026, the Forbes Health editorial team evaluated 15 products from 13 noteworthy brands, with each product’s star rating determined by evaluating a variety of metrics, including its range of use, battery life, ability to detect falls automatically and cost. Medical alert systems for home use and mobile-friendly medical alert systems were evaluated slightly differently based on their distinct use cases. More details on our methodology can be found below.  

Features: 42.5%  

We considered the inclusion of specific features including fall detection, GPS, voice activation, signal range, battery life, extra buttons and lockboxes, multilingual support, additional health monitoring and the overall number of devices available. 

Cost: 27.5% 

We factored in the multiple costs associated with medical alert systems including initial equipment cost, subscription fees, activation fees and the availability of free trials.  

Staff testing score: 20% 

Each featured medical alert device underwent internal testing for usability, ease of setup, emergency response speed and fall detection capability. Fall detection pendants’ tendency to detect false positives was evaluated through drops onto a hard floor and by testers plopping down with force onto a chair when worn.  

User survey data: 10%  

We surveyed 1,504 U.S. adults who have used a medical alert system in the past 24 months. We asked users to rate the device’s ease of setup, ease of use, fall detection reliability, cost transparency, customer service and emergency response quality. 

Read More


(42%)

Features

(28%)

Cost

(20%)

Staff testing score

(10%)

User survey data

Our Team

Our team has decades of experience in the health space. We’re passionate about helping you make smart decisions about your wellness and supporting you on your path to a healthy and balanced lifestyle. 

Read More

Christopher Groux
Christopher Groux

Staff Editor



Meaghan Harmon
Meaghan Harmon

Staff Editor





Christopher Groux

Christopher Groux

Christopher Groux is an editor, writer and accessibility advocate. Before joining the Forbes Health team, he covered Accessibility at Reviewed and gaming at Inverse and Newsweek. When he’s not creating content, you can find Christopher catching up on the latest games or watching a classic slasher film. 

Expertise:




Accessibility


Meaghan Harmon

Meaghan Harmon

Meaghan is an editor and writer who also has experience practicing holistic medicine as an acupuncturist and herbalist. She’s passionate about helping individuals live full, healthy and happy lives at every age. Outside of writing and editing for Forbes Health, Meaghan loves practicing yoga, reading and spending time with her family near the ocean in her home state of Maine.

Expertise:




Holistic health



Supplements



Herbal medicine



Integrative medicine



CBD





Christopher Groux

Christopher Groux is an editor, writer and accessibility advocate. Before joining the Forbes Health team, he covered Accessibility at Reviewed and gaming at Inverse and Newsweek. When he’s not creating content, you can find Christopher catching up on the latest games or watching a classic slasher film. 

Expertise:



Accessibility
Christopher Groux

Meaghan Harmon

Meaghan is an editor and writer who also has experience practicing holistic medicine as an acupuncturist and herbalist. She’s passionate about helping individuals live full, healthy and happy lives at every age. Outside of writing and editing for Forbes Health, Meaghan loves practicing yoga, reading and spending time with her family near the ocean in her home state of Maine.

Expertise:



Holistic health



Supplements



Herbal medicine



Integrative medicine



CBD
Meaghan Harmon

The Best Medical Alert Systems of 2026 

Best Medical Alert System for Versatility

Designed for in-home and mobile use, we were impressed with the design of this device and its overall accessibility. With a reasonable service fee, this is a standout pick.

On Medical Guardian’s Website

Best Mobile Medical Alert System

Featuring location tracking capabilities and water resistance, the Sidekick Mobile from Lifestation is a great medical alert system for mobile use.

On Lifestation’s Website

MOST POPULAR

Best Rugged Medical Alert Device

This medical alert system earned top marks for its rugged and sturdy design, as well as its fall detection performance when we tested seated falls.

On Bay Alarm Medical’s Website

Best Home Medical Alert Device

We selected this medical alert device as our top pick for home use, as it offers simple setup, no equipment fees and a high coverage range.

On LifeFone’s Website

Best Medical Alert System for Large Homes

Another winner from Medical Guardian, this medical alert system is particularly great for large homes, as it has an impressive in-home coverage range of 1,400 feet.

On Medical Guardian’s Website

Best Medical Alert Device With No Monthly Fee

For those looking for a wristwatch medical alert device, we recommend this pick from Apple, as it does not charge a monthly service fee for its medical alert features.

On Amazon

Best Voice-Activated Medical Alert Device

This is our top pick for a voice-activated medical alert system; its voice commands work quickly and easily, and its service fees won’t break the bank.

Best System With Rip Cord Activation

We particularly liked the accessibility features of this medical alert system, which includes Braille characters on its base unit buttons and a pull cord on its wall buttons.

On GetSafe’s Website

Best Android Medical Alert Watch

Another wristwatch option, the Samsung Galaxy Watch7 does not require a subscription and includes other health tracking and fitness features.

On Amazon





FEATURED PARTNER OFFER partner offer
We receive compensation from our partners for Featured Partner Offer placements. While this may influence where their products or services appear on our site, it in no way affects our ratings, which are based on thorough research, solid methodologies and expert advice. Our partners cannot pay us to guarantee favorable review of their products or services.
We receive compensation from our partners for Featured Partner Offer placements. While this may influence where their products or services appear on our site, it in no way affects our ratings, which are based on thorough research, solid methodologies and expert advice. Our partners cannot pay us to guarantee favorable review of their products or services.
Bay Alarm Medical SOS Mobile Alert Systems
Bay Alarm Medical SOS Mobile Alert Systems
  • Stay connected and safe with Bay Alarm Medical's suite of SOS Mobile medical alert systems: help button, two-way speaker, GPS tracking
  • Activate help easily with included wearable button for neck or wrist
  • Powered by 4G LTE for better coverage, faster response
  • Caregiver Tracking: real-time location, history, low battery alerts
  • Long battery life, water-resistant design.
On Bay Alarm's Website
  • Browse Article
  • Best Medical Alert Systems of 2026: Tested and Expert Reviewed 
  • Compare the Best Medical Alert Systems of 2026 
  • Medical Alert System Features 
  • Medical Alert System Pricing 
  • Medical Alert System Tech Specs 
  • Why We Don’t Recommend Life Alert Systems 
  • How Do Medical Alert Systems Work? 
  • Types of Medical Alert Systems 
  • Key Features of Medical Alert Systems 
  • How Much Do Medical Alert Systems Cost? 
  • Does Insurance Cover Medical Alert Systems? 
  • How to Choose the Best Medical Alert System for You 

