Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

Being Refused A Water Account By City Hall

Card image cap

Location: Greenfield, CA.

I have recently accepted a job in this area and had to start work before finalizing a lease. I found a decent apartment that feels safe, is in my price range, and convenient for my commute in Greenfield. I was accepted and paid my deposit, and simply need to give my property manager my water and electricity account numbers before getting my keys.
My PG&E account was easy to set up online, but the only way to have water service at this complex is through City Hall. So I went to city hall, said I wanted to set up water service for my new apartment.
The clerk told me they need my physical social security card and drivers license to start service. Now, I haven’t had a physical SS card in some time. I haven’t needed one…this may sound stupid but any time it’s been requested, there’s always been an alternative document I can provide. I’ve rented a house and set up utilities in other cities in California, and had multiple jobs, and have never been refused ANYTHING on the basis of not having a physical social security card. No one’s ever batted an eye when I provided something else.

I have spoken to a clerk who claims her supervisor is unavailable. Conveniently both times I’ve come in, the supervisor “actually just left”. I waited through the weekend to come back this morning at 10am and apparently “juuuust missed her!” But the clerk could speak on her behalf to say that there are no exceptions to their policy. Allegedly they “need a social card in case the account isn’t paid, to send the information to collections”.
I have explained I do have a social security number, but do not have the physical card. I offered my original birth certificate as well as my federal tax return showing my full name, social security number, and an address that matches the one on my drivers license. This, from my limited knowledge, should be considered proof of my social security number. I have been refused service unless I can provide a physical social security card. Not proof of a social security number. The physical card is specifically required, no exceptions whatsoever.

Is this legal? Or am I being pushed around by people who are hoping I don’t know any better? They didn’t cite any city ordinance or law as an explanation, but maybe one is in place, although I haven’t been able to find any such information online yet. Is it possible the city has been able to get away with a possibly unofficial yet enforced policy that’s screwing people over? Or are they treating me differently than their other customers? If it’s not legal, what do I do?

I am seriously considering asking for my deposit back and finding a different apartment to rent which doesn’t require me to deal with Greenfield City Hall because I can’t bear to live in this hotel room for the two weeks it’ll take to get my new SS card here. I’ll go crazy and shave my head or something.

TLDR: refused a water account by City Hall on basis of not having a physical SS card, even after offering proof of SSN and here questioning if refusal of services is legal.

submitted by /u/Longjumping-Belt-608
[link] [comments]