Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

Car Insurance Rates Are Leveling Off, So Why Are You Still Overpaying?

Card image cap

Car insurance rates are finally leveling off, but after five years of increases that outpaced inflation and income growth, many drivers are still paying too much. Rob Bhatt, senior writer and licensed insurance agent at LendingTree, explains what drives your premium, from repair costs and theft to pandemic-era driving habits.

Jeffrey Snyder, Broadcast Retirement Network

Rob, it’s great to see you. Thanks for joining us on the program this morning.

Rob Bhatt, LendingTree

Thank you. It’s my pleasure.

Jeffrey Snyder, Broadcast Retirement Network

And look, we always enjoy talking to our colleagues at LendingTree and we certainly appreciate all the great work that y’all are doing to cover insurance and all the different things that are going on, all the different products out there. I wanted to ask you, the reason for reaching out to you is about car insurance and we can talk about the impact of speeding. No one speeds these days.

The impact of speeding on car insurance. But I wanted to get the lay of the land from your perspective and LendingTree’s perspective in terms of the car insurance marketplace. Are costs going up, going down, staying the same?

Where are things today?

Rob Bhatt, LendingTree

You know, it’s a really good question. What we’re seeing today is rates stabilizing, but it may not seem that way because for the past five years or so, we’ve seen rates spike. Spike it at levels that have exceeded inflation, have exceeded income growth for most people.

And so right now, if you look at how much you’re paying for car insurance today compared to how much you may have been paying five years ago, chances are it’s eating up a bigger share of your household budget, which is creating financial hardship for some people. This ranges from slight inconvenience to major cuts and other areas of household expenses just to afford car insurance.

Jeffrey Snyder, Broadcast Retirement Network

So when that rates, and I realize, and I think the audience does as well, that insurance is kind of regulated at the state level. But what goes into that premium that ultimately we’re charged? So if I drive a Mazda, or I should say my wife drives the Mazda every day, but what goes into making up that premium cost that we see, whether it’s gone up, down, or stayed the same?

Rob Bhatt, LendingTree

You know, it’s a shared cost. And insurance companies look at the cost of insuring all its customers. And, you know, this includes some factors like, you know, how likely people are to get into accidents.

I mean, if you have a hundred people, you know, insurance works under the law of large numbers. So if you have a hundred customers, insurance companies know that one of those people is going to get into a car accident. They just don’t know which one it’ll be.

And that’s the same from the consumer end. And you’re buying insurance. You’re kind of with a group of other people, and you’re all paying for this thing.

You know, one of you is going to need it over the course of a year. You just don’t know who it’ll be. And so when insurance companies set their rate, they look at their customers.

They kind of try to figure out how much risk they’re taking, what the likelihood is of different people being that person who’s going to get into an accident. And they kind of set their rates with the idea that they’re going to charge everyone an amount that’s going to allow them to afford to pay for the car repairs and the injuries that that one person in the group is going to require. And so, you know, that’s kind of on the basic level.

And then when you get more deeper into it, they assign a risk. They put different drivers into different risk categories and set your rate based on how likely they think you are to be that person or to be those people, be that group that is going to cause an accident.

Jeffrey Snyder, Broadcast Retirement Network

Yeah, really good point. I would imagine, you know, they probably also factor in what it costs to do the repairs, getting parts, because insurance, I guess, theoretically would pay for that. And I can only imagine that those parts, those repairs to do painting and, you know, having somebody who’s skilled at doing that have gone up as well.

So that’s probably all part of this. And then also theft, what vehicles are stolen more than others, I think would probably play a factor too, right?

Rob Bhatt, LendingTree

Of course. All of these areas with higher car theft rates tend to see higher car insurance rates. You know, another thing, if you have full coverage car insurance, then your car insurance is going to cover flood, blood damage, forest fires.

Areas with severe weather, particularly with hurricane risks, often see higher car insurance rates because there’s the greater risk of flooding. Medical costs are another big factor. What we really saw in the first half of this decade as a combination of factors where after the pandemic, you know, during the pandemic, people got used to driving on uncrowded roads.