Best Medical Alert Systems of 2026: Tested and Expert Reviewed 

Best Medical Alert System for Versatility

Medical Guardian MGMini

Medical Guardian MGMini
health-logo-v2.svg
5.0
All ratings are determined solely by our editorial team.
  • Equipment fee: $149.95
  • Service fees: Starts at $39.95 per month (for annual plan)
  • Connectivity: Uses cellular signal, Wi-Fi and GPS
  • Use case: In-home and mobile
On Medical Guardian's Website
Our Expert Review

Medical Guardian’s MGMini offers a modern, streamlined medical alert solution. The defining feature of the MGMini is the ability to wear it in a variety of ways. Not only is this discreet device available in four different colors, but it also comes with a belt clip and lanyard, giving wearers opportunities to stay protected across a wide range of scenarios both inside and outside of the home. In fact, you can even wear the Mini in the shower thanks to its water resistance.

Pros & Cons
  • Simple design makes accidental call button presses unlikely
  • Pendant available in four different colors
  • Included accessories allow you to wear the pendant in a variety of ways
  • Audible pendant charging indicator is helpful in terms of accessibility
  • Fall detection system failed to detect genuine falls and detected false positives in our testing process
  • Button sequence to regularly test the device may be difficult with limited dexterity
  • Reliance on virtual portal for advanced features, such as managing reminders and emergency contacts, may be confusing for some
Our Experience With Medical Guardian MGMini

While trying out the MGMini for its base usability, our Forbes Health testers liked many of the device’s features. It has a few helpful accessibility perks, such as its magnetic breakaway lanyard and an audible charging confirmation when the pendant is placed on its charging cradle (included in equipment purchase). The large emergency button is placed front and center for usability, though we wished the information button on the side of the device was slightly more visible.

We were also disappointed with the MGMini fall detection feature, as it didn’t detect any genuine falls during our testing process. Meanwhile, the device detected false positives when dropped and while plopping down onto a chair. Its build quality and base functionality are great, but our product testers don’t advise relying on the fall detection.


Best Mobile Medical Alert System

LifeStation Sidekick Mobile

LifeStation Sidekick Mobile
health-logo-v2.svg
4.8
All ratings are determined solely by our editorial team.
  • Equipment fee: Equipment is free ($99.95 activation fee)
  • Service fees: $58.95 per month with fall detection
  • Connectivity: Uses cellular signal, Wi-Fi and GPS
  • Use case: In-home and mobile
On Lifestation's Website
Our Expert Review

LifeStation has been offering personal security solutions since 1977. The brand’s Sidekick Mobile, however, is a modern device, with nearly every key accoutrement a user looking for a mobile medical alert may want. It connects through Wi-Fi and LTE and includes GPS features to help locate the pendant and wearer if necessary. This may be a more budget-friendly but comparable alternative to the Medical Guardian MGMini.

Pros & Cons
  • Contrasting colors on small “test” and “silent” buttons may enhance usability
  • GPS helps locate users
  • Water resistance for use in wet environments
  • Failed to detect genuine falls and is prone to triggering when dropped, according to our testing results
  • Monthly fee is expensive on top of activation fee
  • Blinking light system may be difficult to troubleshoot
Our Experience With LifeStation Sidekick Mobile

Forbes Health product testers found the LifeStation Sidekick Mobile easy to set up and use, with simplicity an apparent guiding principle in its design. Just place the pendant on its cradle to charge, and the unit announces when it’s ready with an audible alert. One of the most underrated elements of this product is its color-contrasting design, which may help those with vision impairment easily differentiate between surfaces and buttons. Many medical alert systems have small buttons positioned flush on the side of the device, potentially making them difficult to see.

That said, the fall detection feature may not be worth the price, as the product seemed far more prone to triggering false positives than actual falls, according to our testing.


Best Rugged Medical Alert Device

Bay Alarm Medical SOS All-In-One 2 With Fall Detection

Bay Alarm Medical SOS All-In-One 2 With Fall Detection
health-logo-v2.svg
4.2
All ratings are determined solely by our editorial team.
  • Equipment fee: $189
  • Service fees: Starts at $44.95 per month with fall detection
  • Connectivity: Uses cellular signal, Wi-Fi and GPS
  • Use case: In-home and mobile
On Bay Alarm Medical's Website
Our Expert Review

Bay Alarm Medical has a history that stretches back nearly 80 years, establishing itself as a trusted name in the health care industry, illustrated by the company’s A+ Better Business Bureau rating and 4.8-star Trustpilot rating.

This device is sturdily built, great for those looking for a system that can withstand rugged use. It features all the best amenities in connectivity, water resistance, battery life and more. And while its initial equipment cost may be steep, the monthly commitment is less expensive compared to some competing products on this ranking.

Pros & Cons
  • On-the-go GPS tracking helps caregivers find the wearer, if necessary
  • Rugged design features water resistance up to 1 meter
  • Fall detection performed well in testing for seated slips
  • Additional battery-powered pendant included in the fall detection package
  • Some users may prefer a more discreet design
  • Connection issues experienced during testing
  • Did not detect any standing-position falls during testing
Our Experience With Bay Alarm Medical SOS All-In-One 2 With Fall Detection

In testing the SOS All-In-One 2, our Forbes Health testers found a lot to love. The super-rugged stylings of its large base pendant may not be the most discreet choice on the market, but it does appear built to last. Plus, those who prefer to wear something a little less bulky have the option to don a lighter-weight wearable button as a pendant or bracelet instead (included with the fall detection package).

In our testing, the added fall detection functioned well when sliding to the ground from a chair, but it didn’t react to falls from a standing position. We also had to fully reboot the device once during testing due to an apparent connectivity issue. Potential buyers of this device may want to ensure their AT&T cellular coverage is exceptionally strong before purchasing. It’s also worth noting that users will have to memorize the meaning of green, red and blue status lights to troubleshoot the device.


