Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

As Valuations Rise, The ‘tipping Point’ For New Construction Is Near

Card image cap

Dave Harper

By Dave Harper

Demographics are pushing demand for seniors housing higher year by year while new construction remains limited, and investors are taking notice. This is a sector that needs new construction, and it may be coming not too far in the future.

The private-pay seniors housing category, which includes independent living, assisted living and memory care facilities, needed time to recover after the COVID-19 pandemic and the inflation that followed. Rising wages pushed up operating costs, and higher construction costs made new facilities more expensive to build. 

Now, however, as the sector moves past the challenges of the pandemic and recent inflationary pressures, seniors housing is one of commercial real estate’s most compelling stories. Rising demand and record occupancy rates, among other factors, are lifting valuations. This has spurred significant investment, and seniors housing has become a very high-conviction space.

Properties Are Filling Up

Even when investors hesitated a few years ago, the demographics were moving in the sector’s favor. Baby boomers, born between 1946 and 1964, are beginning to reach their 80s, the most common age for moving into seniors housing. The number of Americans who are 80 or older is expected to increase by about 4.6 percent a year through 2030.

Backed by that demographic trend, occupancy rates in major U.S. markets have climbed steadily for the past five years. The industry has now recovered from the sharp decline in occupancy that occurred during the COVID-19 pandemic and rent growth has been strong. 

The occupancy rate for seniors housing reached 90.1 percent in the second quarter, according to NIC MAP data that covers independent living and assisted living facilities in 99 metro areas nationally. This marks the first time since 2007 — before the Great Financial Crisis disrupted capital markets and development cycles — that this rate has topped the 90 percent benchmark. 

Some 57 of the 99 markets in the NIC MAP data set are now individually above the 90 percent occupancy mark — and 23 have climbed above 92 percent, including Boston, Jacksonville and San Francisco. Rent growth for independent living and assisted living facilities was running at a solid 4.6 percent annual pace in the second quarter. 

Even so, investors have not been ready to build new facilities, and construction has been sluggish. The supply of independent living and assisted living units grew at an annual rate of 0.4 percent in the second quarter, according to NIC MAP, and it has been trending lower for several years. The annual absorption rate for seniors housing, which is the net increase in occupied units as a percentage of the total inventory, was 2.6 percent in the second quarter. 

Stars Align for a Construction Wave

Earlier this year, the view was that significant new construction was still a few years off, but the outlook has shifted. Conversations with borrowers suggest that building could potentially accelerate much sooner. 

To date, high replacement costs and other factors have kept the economics tilted toward existing properties. Conditions vary from market to market, but it still can be 15 to 20 percent less expensive to buy existing properties than to build new products. Investors who purchase assets may see returns quickly rather than having to wait through construction and lease-up.

Indeed, construction starts are at historically low levels. Fewer than 24,000 seniors housing units were under construction in the second quarter, according to NIC MAP. This is the lowest level since 2012 and may be inadequate to keep pace with demand. 

But multiple factors are making the math for new construction increasingly attractive. Occupancy rates and valuations need to climb further before a significant amount of new construction begins, but the tipping point may be getting closer. 

Seeing the occupancy rate cross 90 percent nationwide, and top 92 percent in some markets, will likely attract developers’ attention. Few expect construction costs to decline, but even if they increase modestly, operating income is likely to grow faster. 

With a lag of about two years between groundbreaking and the opening of a new project, the momentum in occupancy and valuations will likely persist even as new construction starts to pick up.

Cap Rates Contract

Strong occupancy rates and rising rents for seniors housing are reflected in capitalization rates that have been declining for several years. Cap rates are a real estate industry metric that looks at how much investors are willing to pay for a property relative to its net operating income. 

We have seen recent trades on quality properties occurring at cap rates in the low 5 percent range, providing another indication that investors are becoming more willing to pay up for desirable properties. 

Investor interest in existing seniors housing properties remains strong. Private equity firms are buying, as are the largest real estate investment trusts. The lending market is very active. Private credit, bank loans and agency lending via Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac is flowing into the space, resulting in a favorable environment for investors. 

Capital One has been lending and arranging financing in this space for more than 30 years — through the COVID-19 pandemic, the recent spike in inflation, the Great Financial Crisis of 2007-2009, and many other challenging periods.

Through it all, demand for investment has been growing, along with the population of older Americans. With occupancy rates and valuations rising, most are clearly focused on the key trends. Investor interest is strong, and fresh capital appears to be coming into the seniors housing sector. 

Ultimately, stronger returns spawning rising valuations and investor interest will likely help jump-start new construction. When a significant development wave comes, the additional supply is ultimately what is expected to keep costs in check for seniors. 

The demographics are no longer hypothetical, occupancy rates are rising and capital has returned. To help meet the needs of an aging population, developers will need to build. 


Dave Harper is head of Capital One’s healthcare real estate seniors housing team, where he oversees business development across the sector. Harper has closed more than $25 billion in healthcare transactions over the past 20 years.

This article originally appeared in the August-September 2026 issue of Seniors Housing Business magazine.

The post As Valuations Rise, the ‘Tipping Point’ for New Construction Is Near appeared first on Seniors Housing Business.