Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

Lawton Lawsuit Against State Farm Insurance Scheduled For Trial Feb. 1, 2027

Card image cap

A jury trial in the lawsuit of newly elected District Judge Neil West and his wife Lacy against State Farm Fire and Casualty Co. and Nancy Holcomb Insurance Agency is scheduled for trial in Comanche County District Court on Feb. 1, 2027.

In court documents filed in April and May of 2025, the Wests claimed that "despite its 'good neighbor' promises," State Farm is "engaged in a systematic and pervasive scheme to deny or underpay insureds throughout Oklahoma [including the Wests] for wind- and hailstorm claims." The company's denial of wind and hail storm damage claims are "unreasonable, lack true justification, and are pre-determined," and they do it "purposefully for profit and do so in bad faith."

The Wests accused Holcomb Insurance Agency of "advancing State Farm's Scheme by selling and renewing a State Farm homeowners insurance policy" to the Wests that Nancy Holcomb "knew was not worth the paper it was written on."

Holcomb "sold and renewed" the Wests' policy "knowing that State Farm never intended to provide full replacement cost coverage, regardless of the policy language, due to State Farm's 'Hail Focus initiative' that was designed and implemented to render replacement cost policies worthless through reducing indemnity payments by targeting and wrongfully denying full roof replacements … on valid wind and hail claims."

The Wests' attorneys referred to court rulings in 1988 and 2022 which decreed, "Although a party may keep absolute silence and violate no rule of equity, yet, if he volunteers to speak and to convey information which may influence the conduct of the other party, he is bound to disclose the whole truth."

Furthermore, State Farm agents "almost always fail to inspect the property to verify whether it … qualifies for the coverage stated in the policy, and is free from any defect that would negate that coverage."

Neither agent Holcomb nor State Farm "ever inspected" the Wests' home "to verify if it met State Farm's underwriting guidelines," nor did they retain a third party to perform such an inspection, the lawsuit alleges. Holcomb "procured, bound, and renewed coverage on State Farm's behalf, nonetheless."

But when a hailstorm damaged the Wests' roof on June 15, 2023, "State Farm ignored patent wind and hail damage and attributed the damage to pre-existing damage and non-covered causes of loss (wear, tear, decay, deterioration, mechanical breakdown, etc.)"

Neither Holomb nor State Farm ever advised the Wests that their property had "any defect, pre-existing damage, or other conditions that would exclude it from replacement cost coverage," the Wests assert. Additionally, if Holcomb "had identified any such condition, she would have been required to report the same" to the Wests and to State Farm, the Wests' attorneys noted.

Holcomb "set up" the Wests "as State Farm's next victim and did so knowing the Scheme would be used" against the Wests "to improperly limit coverage."

State Farm's attempt to have the Wests' lawsuit, and 10 others filed in Oklahoma County, moved to Oklahoma City's Western District federal court was denied by U.S. District Judge Scott Palk on Aug. 21, 2025. The Wests' case was remanded to Comanche County District Court, and the other 10 were sent back to Oklahoma County District Court.

In fact, Oklahoma's federal district courts have "repeatedly rejected State Farm's removal of nearly identical claims" 25 times, the Wests' attorneys pointed out, citing chapter and verse: 20 times in the Western District court, four times in the Northern District federal court in Tulsa, and once in the Eastern District federal court at Muskogee.

"It is unclear why State Farm chose to omit these cases from its Notice of Removal," the Wests' attorneys wrote in a footnote to the court. A legal requirement decrees that, "A lawyer shall not knowingly fail to disclose to the tribunal legal authority in the controlling jurisdiction known to the lawyer to be directly adverse to the position of the client…"

In a related matter, The Lawton Constitution filed an application Oct. 13 for permission to conduct electronic media coverage of the Wests' trial. State Farm opposed that application on Nov. 9, and The Constitution's attorney, Lysbeth George of Oklahoma City, responded on Nov. 13. District Judge Grant Sheperd has not yet ruled on the newspaper's application.

The Wests are represented by the Oklahoma City law firm of Whitten Burrage and the Lawton law firm of Burgess & Hightower. State Farm is represented by two attorneys from Oklahoma City and one from Los Angeles, and Holcomb is represented by Timila S. Rother of the Crowe Dunlevy law firm in Oklahoma City.

___

Mike W. Ray is a fifth-generation, award-winning journalist who has more than 55 years' experience covering municipal, county, state and federal government in Oklahoma and Texas. He can be reached at mike.ray@swoknews.com.

Distributed by Newsbank, inc.

The post Lawton lawsuit against State Farm Insurance scheduled for trial Feb. 1, 2027 appeared first on Insurance News | InsuranceNewsNet.