Best Home Medical Alert Device

LifeFone At-Home Cellular With Fall Detection

LifeFone At-Home Cellular With Fall Detection
health-logo-v2.svg
4.1
All ratings are determined solely by our editorial team.
  • Equipment fee: None
  • Service fees: Starts at $30.95 per month (for annual plan)
  • Connectivity: Uses cellular signal
  • Use case: In-home
On LifeFone's Website
Our Expert Review

LifeFone has been a trusted name in the medical alert system market for over 40 years, dedicating itself to providing individuals access to care in the event of an emergency. With no equipment fee and just a $5 monthly subscription cost for fall detection, plus a generous range of 1,300 feet, this may be a solid option for people looking for an affordable, at-home personal safety device. However, during testing, the response time was extremely prolonged, which should be considered prior to purchase.

Pros & Cons
  • No equipment fees
  • Simple design
  • Comparatively high coverage range for an in-home system
  • Features nearly instant setup
  • Fall detection required stillness for about 30 seconds after falls
  • Call quality seemed to vary greatly by agent, according to our testing experience
  • Additional buttons must be purchased as accessories
Our Experience With LifeFone At-Home Cellular With Fall Detection

From a usability perspective, the LifeFone At-Home Cellular base unit immediately impressed Forbes Health testers with its heavy-duty design and large emergency button that features a nice color contrast for users with low vision. The included pendant also offers some nice accessibility perks, such as a magnetic breakaway lanyard that may be easy for most users to attach and detach, even in the case of limited dexterity.

We found the fall detection feature to function well compared to some other devices. Standing-position falls were detected 33% of the time, though it did require about 30 seconds of immobility to trigger a response. While this may be intended to reduce false positives, an alert may not be triggered unless a fall completely incapacitates the wearer. The pendant failed to detect seated falls, so those who use a wheelchair or mobility scooter may not want to rely on the LifeFone At-Home Cellular’s fall detection specifically.


Best Medical Alert System for Large Homes

Medical Guardian MGHome Cellular

Medical Guardian MGHome Cellular
health-logo-v2.svg
4.0
All ratings are determined solely by our editorial team.
  • Equipment fee: $149.95
  • Service fees: Starts at $34.95 per month (for annual plan)
  • Connectivity: Uses cellular signal, Wi-Fi
  • Use case: In-home
On Medical Guardian's Website
Our Expert Review

In addition to testing Medical Guardian’s MGMini device, Forbes Health testers also reviewed the base-centric MGHome Cellular unit. Compared to the MGMini, this home-based system may work better for users who are stationary much of the time. Plus, the unit’s expansive range of 1,400 feet makes this product suitable even for users living in larger spaces.

Pros & Cons
  • Included pendant can be worn as a lanyard or wrist strap
  • Water resistance enhances wearer’s security in the shower
  • Features the farthest range for an in-home system in this ranking
  • Simple pendant pairing to base
  • Two-way communication not available through pendant
  • Unit had to be reset due to bugs during our testing
  • Three-month minimum contract required
Our Experience With Medical Guardian MGHome Cellular

Generally speaking, the MGHome has the same strong industrial design offered by many of the at-home devices Forbes Health tested. It has the added benefit of raised Braille on its emergency button, which is a relatively uncommon feature among similar devices. A light surrounds the emergency button to help it stand out.

Medical Guardian MGHome Cellular features somewhat effective fall detection, according to our product testing. Though the device was prone to false positives when dropped, it detected standing-position falls with a success rate of 33%. The device didn’t detect seated falls, however.

During testing, the base station failed to connect to a call at one point, which required a full reset of the unit, and an agent followed up to confirm our tester’s safety once the device was operational.


Best Medical Alert Device With No Monthly Fee

Apple Watch Series 10

Apple Watch Series 10
health-logo-v2.svg
4.0
All ratings are determined solely by our editorial team.
  • Equipment fee: Starting at $399
  • Service fees: None
  • Connectivity: Cellular signal, Wi-Fi and GPS
  • Use case: In-home and mobile
On Amazon
Our Expert Review

Apple has hung its hat on leveraging the Apple Watch as a personal safety device for years, with the added benefit of not charging users a monthly fee for medical alert features. As far back as 2018, the iPhone maker has been advertising the fall detection features of its companion watch. Being such a popular wearable product that many already have access to, we were equally impressed that it doesn’t charge a monthly fee for its medical alert features, including initiating an emergency call and reaching out to emergency contacts.

Pros & Cons
  • Wi-Fi and cellular connections ensure functionality at home and on the go
  • Stores emergency contacts to function within a local support network
  • Press to dial 911 is easily achieved but difficult to accidentally trigger
  • Step tracking, heart rate and respiratory rate can also be monitored
  • Requires iPhone and familiarity with Apple iOS platforms
  • Fall detection did not prove effective during our testing
  • Doesn’t feature dedicated operators for emergency relief
Our Experience With Apple Watch Series 10

The Apple Watch Series 10 functions well as a companion device to the iPhone. It’s sleek, has a long-lasting battery life and is water resistant, making it a great product for active individuals with an interest in Apple’s ecosystem. For those who don’t need to rely on fall detection, an Apple Watch can initiate an emergency call and reach out to emergency contacts. Just know that these actions must be performed manually and require dexterity.

In spite of being an Apple Watch feature for more than five years, its potential use case as an automatic medical alert device is disappointing, according to Forbes Health product testers. In past experience, one tester reported having personally witnessed the Apple Watch falsely detect a fall when their father jumped down from a tall height. However, the fall detection feature failed to initialize at all during Forbes Health testing for false positives, standing-position falls or seated falls. In our testing experience, the fall detection feature of the Apple Watch Series 10 shouldn’t be relied upon with certainty.


Best Voice-Activated Medical Alert Device

Amazon Alexa Emergency Assist

Amazon Alexa Emergency Assist
health-logo-v2.svg
3.8
All ratings are determined solely by our editorial team.
  • Equipment fee: Compatible with Echo devices at varying prices
  • Service fees: $5.99 per month for Amazon Prime members ($59 annually)
  • Connectivity: Wi-Fi
  • Use case: In-home
Our Expert Review

Amazon Echo, and the larger Alexa brand, are among the most recognizable names on the smart speaker market. Like the aforementioned Apple Watch, there’s a high probability one might already have an Alexa device at home. That said, many people don’t know that, for as little as $59 per year, your tiny speaker can offer some basic home security features, including Alexa Emergency Assist. Particularly for those with mobility or dexterity concerns, accessing assistance by voice is a viable alternative to wearing a pendant or watch.

