Hr Unlawfully Deducted $2,400 From My Paycheck And Is Refusing To Fix It

Location: San Diego, CA

For context, I am an RN and I work 12 hour shifts at a hospital.

In November, I was notified that there were discrepancies in my time card and that I was receiving 0.5hr of incidental overtime for 63 shifts. This is because I hadn’t realized that I was supposed to clock out for my unpaid 30min lunches (it is a different timekeeping system than any hospital I have ever worked at). I admitted the mistake to my direct manager and agreed to fix it.

In December I met with my manager to go over my time card in detail. Going through everything we realized that there were 53 hours in which I was not paid either because I missed a punch or because no hours were accounted for in between for my clock in and clock out for some unknown reason or because my hours were coded incorrectly (not paid holiday pay on a holiday, for example).

On 12/29/25 we finalized the corrected time card and my manager told me that someone from HR would soon reach out to me to figure out a repayment plan.

On 1/8/26, I received an email from HR stating that an overpayment of $1,147.31 was made on my 1/9 paycheck and that I had until 1/22/26 to agree to a repayment plan or they would deduct it from my paycheck.

On 1/9, my paycheck hit for the pay period 12/21-1/3 and there were two deductions of $1,234.54 made marked as retro pay. There was a positive retro pay (likely for my underpayment) for 27 hours (no differentials even though I work night shift). The hours also did not match my time card, with about 15 hours I worked not being accounted for. The net pay was $3,014.75, more than 1k less than my usual payout. Most of my coworkers complained that their paychecks were also wrong too on 1/9 and that they were underpaid.

I reached out to my manager immediately and she agreed that I was not notified per policy as she is cc’d on emails regarding overpayment and she received the one on 1/8 but not one notifying me at least one pay period before the deductions that were made. She had attempted to reach out to HR everyday last week on my behalf but has been unable to reach anyone.

I emailed HR immediately through the provided email on my 1/8 overpayment notice and asked them why I was not notified, how they came to the amounts they came to, if I was going to receive the rest of my underpayment, and why the hours on my paycheck didn’t match the hours on my time card. I received this automated message in reply:

> We have reviewed your case and we wanted to inform you that as per [redacted]’s policy, we do not reduce an employee’s pay until an employee had a chance to review and agree to a repayment plan. When an overpayment is identified, the respective department[s] creates negative retros on your paycheck to initiate the recouping process. At the same time, the Overpayment team creates a positive element called "Overpayment" to offset these negative retros. By doing that we initiate the overpayment process but do not deduct employee's pay. This overpayment is valid.

>As a result, you can see Overpayment for $ 1427.90 has been offset with negative and positive retros in the paycheck dated 01/09/2026.

An attachment of my paycheck was included.

I replied that this message did not address any of my concerns and I restated I was not notified per policy and that I wanted to speak with an HR representative for a line-by-line explanation of the paycheck. I then received two emails in reply, the first was an identical automated message to the one above, the second was from a representative from HR stating, “please see the above reply that your case has been addressed.”

I replied again, restating my problems and that I needed an actual person to discuss these problems in my paycheck and again reminded them that they were in violation of policy because contrary to the automated email I was not notified. A different representative then replied stating that the case had been addressed and to “kindly review the email and attachment” which is referring to the automated email with my paycheck attached since that is the only email with an attachment in the thread.

I reached out to my union representative and she gave me the contact information for our local HR representative. I sent her an email with all these details and her reply was:

> Please work with staffing to review and audit your timecards. I’m assuming the way they did your adjustments created that. I recommend you work with your manager to go through every pay period that was impacted.

Please help, I am completely at a loss of what to do and losing $2,400 from this paycheck has made money tight this month. How do I hold this hospital accountable for this? How do I get an answer or resolution when my concerns are being blatantly ignored by HR?