And in the process of that, they got more comfortable speeding or using their cell phone while driving, texting while driving. And then when the shutdowns ended, a lot of these people who developed these bad habits were back on crowded roads. So we saw an increase in car accidents.

Unfortunately, this coincided. I mean, that’s never a good thing. But what made it particularly difficult was that this coincided with a time when inflation was surging.

And so you had a situation where insurance companies had to pay to repair or replace more cars. And the costs of these repairs and replacement for each one had gone up. And so that had this compounding impact on the amounts that insurance companies were paid to settle car insurance claims.

And of course, car accident injuries are also another factor in that. Those costs always go up. And so these are the types of costs where when they go up, insurance companies raise their rates to cover them.

It’s that shared cost of covering the cost that, you know, again, we don’t know who the people are who are going to get into an accident. We just know someone will. And in this case, when more people were getting into accidents, it was raising costs for everyone.

I think we’re all still feeling sticker shock from that. But if there’s any good news, when we look at rate increases nationwide, they appear to have leveled off for the time being. Now, how long they stay leveled off remains to be seen because, you know, just as we’ve seen in the recent past, things can change very quickly.

Jeffrey Snyder, Broadcast Retirement Network

Yeah. We have to say when the accidents people get into, let me, you brought up speeding and I wanted to, in particular, ask you about that. So if I, I guess in the old days, I was known for a little bit of a heavy foot, maybe not so much today.

But if you do get caught ticketed, what’s the material, what could you see as a factor? How would that factor into would your costs go up significantly? Because theoretically, the faster you go, you’re breaking the law.

One, but two, I would imagine the risk of getting into an accident goes up and, you know, that’s, that’s not a good thing.

Rob Bhatt, LendingTree

Yeah. You know, a speeding ticket, we’ve seen it. We’ve seen this be in the 15 to 25% range.

It kind of depends on, on the how fast you’re going. You know, there, there are different levels of speeding. If you’re within 10 miles of the speeding limit and 10 miles per hour of the speed limit, it’s not as severe, but if you’re more than 10 miles over the speed limit, then you’ll get a bigger ticket.

And then if you’re more than 25 to 30 miles per hour over the speed limit, then you’ll, you’ll get a big ticket. And, and with some of those higher speed extreme speeding violations, you may not even be eligible to say, go to a traffic school or take a driver improvement class to keep that, that ticket off your record. So, you know, it definitely depends on the, on the nature of the severity of the speeding violation, you know, with, with, with a lot of, in a lot of States, if you’re, you know, within a reasonable amount over the speed limit, 10, 15, you know, some States up to 25 miles per hour within the speeding limit, you can go to a traffic school or take a driver improvement class.

And that helps you keep the speeding ticket off your record. And that will save you money in the long run. So that’s something I always recommend to people when available, but you know, otherwise you’re looking at your rate going up 15, 20, 25% for maybe two to three years, depending on where you live and your insurance and how your insurance company treats speeding.

Jeffrey Snyder, Broadcast Retirement Network

Yeah. I mean, that’s obviously it’s not a, it’s not a good thing, especially in today’s environment. You mentioned, I know you mentioned that the, maybe the rate of increase of car insurance has kind of leveled off.

That’s a good thing. Yeah. I mean, I think it’s a good thing to be able to see what’s going to happen in the future years when they look at the, the, I guess, the insurance pool and see behavior, but how do I find not me in particular, but how does the audience find the best deal?

I would imagine shopping is still the best way to go. How, how, how do you, how best can you shop for car insurance and what, what should you be looking at? Because sometimes it’s hard to compare and contrast the different products that are out there.

Rob Bhatt, LendingTree

Yeah. It could be confusing. I mean, every company will tell you they have cheap rates, but you know, they don’t have cheap rates.

No one company has cheap rates for everybody. It varies by customer. And so you really have to get quotes.

It’s good to get quotes from a few different companies when you shop. And that way you can kind of see, you can kind of make sure you’re not overpaying, see which company can give you, give you the best deal. Some companies have different discounts than other companies.