Pros & Cons
  • Cost-effective subscription
  • Comparatively low equipment cost
  • Voice commands work quickly and easily
  • Functions with devices and subscriptions individuals may already have
  • Requires familiarity with smartphones and apps
  • Commands must be memorized for features to work
  • Doesn’t function without power or a Wi-Fi connection
Our Experience With Amazon Alexa Emergency Assist

While it doesn’t feature fall detection, a base station or a wearable lanyard, Alexa Emergency Assist proved to be an effective way to receive assistance. Initial setup of any Alexa device requires familiarity with smartphone apps, but those who already have one in the house can subscribe in less than 30 seconds by saying, “Alexa, subscribe to Emergency Assist” and then following a few confirmation prompts.

Once subscribed, users can contact Urgent Response agents by saying “Alexa, call for help.” The subscription also offers auto-detection features for smoke or carbon monoxide alarms and breaking glass in the event voice commands aren’t possible. Additionally, users can store up to 25 emergency contacts to contact for less severe emergencies. In our testing, all of these features worked well, and an Echo Dot proved effective in hearing commands throughout a 1,020-square-foot testing space, even with a door closed. Sound detection features worked well, prompting users with a smartphone alert and an option to call Urgent Response, if necessary.

Alexa Emergency Assist isn’t a perfect solution as a medical alert device, but it may function effectively inside the home if voice activation is possible. Considering its affordable price, it may be adequate for semi-independent individuals who don’t have difficulty with speech.


Best System With Rip Cord Activation

GetSafe Starter With Fall Detection

GetSafe Starter With Fall Detection
health-logo-v2.svg
3.3
All ratings are determined solely by our editorial team.
  • Equipment fee: $79
  • Service fees: Starts at $29.95 per month
  • Connectivity: Uses cellular signal
  • Use case: In-home and mobile
On GetSafe's Website
Our Expert Review

GetSafe is owned by Bay Alarm Medical, but its product offering differs substantially. While many of the products we’ve featured thus far focus on wearable pendants, GetSafe puts those options to the side unless you require fall detection or purchase an accessory. Instead, GetSafe Starter includes a base station plus an additional mountable base station that features a large emergency button and a rip cord for times when hitting the button isn’t possible, making it a solid option for those looking for a non-traditional unit.

Pros & Cons
  • Braille characters on base unit buttons may be useful to some
  • Features one of the least expensive monthly rates for live monitoring
  • Wall button with pull cord offers additional options for emergency response
  • Pairing the wearable with the base station was simple
  • Base station range may not be appropriate for larger homes
  • No wearable included in entry-level set
  • Some dexterity may be required to set up accessories
Our Experience With GetSafe Starter With Fall Detection

In testing, the core features of the GetSafe Starter, such as call response and effectiveness of buttons, were adequate. Accessing the main unit’s backup battery and threading the rip cord through the secondary unit requires some dexterity, but everything functions as planned with fast response times from emergency response agents. Forbes Health product testers appreciated the tactile Braille characters on the emergency and reset buttons on the base station.

The fall detection feature of the wearable help button, however, didn’t detect any false positives or genuine falls during testing. While manually pressing the wearable button prompted a call to emergency response operators, no falls were automatically detected.


Best Android Medical Alert Watch

Samsung Galaxy Watch7

Samsung Galaxy Watch7
health-logo-v2.svg
3.2
All ratings are determined solely by our editorial team.
  • Equipment fee: $249.99 (40 millimeter), $279.99 (44 millimeter)
  • Service fees: None
  • Connectivity: Uses cellular signal, Wi-Fi and GPS (version without cellular also available)
  • Use case: In-home and mobile
On Amazon
Our Expert Review

The Samsung Galaxy Watch7 is a product with potential to work well across the wide array of Android devices. It features GPS tracking, water resistance and other safety and health-tracking elements. While one safety feature includes fall detection, the watch didn’t recognize any genuine falls or false positives for falls during our testing.

Pros & Cons
  • No subscription required
  • Can be used to track workouts, sleep and other advanced fitness features
  • False positive fall detection is low
  • Emergency status can be customized to alert 911 or an emergency contact
  • Fall detection could not be triggered during testing
  • Requires Android smartphone and familiarity with Android systems
  • Manual emergency activation requires multiple presses
Our Experience With Samsung Galaxy Watch7

Forbes Health testers found similarities between the Samsung Galaxy Watch7 and Apple Watch Series 10, with the former being the preferred option for Google users and the latter better for Apple users. The Galaxy Watch7 offers many tracking features for folks leading active lives, including water resistance.

That said, the fall detection feature on the Samsung Galaxy Watch7 should not be trusted with any degree of certainty. In our testing, the device failed to pick up any false positive or intentional fall triggers. The watch can send SOS alerts if the user presses the Home button five times in rapid succession, and it can even reach out to programmed emergency contacts. As long as you have the dexterity to trigger or cancel an alert, this watch may still be a suitable alert device if fall detection isn’t required.

Most Popular is calculated from the number of times each affiliate product was selected by Forbes Health users over a six month time period.


Compare the Best Medical Alert Systems of 2026 

The table below will allow you to quickly see the final score for each medical alert system we tested, what we believe it is best used for and whether it’s designed for mobile or at-home use. 

