Home Sale - Sewer Issues - Contract Breach
Location: Connecticut
We're under contract to purchase a house in Connecticut and have encountered a significant dispute with the seller over sewer repairs. I'm interested in perspectives on whether the seller would be in breach of contract if he refuses to complete the repairs or close.
Background and timeline:
1. Original home inspection
During our initial home inspection, the sewer camera identified serious problems with the existing cast-iron sewer line, including standing water, an obstruction, and two large cracks. The camera could not advance beyond approximately 10 feet.
We negotiated with the seller, who agreed to repair the sewer line at his expense. This obligation was specifically incorporated into our signed purchase contract.
2. Seller performs repairs
The seller hired a plumber who replaced a section of the sewer line with PVC piping.
After the work was completed, we hired an independent sewer specialist to perform another camera inspection, as expressly permitted under our contract.
3. Post-repair inspection reveals additional problems
The inspection identified several concerning issues:
- A belly in the newly installed PVC piping where water was collecting.
- An improperly positioned sewer cleanout that made access difficult.
- The new PVC piping connected to an older section of Orangeburg pipe.
- The remaining Orangeburg pipe showed significant deterioration, including deformation, protrusions, and apparent root intrusion.
- The camera could not reach the municipal sewer connection, meaning the entire line could not be verified.
Our plumber expressed concerns about the condition of the remaining sewer line and the adequacy of the repairs.
4. Seller requests hydro jetting, revealing further problems
Rather than immediately agreeing to additional repairs, the seller independently authorized hydro jetting to clear the obstruction and allow another camera inspection.
During jetting, the improperly positioned cleanout cracked.
After jetting, the camera was able to reach the municipal sewer connection. However, the inspection still documented significant deterioration in the remaining Orangeburg piping, including protrusions, ruptures, and blockages.
Our independent sewer specialist concluded that jetting had not resolved the underlying structural problems and recommended replacing the remaining defective sewer line.
5. Scope of repairs and municipal requirements
We subsequently learned that the seller's plumber had stopped the sewer replacement short of the property boundary.
Our understanding is that extending the replacement to the property boundary would have triggered additional municipal permitting and inspection requirements through the Department of Public Works, including replacement of the remaining Orangeburg piping.
The limited repair scope avoided triggering those additional requirements.
We're not alleging that the seller performed work without a legally required permit. Our concern is that the limited scope of repairs left deteriorated Orangeburg piping in place despite the contractual agreement to resolve the sewer blockage.
6. Seller threatens not to close
During one of our inspections, the seller was present at the property.
After learning about the additional sewer problems, he became frustrated and essentially stated that he wasn't spending any more money on the property, that we might not close, and that he could simply sell the house to someone else.
This is particularly concerning because we've already incurred substantial expenses in connection with the purchase and have made arrangements to vacate our current residence.
7. Seller's attorney makes claims contradicted by our inspection report
Following the hydro jetting, we received an email from the seller's attorney that raised additional concerns.
The attorney represented that the post-jetting camera inspection had successfully reached the street connection, that the sewer line was functioning, and that no visible damage remained. The attorney also indicated that the outstanding municipal permits would be closed.
While it is true that the camera was eventually able to reach the municipal connection, the characterization that the line had no visible damage directly conflicts with what our independent sewer specialist documented. The Sewer specialist also made very clear to the seller that the hydro jetting knocked a large chunk out of the replaced line due to the line being at an improper 45 degree angle (which we have video evidence of).
The post-jetting inspection continued to show protrusions, ruptures, and blockages in the deteriorating Orangeburg piping. Our plumber's written report specifically recommended full replacement.
In other words, the seller's position appears to be that successfully getting a camera through the pipe after jetting establishes that the sewer repair was completed satisfactorily, despite documented structural defects remaining.
The seller's attorney then offered us two options:
- Terminate the contract and receive our deposit back.
- Proceed with closing and accept a $5,000 credit.
Neither option involved the seller completing the additional repairs.
Our response:
Through our attorney, we disputed the seller's characterization of the final inspection and provided the updated written findings from our independent sewer specialist.
We emphasized that:
- The seller independently authorized the hydro jetting.
- The sewer cleanout cracked during that process.
- The post-jetting inspection continued to reveal significant structural defects, including protrusions, ruptures, and blockages.
- Our independent plumber recommended full sewer-line replacement.
- We do not agree that the seller has fulfilled his contractual obligations merely because the camera was eventually able to reach the municipal connection.
We rejected the proposed $5,000 credit and reiterated that we intend to enforce the terms of the executed purchase contract.
Our concern is that the seller is attempting to characterize the sewer repair as completed, despite contrary findings from an independent inspection, and is now trying to force us either to accept a credit or terminate the purchase.
Relevant contract language — Paragraph 20(b):
The following is from our signed contract, with only the municipality's name anonymized.
"The Parties agree that the Seller shall have a licensed plumber pull permits with the City of [Municipality] for all required work to address the broken sewer line located at the Premises to ensure that the sewage blockage is fixed in accordance with all local and state regulations. Seller shall be required to obtain signoff for said work from all required [Municipality] Municipal offices including but not limited to the Public Works Department and Health Department. In addition, the Parties agree that once the broken sewer line is repaired and Seller's plumber signs off on the same with written documentation, the Buyer shall have the right to have the sewer line inspected via a video camera at Buyer's sole cost and expense. Additionally, the Parties agree that the Seller shall be obligated to make any and all additional repairs that the City of [Municipality] deem necessary and required to complete the sewer line blockage repair. The Parties agree that all work shall be completed prior to the closing of title. Seller will provide said Municipal sign offs for said work, along with a receipt of both completion and payment to the Buyer's attorney at least three days prior to the closing of title. Buyer shall not be obligated to close until these items are completed and provided."
My questions:
- Given Paragraph 20(b), can the seller reasonably argue that he satisfied the contract by replacing only part of the sewer line, despite the remaining structural defects and blockage issues?
- Does the obligation to ensure the sewage blockage is fixed in accordance with applicable regulations extend beyond simply making the pipe temporarily passable with hydro jetting?
- How significant is it that the seller's attorney characterized the post-jetting inspection as showing no visible damage when our independent plumber documented substantial remaining defects that are proven by the video?
- Can the seller legally refuse to perform additional repairs and instead insist that we accept a $5,000 credit or terminate the contract?
- If the seller refuses to close, would we have grounds to pursue specific performance or damages under Connecticut law?
- Does the provision stating that we are not obligated to close until the required work and documentation are completed protect us from being considered in default if we refuse to close under these circumstances?
- How much weight would a court typically give to the independent plumber's written inspection findings versus the seller's assertion that the line is functional? The video backs up the plumbers claims as well.
We have a real estate attorney representing us and have documented the inspection findings, communications, and repair history.
We still want to purchase the house. We're simply seeking to have the seller fulfill the repair obligations he agreed to in writing.
I'd particularly appreciate input from Connecticut real estate attorneys or anyone who has encountered a similar dispute involving contractual repair obligations and a seller threatening to walk away.
[link] [comments]
Popular Products
-
Adjustable Shower Chair Seat$107.56$53.78 -
Adjustable Laptop Desk$91.56$45.78 -
Sunset Lake Landscape Canvas Print$225.56$112.78 -
Adjustable Plug-in LED Night Light$61.56$30.78 -
Portable Alloy Stringing Clamp for Ra...$119.56$59.78