He Moves $400,000 Of His 401(k) Into Its Stable Value Fund At 63. One Point Of Lost Interest Costs Him $4,000 A Year
The post He Moves $400,000 of His 401(k) Into Its Stable Value Fund at 63. One Point of Lost Interest Costs Him $4,000 a Year appeared first on 24/7 Wall St..
A 63-year-old who moves $400,000 of his 401(k) into the plan’s stable value fund is buying one thing: a interest rate. That rate is his entire return, and the insurer sets it. A one-point change in the rate moves his income by $4,000 a year, and his statement never shows it as a line item.
That risk now has a dollar figure. On Nov. 4, 2026, participants in Nationwide’s own 401(k) asked a federal court in Ohio to initially approve a $12.9 million settlement over the spread Nationwide Life Insurance Company earned on the plan’s Guaranteed Fund. The class covers roughly 83,000 to 85,000 people.
How a Buried Spread Lowered Nationwide’s 401(k) Rate
Plaintiffs alleged that the 401(k) version of the fund paid a lower interest rate than the identical investment held in Nationwide’s pension plan. They also claimed excess fees, which they called the “spread,” were buried inside the crediting rate. Nationwide denied liability and said the fund produced competitive returns.
Many participants were exposed. As of 2020, 86% of participants held part of their account in the fund, totaling $1.75 billion, or 30% of plan assets.
In a general account product, the insurer invests your money. It keeps the difference between what its portfolio earns and what it credits you, and reports only the net rate. A spread never shows up on a fee disclosure because it is never charged as a fee.
One Lost Point Costs About $70,000 Before His First RMD
Because he was born in 1963, his required minimum distributions (RMDs) don’t start until age 75, and his first RMD year is 2038. That leaves 12 years of compounding.
Take two example rates. At 4%, $400,000 grows to about $640,000 by 75. At 3%, it reaches about $570,000.
That one point costs roughly $70,000 before he takes a single distribution.
Market benchmarks show how wide the gap can get. One large plan’s stable value fund credited 3.2% annualized in October, while the 10-year Treasury yield stood at 5.2%. On $400,000, the difference between those two rates is about $8,000 a year.
Stable value funds smooth their returns, so interest rates can trail market rates by 12 to 24 months. Beating the national average 12-month CD at 1.8% shows very little about whether the rate is fair.
Medicare Makes Every Withdrawal More Expensive
Every dollar in that fund eventually comes out as ordinary income under 26 U.S.C. § 402(a). Withdrawals stack on top of Social Security.
Once income passes the statutory thresholds, up to 85% of benefits become taxable under 26 U.S.C. § 86(a)(2). A retiree in the 22% bracket who also triggers Medicare surcharges can face an effective marginal rate near 40%.
Medicare’s 2027 figures, announced on November 17, raise the standard Part B premium to $209.40 a month.
A single filer with modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) over $112,000 pays $293.10 for Part B plus a $15.40 Part D adjustment.
Joint filers reach that first tier above $224,000. That first step alone costs about $1,189 a year per person, or $2,378 for a couple.
Medicare sets premiums using the tax return from two years earlier, so the income he reports at 63 determines what he pays at 65.
A fair crediting rate and a planned withdrawal schedule work together, as underpaid interest reduces the balance he can draw from in his early retirement years, before RMDs start. Any withdrawals he takes without a plan raise his Medicare premiums.
Three Moves to Make Before Transferring the $400,000
- Identify the product type. Pull the fund’s fact sheet and your plan’s annual fee disclosure. Then ask the plan administrator to identify the fund. It may be a general account product with a hidden spread or a synthetic fund that holds a bond portfolio and charges a stated wrap fee. The current interest rate may trail the 10-year Treasury. If it trails by two points or more, ask the plan administrator to explain the gap in writing.
- Read the exit rules first. Many stable value funds block direct transfers into competing options such as money market funds, and some insurer contracts also restrict or delay withdrawals of the whole plan’s money. Find out how you would get out before you move six figures in.
- Map withdrawals and Roth conversions to the Medicare surcharge (IRMAA) tiers. Keep MAGI at or below $112,000 for individuals or $224,000 for couples in each year from 63 forward. If a planned conversion would push you past the first tier, a one-time projection from a fee-only advisor is worth paying for.
A stable value fund makes sense at 63 as protection against a bad market just before retirement, as long as the rate is fair. The Nationwide case shows why you should confirm that rate yourself rather than rely on the plan sponsor.
Released: 401k & IRA Tips and Answers
(sponsor) 401(k)s are powerful retirement tools. But even savvy savers can make mistakes that quietly cost you money for decades. Choosing the wrong fund, ignoring small fees nobody adds up, rollover steps done in the wrong order, the list goes on.
These sort of mistakes is exactly what 401k & IRA Tips and Answers was created to help prevent. It is a free guide from Fisher Investments on rollovers, contributions, required withdrawals and the mistakes that do the most damage to a retirement account. Learn More Here ›
The post He Moves $400,000 of His 401(k) Into Its Stable Value Fund at 63. One Point of Lost Interest Costs Him $4,000 a Year appeared first on 24/7 Wall St..
Popular Products
-
Fireproof Document Bag with Zipper Cl...$60.87$31.78 -
Acrylic Desktop File Organizer with 5...$100.99$69.78 -
Child Safety Cabinet Locks - Set of 6$83.56$41.78 -
Travel Safe Lock Box with 4-Digit Cod...$146.99$78.78 -
Dual Laser Engraver$5,068.99$3034.78