Provider Details
Learn More

On Medical Guardian's Website

Ratings
5
forbes-health.svg
Rating
Best For

Best for Versatility
Use Case

In-home and mobile
Learn More

On Medical Guardian's Website

Learn More

On Lifestation's Website

Ratings
4.8
forbes-health.svg
Rating
Best For

Best Mobile Medical Alert System
Use Case

In-home and mobile
Learn More

On Lifestation's Website

Learn More

On Bay Alarm Medical's Website

Ratings
4.2
forbes-health.svg
Rating
Best For

Best Rugged Medical Alert Device
Use Case

In-home and mobile
Learn More

On Bay Alarm Medical's Website

Learn More

On LifeFone's Website

Ratings
4.1
forbes-health.svg
Rating
Best For

Best Home Medical Alert Device
Use Case

In-home
Learn More

On LifeFone's Website

Learn More

On Medical Guardian's Website

Ratings
4
forbes-health.svg
Rating
Best For

Best Medical Alert System for Large Homes
Use Case

In-home
Learn More

On Medical Guardian's Website

Shop Now

On Amazon

Ratings
4
forbes-health.svg
Rating
Best For

Best Medical Alert Device With No Monthly Fee
Use Case

In-home and mobile
Learn More

On Amazon

Ratings
3.8
forbes-health.svg
Rating
Best For

Best Voice-Activated Medical Alert Device
Use Case

In-home
Learn More
Shop Now

On GetSafe's Website

Ratings
3.6
forbes-health.svg
Rating
Best For

Best System With Rip Cord Activation
Use Case

In-home and mobile
Learn More

On GetSafe's Website

Shop Now

On Amazon

Ratings
3.2
forbes-health.svg
Rating
Best For

Best Android Medical Alert Watch
Use Case

In-home and mobile
Learn More

On Amazon

Product Forbes Health rating Best for Use case Learn more
5
forbes-health.svg
Rating
Best for Versatility
In-home and mobile
Learn More

On Medical Guardian's Website

4.8
forbes-health.svg
Rating
Best Mobile Medical Alert System
In-home and mobile
Learn More

On Lifestation's Website

4.2
forbes-health.svg
Rating
Best Rugged Medical Alert Device
In-home and mobile
Learn More

On Bay Alarm Medical's Website

4.1
forbes-health.svg
Rating
Best Home Medical Alert Device
In-home
Learn More

On LifeFone's Website

4
forbes-health.svg
Rating
Best Medical Alert System for Large Homes
In-home
Learn More

On Medical Guardian's Website

4
forbes-health.svg
Rating
Best Medical Alert Device With No Monthly Fee
In-home and mobile
Shop Now

On Amazon

3.8
forbes-health.svg
Rating
Best Voice-Activated Medical Alert Device
In-home
3.6
forbes-health.svg
Rating
Best System With Rip Cord Activation
In-home and mobile
Shop Now

On GetSafe's Website

3.2
forbes-health.svg
Rating
Best Android Medical Alert Watch
In-home and mobile
Shop Now

On Amazon

See More See Less

Medical Alert System Features 

The table below outlines the defining features of our top medical alert systems including fall detection, battery life, coverage range and response times.

Product Fall detection Battery life Maximum in-home coverage range Response time (according to internal product testing)
Medical Guardian MGMini
Available for an additional cost
Up to five days
N/A
50 seconds
LifeStation Sidekick Mobile
Included in Supreme package
Up to five days
N/A
49 seconds
Bay Alarm Medical SOS All-In-One 2 With Fall Detection
Included
Up to three days
600 feet
31 seconds
LifeFone At-Home Cellular With Fall Detection
Available for additional cost
Base station has a 32-hour backup battery
1,300 feet
2 minutes and 15 seconds
Medical Guardian MGHome Cellular
Available for additional cost
Base station has 32-hour backup battery
1,400 feet
32 seconds
Apple Watch Series 10
Included
36 hours
N/A
N/A
Amazon Alexa Emergency Assist
Not available
N/A
Variable
Six seconds
GetSafe Starter With Fall Detection
Available for additional cost
Base station has 32-hour back-up battery
800 feet
49 seconds
Samsung Galaxy Watch7
Included
Up to 24 hours
N/A
N/A
See More See Less
Product Fall detection Battery life Maximum in-home coverage range Response time (according to internal product testing)
Medical Guardian MGMini
Available for an additional cost
Up to five days
N/A
50 seconds
LifeStation Sidekick Mobile
Included in Supreme package
Up to five days
N/A
49 seconds
Bay Alarm Medical SOS All-In-One 2 With Fall Detection
Included
Up to three days
600 feet
31 seconds
LifeFone At-Home Cellular With Fall Detection
Available for additional cost
Base station has a 32-hour backup battery
1,300 feet
2 minutes and 15 seconds
Medical Guardian MGHome Cellular
Available for additional cost
Base station has 32-hour backup battery
1,400 feet
32 seconds
Apple Watch Series 10
Included
36 hours
N/A
N/A
Amazon Alexa Emergency Assist
Not available
N/A
Variable
Six seconds
GetSafe Starter With Fall Detection
Available for additional cost
Base station has 32-hour back-up battery
800 feet
49 seconds
Samsung Galaxy Watch7
Included
Up to 24 hours
N/A
N/A
See More See Less

Medical Alert System Pricing 

The table below outlines prices associated with our top medical alert systems, including equipment fees, service fees and additional fall detection and activation fees.

Product Equipment fee Service fee Fall detection fee Activation fee
Medical Guardian MGMini
$149.95
Starts at $39.95 per month
$10 per month
$0
LifeStation Sidekick Mobile
$0
Starts at $42.95 per month
Included in Supreme package at $58.95 per month
$99.95
Bay Alarm Medical SOS All-In-One 2 With Fall Detection
$189
$44.95 per month for package with fall detection
Included
$0
LifeFone At-Home Cellular With Fall Detection
$0
Starts at $30.95 per month for annual plan
$5 per month
$0
Medical Guardian MGHome Cellular
$149.95
Starts at $34.95 per month for annual plan
$10 per month
$0
Apple Watch Series 10
Starts at $399
$0
Included
$0
Amazon Alexa Emergency Assist
Compatible with Echo devices at varying prices
$5.99 per month for Amazon Prime members
N/A
$0
GetSafe Starter With Fall Detection
$79
$29.95 per month
$10 per month
$0
Samsung Galaxy Watch7
Starts at $249.99
$0
Included
$0
See More See Less
Product Equipment fee Service fee Fall detection fee Activation fee
Medical Guardian MGMini
$149.95
Starts at $39.95 per month
$10 per month
$0
LifeStation Sidekick Mobile
$0
Starts at $42.95 per month
Included in Supreme package at $58.95 per month
$99.95
Bay Alarm Medical SOS All-In-One 2 With Fall Detection
$189
$44.95 per month for package with fall detection
Included
$0
LifeFone At-Home Cellular With Fall Detection
$0
Starts at $30.95 per month for annual plan
$5 per month
$0
Medical Guardian MGHome Cellular
$149.95
Starts at $34.95 per month for annual plan
$10 per month
$0
Apple Watch Series 10
Starts at $399
$0
Included
$0
Amazon Alexa Emergency Assist
Compatible with Echo devices at varying prices
$5.99 per month for Amazon Prime members
N/A
$0
GetSafe Starter With Fall Detection
$79
$29.95 per month
$10 per month
$0
Samsung Galaxy Watch7
Starts at $249.99
$0
Included
$0
See More See Less

Medical Alert System Tech Specs 

The table below outlines the tech specs associated with our best medical alert systems. 

