Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

[nj] Debt Collector Failed To Appear, Case Was Dismissed, Then Rescheduled After Their Attorney Showed Up An Hour Late. Is This Legal?

Card image cap

[NJ] Debt collector failed to appear, case was dismissed, then rescheduled after their attorney showed up an hour late. Is this legal?

Location: New Jersey, USA

I'm a self-represented defendant in a New Jersey Special Civil Part debt-collection lawsuit. I'm hoping someone familiar with NJ civil procedure can weigh in.

Here's what happened:

  • I appeared on time for my virtual court hearing, prepared to negotiate or proceed with trial.
  • The plaintiff's attorney failed to appear. The court representative expressly announced that my case was dismissed and excused me from the proceeding.
  • I called the courthouse afterward to inquire whether the dismissal was with or without prejudice.
  • Later, I received a missed call from the Judiciary with no voicemail. I returned the call but received no explanation and was promised a callback that never came.
  • That afternoon, I received an email and discovered through the court portal that my case had instead been adjourned for two weeks.
  • When I contacted the courthouse again, I learned that the plaintiff's attorney had arrived nearly an hour late and was granted an adjournment without my knowledge or an opportunity to object.
  • During the same morning's proceedings, I personally witnessed default paperwork being initiated against defendants who failed to appear.

I have already submitted a written settlement proposal to the plaintiff's law firm, which went unanswered. I've also prepared an objection and requested guidance on obtaining judicial review.

My questions:

  1. Can a court announce that a case is dismissed, expressly excuse the defendant, and then reverse course when the plaintiff's attorney appears late?
  2. Does my reliance on the court representative's dismissal announcement have any legal significance?
  3. Should I challenge this through a written request for judicial review or a formal motion?

I understand courts have discretion to grant adjournments, but I find this apparent disparity in treatment fundamentally unjust. I'm not asking for preferential treatment, just procedural fairness.

I'd appreciate insight from anyone familiar with New Jersey civil procedure.

submitted by /u/Antique-Anybody-1217
[link] [comments]