Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

Letter From The Editor-in-chief: Why One Big Meal Isn’t The Real Holiday Health Problem

Card image cap

Your holiday habits matter more to your health than one big Thanksgiving meal. Photo by Getty
  • One big Thanksgiving meal is unlikely to matter much for your health, and a 2020 review of 23 studies found that most studies showed significant weight gain during festive periods, suggesting the stretch around the holiday matters more than any single day.
  • Healthline’s Editor-in-Chief, Robin Hough, uses a Thanksgiving movie classic to make the case for being kinder to ourselves over the holidays, and for ditching the guilt that holiday health myths tend to fuel.
  • This column addresses common holiday health myths, from juice cleanses to punishing workouts, and offers a game plan for feeling better on Black Friday, including guidance for people managing conditions like diabetes, GERD, high blood pressure, heart failure, or kidney disease.

In the classic Thanksgiving comedy Planes, Trains and Automobiles, hapless hero Del Griffith (played by the late, great John Candy) delivers an emotional riposte to Steve Martin’s uptight ad man Neal Page that stands as a beautifully dignified defense of kindness, empathy and self-love in the face of his own perceived shortcomings.

“You want to hurt me? Go right ahead if it makes you feel any better…I could be a cold, hard cynic like you. But I don’t like to hurt people’s feelings. You think what you want about me, I’m not changing. I… I like me. My wife likes me…because I’m the real article. What you see is what you get.”

For many of us around the holidays, particularly after a night of excess, Del and Neal’s exchange could read as our internal monologue – your kinder inner voice battling the internal bully who judges your every overindulgence. The jury’s out on whether the kind voice is ever as potent as Del’s is in that moment. But it should be, because when it comes to your health around the holidays, the bully has usually got it wrong. 

Busting common Thanksgiving health myths 

The truth is, for most of us, one day of immoderation during Thanksgiving is unlikely to matter in the grand scheme. As such, you would do well to avoid the litany of holiday season health myths out there, many of which seem hell-bent on punishing you for taking a day off: 

  • Penance workouts: Exercise is great. Exercise as punishment to be feared is a setup for failure. A regular walk beats a brutal workout when you’re nursing a hangover or feeling bloated. 
  • Skipping meals to “save room” tends to backfire: You arrive ravenous and eat faster, so you may end up eating more. And if you take medication that lowers blood sugar, skipping meals can also carry its own risks.
  • Detoxes and cleanses: Your liver and kidneys already do that job, and there’s very little scientific evidence to suggest a juice cleanse does it any better.
  • The sleepy turkey myth: Turkey has roughly as much tryptophan as chicken. Neither is enough to make you sleepy. That post-dinner slump is more likely the big meal, the alcohol, and a long day, none of which make for a good night’s sleep.

Why the holiday season matters more than one meal

Like all misinformation, these kinds of medical myths are loud and tend to die hard, but they almost always trade on quick fixes that target the wrong thing. 

A 2020 review of 23 observational studies found that most showed significant weight gain during festive periods, averaging roughly a pound and a half. One of the original studies, a landmark NIH study from 2000, found that much of that weight tends to stick around. So the question is not what you ate on Thanksgiving Thursday and how quickly you can “undo the damage,” but rather whether the extended holiday season becomes a two-month period where your healthy routine goes out the window. Some things to look out for on that front:

  • Sleep: Late nights, early flights, and a disrupted routine. A lack of sleep affects mood, appetite, blood pressure, and blood sugar.
  • Alcohol: One toast is nothing. Weeks of parties through November and into December is a pattern. Alcohol disrupts sleep and can interact with common medications. If you do drink, keep it moderate and alternate with a nonalcoholic drink (water, if you’re not on a fluid limit).
  • Medication consistency: Travel and schedule changes are when doses get missed. Pack extra and set alarms for the new routine.
  • Travel and routine disruption: Hours of sitting, irregular meals, inconsistent exercise, and unfamiliar food add to everything else.
  • Stress: Hosting, money, family. Stress feeds back into sleep, blood pressure, and how well you generally look after yourself. Create a plan for mitigating as much of it as possible. 