Product Connectivity Ability to synch with mobile app(s)? Other health tracking features available?
Medical Guardian MGMini
Cellular signal, GPS, Wi-Fi
Yes
Yes
LifeStation Sidekick Mobile
Cellular signal, GPS, Wi-Fi
No
No
Bay Alarm Medical SOS All-In-One 2 With Fall Detection
Cellular signal, GPS, Wi-Fi
Yes
No
LifeStation At-Home Cellular With Fall Detection
Cellular signal
No
No
Medical Guardian MGHome Cellular
Cellular signal, Wi-Fi
Yes
No
Apple Watch Series 10
Cellular signal, GPS, Wi-Fi
Yes
Yes
Amazon Alexa Emergency Assist
Wi-Fi
Yes
No
GetSafe Starter With Fall Detection
Cellular signal
No
No
Samsung Galaxy Watch7
Cellular signal, GPS, Wi-Fi
Yes
Yes
See More See Less
Product Connectivity Ability to synch with mobile app(s)? Other health tracking features available?
Medical Guardian MGMini
Cellular signal, GPS, Wi-Fi
Yes
Yes
LifeStation Sidekick Mobile
Cellular signal, GPS, Wi-Fi
No
No
Bay Alarm Medical SOS All-In-One 2 With Fall Detection
Cellular signal, GPS, Wi-Fi
Yes
No
LifeStation At-Home Cellular With Fall Detection
Cellular signal
No
No
Medical Guardian MGHome Cellular
Cellular signal, Wi-Fi
Yes
No
Apple Watch Series 10
Cellular signal, GPS, Wi-Fi
Yes
Yes
Amazon Alexa Emergency Assist
Wi-Fi
Yes
No
GetSafe Starter With Fall Detection
Cellular signal
No
No
Samsung Galaxy Watch7
Cellular signal, GPS, Wi-Fi
Yes
Yes
See More See Less

Why We Don’t Recommend Life Alert Systems 

Life Alert is one of the most widely recognized manufacturers of medical alert systems, thanks to the iconic “Help! I’ve fallen and I can’t get up!” television commercials. However, there are several reasons this brand didn’t make our list. 

Product information on its website is scarce. You must call the company directly to receive a free brochure and navigate the purchasing process. By speaking to two sales representatives, we learned Life Alert locks users into a three-year contract, has startup costs that can reach as high as $300, has one of the highest monthly subscription costs and doesn’t offer automatic fall detection in any capacity. 

One sales representative also misrepresented facts, suggesting Life Alert had invented fall detection technology and that its devices were “endorsed by the American Heart and National Stroke Association.” When asked to confirm this information, representatives from the American Heart Association told Forbes Health “The American Heart Association does not endorse any companies, products or services. We strictly prohibit any implication of endorsement, recommendation or superiority of one entity over another.” 

In contrast, every medical alert system manufacturer considered for our rankings was clear and upfront with product and subscription details online, making it easy for prospective users to conduct thorough research and make an informed purchasing decision. 


FEATURED PARTNER OFFER partner offer
We receive compensation from our partners for Featured Partner Offer placements. While this may influence where their products or services appear on our site, it in no way affects our ratings, which are based on thorough research, solid methodologies and expert advice. Our partners cannot pay us to guarantee favorable review of their products or services.
We receive compensation from our partners for Featured Partner Offer placements. While this may influence where their products or services appear on our site, it in no way affects our ratings, which are based on thorough research, solid methodologies and expert advice. Our partners cannot pay us to guarantee favorable review of their products or services.
Bay Alarm Medical SOS Mobile Alert Systems
Bay Alarm Medical SOS Mobile Alert Systems
  • Stay connected and safe with Bay Alarm Medical's suite of SOS Mobile medical alert systems: help button, two-way speaker, GPS tracking
  • Activate help easily with included wearable button for neck or wrist
  • Powered by 4G LTE for better coverage, faster response
  • Caregiver Tracking: real-time location, history, low battery alerts
  • Long battery life, water-resistant design.
On Bay Alarm's Website

How Do Medical Alert Systems Work? 

A medical alert system, also known as a personal emergency response system (PERS) or a medical emergency response system, enables a person to connect to medical help quickly in the event of a health emergency. Most systems include a wearable transmitter device, such as necklaces, bracelets or smartwatches, that feature an easily accessible emergency button and a speaker for quick connection to a trained medical response operator. 

If you have a medical concern or emergency, press the help button on your medical alert system. The device sends a signal to an emergency response expert. Often, the operator will connect you with the family member, caregiver or friend listed in your contact information, notifying them that you need help. In the event of a true medical emergency, they help dispatch an ambulance, the police or the local fire department to your home. 

“Medical alert systems offer a critical lifeline, providing safety and reassurance for older adults and their loved ones by ensuring immediate access to help in emergencies,” says Jason Garbarino, a registered nurse and Forbes Health Advisory Board member. “These systems empower individuals with functional mobility concerns to remain active and age in place with confidence.” 

Who Is a Medical Alert System For? 

According to Eve Pennie, M.D., a general practitioner and an epidemiologist at the Texas Department of State Health Services, individuals in the following demographics may benefit from using a medical alert system with fall detection: 

  • Older adults, especially those living independently 
  • Individuals with neurological or musculoskeletal disorders that affect balance 
  • Those recovering from surgery 
  • Anyone taking medications that may cause dizziness 
  • Caregivers seeking real-time confirmation that a family member is safe 

Medical alert systems are most often used by individuals who have an increased risk of falling. Older adults are the largest population of medical alert system users, especially those living alone. Over 30% of people over the age of 65 fall each year, and nearly half of this group experiences recurrent falls.

While a medical alert system cannot prevent a fall or subsequent injury, it can help the person access emergency services for much quicker assistance. In addition to a manual emergency button, many systems offer automatic fall detection, sensing when the user falls and notifying emergency services shortly thereafter. 