And so, you know, say, say you’re with company a, and they give you a pretty good rate, but company B might give you a good rate plus have a discount for your profession. Some companies, you know, Geico, for example, has discounts for federal employees and farmers has discounts for engineers and doctors. And, you know, some different companies have, other companies have discounts for teachers.

For example, these are some of the things you, you discover when you shop around and get quotes from a few different companies. You know, for example, if you visit LendingTree, you could fill out one form and a few different insurance companies will contact you. That’s one way to shop.

Independent, independent insurance agents are another good way to shop because they can get you quotes from multiple companies at once. With some companies, you know, some of these bigger companies like say a State Farm and Allstate and some of these others, they, they have, they, they use captive agents. These are exclusive agents who sell you insurance from their company, but only their company.

So if you’re contacting a company with a captive agent, they’re also known as exclusive agents. Then you have to contact multiple companies separately because each one can only give you a quote from their company. When you talk to an independent agent, they can give you quotes from a few different companies, just not, just not a State Farm or Allstate, but they’ll get you like a Travelers Progressive.

If you’re in certain parts of the country, you can also get like a, an eerie quote from an independent agent. Auto Owners is another good company. And so, you know, it’s good to, it’s good to definitely put out your feelers, ask your friends who they use and, and really be active in the shopping market to, to find a way to save some money because the savings can add up.

I mean, we’ve, we’ve, we’ve surveyed people and we found that some people knocked off a couple of hundred bucks off their annual insurance rate. And so that’s something that definitely helps your household budget.

Jeffrey Snyder, Broadcast Retirement Network

That’s definitely material. And, and how, you know, when you’re doing that shopping, I would imagine that the different, you know, there’s different thresholds for the different, you know, collision and things like that. You really gotta be, you gotta really know what you’re looking at.

Right. I mean, that’s where that comparative tool you were talking about at LendingTree or going through an independent agent, they got to put it in front of you and say, well, if you keep all things the same in terms of coverage, here’s what your premium is going to be. And then, right.

I mean, that’s that’s really why that’s the benefit of doing something across. You’ve got to be, look at the coverages to make sure you’re comparing apples to apples.

Rob Bhatt, LendingTree

Definitely good to look at your quotes and, you know, maybe just take a few minutes to familiarize yourself with your, with your current policy. Every policy comes with a, it’s called the declarations page. It’s a, it’s sometimes called a policy summary and it’ll show what your coverages are.

And so you kind of look at that and, you know, maybe even ask your, your current agent about it to explain anything to you if you have questions. And, and then when you get quotes from other companies, you can ask them to give you the same or comparable coverages so that you are covering, you are comparing apples to apples. I mean, it can be confusing and, and, and each company has slightly different ways of, of offering things or naming things.

And so it kind of, you know, you want, you want to ask them to, to help make it as simple as possible for you. You know, the other, other thing to keep in mind is, you know, you don’t have to feel bad about asking for quotes or even ask for multiple quotes. Insurance companies expect you to shop around and compare quotes.

And so, you know, they’re not going to be offended if you ask them for quotes and they’re surely not going to be offended if you need a little more time because you have questions or, or you want to see multiple options. And in fact, you know, that’s a sign of good service. If your insurance agent or an insurance company, if you’re contacting them online is being patient and making, making it easy for you to understand and be responsive to you, then that’s, that’s a good sign of good service.

And that’s a good sign that there’ll be there for you if you do have to file a claim.

Jeffrey Snyder, Broadcast Retirement Network

Yeah. Really, really good point. Because if the shoe were on the other, other foot, I’m sure they would not hesitate to drop you if it were a very risky driver and then you’d be shopping anyway.

Hey Rob, we’re going to have to leave it there. Really impressive analysis, great resources as always at LendingTree. And look, thank you so much for joining us.

We look forward to having you back on the program again very soon.

Rob Bhatt, LendingTree

It’s my pleasure. I would love to talk to you anytime.