When one day really can matter: Managing health conditions

None of this is a free pass for everyone. If you manage a health condition, you likely have less margin for error, even when talking about a single meal or a drink. Critical factors include timing, sodium intake, alcohol intake, and missed medication. A few non-exhaustive examples:

  • Diabetes: Holiday meals can often be served at times that don’t match your regular schedule, and eating too little or too much while on diabetes medication can cause blood sugar irregularities. Alcohol adds to it because the liver prioritizes processing it over maintaining steady blood sugar. Check your levels more often than usual, and talk with your doctor beforehand about whether your dose needs adjusting. 
  • GERD: Large meals stretch the stomach and raise the pressure that lets acid move upward. Alcohol and late-night eating are common triggers. Try not to eat within two to three hours of bedtime and avoid your personal trigger foods. 
  • High blood pressure and heart failure: When the heart is already struggling to pump, extra salt and fluid make the job harder. For most people, that means a puffy Friday morning. For someone with heart failure, too much salt or fluid can mean a hospital stay. Heavy drinking can also trigger “holiday heart,” an irregular heartbeat whose symptoms typically show up 12 to 36 hours after drinking, so Thursday’s cocktails can announce themselves on Friday. 
  • Kidney disease: Dietary slip-ups can cause high potassium and fluid overload, both of which can land a patient in the emergency room. Low-sodium products often replace sodium with potassium chloride, so make sure to read the labels. 
  • Heartburn or heart attack? The American Heart Association (AHA) describes heart attack discomfort as pressure, squeezing, fullness, or pain in the center of the chest that lasts more than a few minutes or comes and goes. Relief after an antacid doesn’t rule out a heart attack. If you have chest pain or pressure, don’t assume it’s heartburn. Call 911.

Whatever condition you’re managing, the move for all of them remains the same – be prepared. Check your plan with your care team before the holiday, not after, and call them if something feels off afterward.  

Your Black Friday health game plan 

Technically, feeling good on Black Friday starts on Thursday. A short and light walk after a feast can help smooth out post-meal blood sugar – the earlier the better, ideally within an hour of eating. Staying upright for a couple of hours to help with digestion, particularly if you’re prone to reflux, is also a great idea. If you’re on medication, remember to take it on time. And, at the risk of sounding prudish, and this goes for everyone: try to get to bed at a sensible hour. 

For the Friday morning: 

  • Eat a healthy breakfast: Something balanced you can keep down, like eggs and toast. A greasy breakfast won’t cure anything, despite what prevailing myths will have you believe. By morning the alcohol has left your stomach, so there’s nothing for the grease to soak up. And if you have reflux, or are watching your salt, grease is a doubly poor bet.
  • Drink water – unless your care team has told you to limit fluids, as with heart failure or kidney disease. In that case, follow your plan. Otherwise, H2O is your friend. 
  • Take a 10 to 30 minute post-breakfast walk – gentle movement soon after eating may help smooth out blood sugar and ease bloating, and as little as 10 minutes counts. If it leaves you queasy, wait 10 to 15 minutes or slow down.
  • Go easy on the salt for a day or two – puffiness from a salty meal is mostly water and usually fades. If you have heart or kidney disease and notice swelling, rapid weight gain, or shortness of breath, don’t write it off as holiday bloat. Call your care team.
  • Take your medication as prescribed – don’t skip doses to “balance” the day; get back to your cadence.

Above all else, Thanksgiving is a holiday built around gratitude and kindness, so channel your inner Del Griffith and remember to be both grateful and kind, to yourself and to those around you – evidence suggests that’s also good for your health.  

Robin Hough is the Editor-in-Chief of Healthline, and in addition to this regular Letter from the Editor column, he can be found every other Wednesday in our Healthline Wellness Wire newsletter.