Types of Medical Alert Systems 

In-Home Medical Alert Systems 

In-home medical alert systems typically feature two components: 

  • A stationary base device that contains a speaker and microphone that connects the user to the company’s call center. These devices use either a landline connection or a cellular connection. 
  • A wearable element, such as a pendant or bracelet, with a button the user can press to activate the base device in the event of an emergency. The button’s range of use, meaning the maximum distance it can be from the base device to still activate a call when pressed, varies significantly from product to product. 

Mobile Medical Alert Systems 

Mobile medical alert systems use cellular service and GPS technology to help the user connect with the call center both inside and outside. Most of these units are all-in-one devices of varying sizes and efficiency. Typically, the more compact the device or the more features it offers, the shorter its battery life, making frequent charging important. 


Key Features of Medical Alert Systems 

Activity Monitoring 

Similar to automatic fall detection, this feature tracks the user’s movement. It notifies family members and friends if their loved one hasn’t shown signs of movement for an extended period. 

Medication Reminders 

Some medical alert systems offer medication reminders. These scheduled notifications can help keep aging adults compliant with the care plan prescribed by their health care professionals. 

According to a recent Forbes Health survey of 2,000 U.S. adults conducted by OnePoll, respondents value many of the features offered by modern-day medical alert system providers. However, three in particular stand out among the rest: features like activity monitoring and medication reminders (49%), GPS or cellular connectivity for 24/7 assistance (44%) and extras like voice-activated wall buttons and lock boxes (43%).

Live 24/7 Monitoring 

To get the most protective value from a medical alert system, opt for one that offers live 24/7 monitoring. That way, no matter when you have a medical concern and press your emergency button for help, you’ll always be connected with a live emergency response agent. 

Automatic Fall Detection 

Typically for an additional monthly fee, medical alert systems offer automatic fall detection. As its name suggests, this feature automatically notifies the call center when your wearable device senses—using technology like accelerometers and processors—that you had a fall and don’t move for a period of time after the fall. It’s designed to help in the event of a serious fall that renders the user unconscious, unable to press their help button manually or unable to communicate verbally with the emergency response expert at the call monitoring center. 

Wall Buttons 

Many medical alert systems allow you to purchase additional wall buttons for the higher-risk areas of your home, such as the bathroom, kitchen and stairwells. Just like a wearable pendant, when pressed they send a signal to the base station, which communicates with the call center. Wall buttons are useful for people who forget to wear or dislike wearing their devices. 

Lockboxes 

Some medical alert system makers encourage you to add a lockbox to your device purchase. It’s intended to hold an extra key for emergency responders so they don’t have to break down a locked door to come assist in an emergency event. The location and access of your lockbox is often noted in your profile with the medical alert system, so the call center employee can share those details with emergency responders when necessary. 

Water-Resistant Wearables 

If you want to be able to keep the wearable component of your medical alert system on your person or nearby while bathing or showering, it’s important for the device to hold up well to water and humidity. 

GPS Tracking 

Medical alert systems that offer live location tracking via GPS may be helpful for active seniors and those with memory loss. These systems are meant to alert family members directly and quickly of their loved one’s locations. 

Cellular Connection 

While there are many medical alert systems that still operate exclusively through landline connections inside the home, it’s no secret that landline use has decreased in recent years. Plus, landline systems only provide protection within the range of the connected base station. 

Because cellular connections operate across much of the world, anyone wearing a medical alert device with a cellular connection has access to their security network from anywhere most cell phones function. Cellular connectivity is especially helpful for mobile medical alerts that have two-way communication because users can quickly speak to dedicated emergency response operators while on the go. That said, as pervasive as cellular connectivity may be, the technology may perform less well in remote or rural areas. 

In-Home Range 

When using an in-home medical alert device with a base station, cellular or landline alike, usability range comes into play. Home-based medical alert systems typically have an operational range between 800 to 1,400 feet away from their respective base stations.

As such, buyers working under these constraints should think about the size of their living space as well as where the base station will be placed. Those living in larger houses may want to prioritize range for maximum security. 

Discreet Wearable Devices 

While many bulky medical alert devices still exist, designs have evolved to be quite discreet. After all, this list includes two sleek-looking smart watches capable of blending in with any outfit in any scenario. On the other hand, the MGMini is a small pendant that can be worn around the neck or clipped to a pocket or purse. In modern times, it’s possible to stay secure without calling attention to balance concerns.

Water Resistance 

For people who may be unsteady on their feet, the bathroom can be a dangerous place. That’s why it’s especially helpful that some medical alert pendants and watches have varying degrees of water resistance so they can be used while the wearer is in the shower. For example, the Apple Watch featured on this list can withstand depths up to 130 feet. That’s plenty of wiggle room to keep just about any casual wearer protected while near water. 

Bay Alarm Medical On-The-Go GPS Help Button

Bay Alarm Medical helps connect you with expert emergency response services at the touch of a button. With a variety of products to suit a wide range of lifestyles, you may find a Bay Alarm Medical Alert system that fits both your needs and budget.

Learn More

On Bay Alarm Medical's Website


How Much Do Medical Alert Systems Cost? 

Monitoring services for a medical alert system can cost as low as $14.95 per month and as much as $61.95 per month. These prices don’t necessarily include the initial cost of the equipment itself—some medical alert companies charge a one-time upfront fee for the system devices. 

In addition to upfront device fees, some medical alert system providers charge a one-time connection or installation fee required at the time of setup, and these fees can vary significantly. 

Add-on features typically come with additional charges, too. Automatic fall detection often increases a monthly bill by $10, and additional wall buttons and lockboxes can come with small add-on fees as well. If a caregiver app is available as part of the system, it may be free, though some cost a small amount to download to your smartphone

The lower end of the price spectrum typically includes the most basic medical alert system equipment and connectivity. Meanwhile, the more you spend, the more features and functionality you get, such as automatic fall detection, live location tracking, caregiver app access and more. 

Unfortunately, some medical alert system providers have less-than-transparent pricing structures. For instance, they may not lock in a subscription price when you sign up, ultimately raising rates without notice after a year of service. Others might not clearly disclose connection or activation fees until you reach the final steps of purchasing a system and enrolling in a monitoring subscription service.

How To Save Money on Medical Alert Systems 

If you’re concerned about the total cost of a medical alert system, consider how much you’d spend on a system when you pay annually for the monitoring service versus paying monthly. 

Depending on the medical alert system you choose, the company may offer an annual subscription with a price that averages less monthly than a standard monthly subscription cost. You have to be comfortable paying the full amount up front, but the discount can be significant in the long term. 

Other ways to save money on medical alert systems include:

  • Use Flexible Spending Accounts (FSA) and Health Savings Accounts (HSA) to pay for qualified medical expenses, including many medical alert systems, utilizing pre-tax dollars for savings. 
  • Look for discounts on monthly fees from medical alert service providers by choosing to pay quarterly or annually. 
  • Take advantage of sales and promotions, particularly during holidays such as Memorial Day and Christmas, for lower monthly rates and reduced equipment fees. 
  • Connect with your local Area Agency on Aging (AAA) for resources that help older adults maintain independence at home and in the community; find your nearest office using the Eldercare Locator tool. 

Does Insurance Cover Medical Alert Systems? 

Only a select few private insurance providers pay for medical alert systems. But in some cases, the devices can be considered tax deductible if they’re deemed “medically necessary equipment” and prescribed by a doctor. 

Does Medicare Cover Medical Alert Systems? 

Typically, traditional Medicare (Medicare Part B) doesn’t cover the purchasing or monthly subscription costs of medical alert systems because they are not usually deemed “medically necessary” durable medical equipment (DME). 

Meanwhile, some Medicare Advantage plans (Medicare Part C), which are offered through private insurance companies, may provide partial or full coverage of medical alert systems. If you’re insured by a Medicare Advantage plan, ask your provider about their coverage policies regarding medical alert systems. 


How to Choose the Best Medical Alert System for You 

The right medical alert system depends on you or your loved one’s activity levels and preferences. “I recommend sitting down and making a list of what is important to you,” says Cheryl Phillips, M.D., senior program consultant at the elder care-focused John A. Hartford Foundation and a Forbes Health Advisory Board member.

When determining which medical alert system with fall detection could be right for you or a loved one, Charles Jordan, M.D., a Florida-based orthopedic surgeon specializing in orthopedic trauma with Baptist Health Orthopedic Care, suggests considering the following factors: 

  • Whether it offers 24/7 monitoring 
  • If it includes automatic fall detection 
  • Monthly costs and contracts associated with the device 
  • Battery life 
  • Customer support quality and consumer reviews 

An individual’s fall risk level, living environment, user ability and comfort with a device should be considered, notes Patricia C. Heyn, Ph.D., founding director of the Center for Optimal Aging at Marymount University, clinical associate professor of physical medicine and rehabilitation at the University of Colorado School of Medicine and a Forbes Health Advisory Board member.

“Most importantly, whenever possible, test the device for fit, comfort and functionality before committing to a purchase,” urges Dr. Heyn. “A well-chosen system can provide peace of mind and an essential safety net—especially for older adults living alone or at higher risk of falls.” 

The above-listed options can help get you started, but seeking input from a wider support network is essential. “Once you have made your priority list, I would then share with family, caregivers or your primary care physician or provider to get additional feedback,” adds Dr. Phillips. 

Alena Hall and Jessica Lester also contributed to this piece. 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) 

Are medical alert systems worth it? 

“Yes, for many people—especially seniors or individuals with mobility issues—fall detection is worth it,” says Dr. Jordan. “It provides peace of mind, faster emergency response and can even be life-saving in situations where the person is unconscious or unable to reach a phone.” 

According to the results of a Forbes Health survey, many older adults find medical alert systems to be worth the investment. Of those who use a medical alert system for themselves or the adult they care for, 86% say the device has saved them (or the person they care for) from an incident. 

Does fall detection work without Wi-Fi? 

Most fall detection units can operate just fine without Wi-Fi, as they often rely on built-in cellular modules or landlines to sound alarms, explains Dr. Pennie. “Wi-Fi, when available, usually enhances indoor location accuracy rather than being a necessity,” she notes, adding that the device’s signal strength should be tested where it will typically be worn to ensure emergency calls can go through if ever needed. 

Do medical alert systems call family members? 

Yes, some medical alert systems ask users to provide an emergency contact list of loved ones during initial system setup. In the event that they press their emergency call button, the representative at the monitoring center responds to the user in distress and notifies those listed on their emergency contact list that their loved one called for help. Medical Care Alert is a good example of one of these systems. 

Which medical alert system does AARP recommend? 

AARP (the American Association of Retired Persons) doesn’t recommend specific medical alert system products, but rather encourages people to consider their or their loved one’s specific needs and abilities in determining which one would be most suitable. With that said, AARP members can save 15% on medical alert systems from Lifeline Medical Alert Service, as well as receive free shipping and waived activation charges for their products. 

Who responds to the system alerts, and how long does it take for someone to respond? 

Each medical alert system connects with a call center, many of which are active 24 hours a day, seven days a week. Most companies staff these call centers with emergency response experts, who are primarily responsible for answering all incoming alert calls from these systems. 

The amount of time it takes to connect with a call center employee once pressing the emergency button on your system can vary. Some systems have an average wait time of less than 30 seconds while others can take nearly three times as long. 

Once you select a medical alert system, test it a few times. These calls will give you the best sense of what to expect from the system in your area. 

How do non-monitored medical alert systems work? 

Typically, an unmonitored medical alert system requires a landline connection as opposed to cellular service. When the wearer presses the emergency button, the system either dials 911 directly or a preset personal contact via that landline connection. When a person calls 911 from a landline, the call center can immediately see their home location, which can expedite the emergency dispatch, a clear benefit to the person using the medical alert system. 

How do I know what range I need in a medical alert system? 

Generally speaking, the required range needed in a medical alert system depends on two factors: the size of your house and how often the wearer might engage in outdoor activity. Devices with lower ranges may be suitable for particularly small houses, condos or apartments. 

Do medical alerts with fall detection work in the shower or bath? 

“Some do, but not all,” says Dr. Jordan. “Always check the IP rating or product specs before use in wet environments,” he says. 

“Manufacturers recognize that bathrooms pose the greatest fall risk, so nearly every pendant or mobile unit with fall detection features has at least an IP 67 rating, indicating it can withstand a shower and brief splashes,” adds Dr. Pennie.

Sources

Footnotes

References