Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

Nyc Roommate Keeps Turning Off Central Heat Despite Apartment Falling Below Legal Minimum Temperatures. What Are My Options?

Card image cap

location: New York

note: I’m soliciting only legal answers, not interpersonal judgment, “go cry about it” comments, or anything else.

I’ve lived in the city for ten years and have been in my apartment for three years. My roommate moved in this spring, so this is our first winter living together.

Our apartment is poorly insulated, and outside temperatures have a significant effect on the temperature indoors. This was an issue over the summer as well, when heat and humidity easily entered the apartment. I've already contacted our super, who is coming to inspect the windows and check whether they're properly sealed. I'm actively trying to address the insulation problem.

In the meantime, my roommate strongly prefers keeping the central heat off, even when it's unreasonably cold inside and outside. Recently, my bedroom measured 59°F and the living room 62°F during the day. NYC's heating requirements are 68°F during the day when it's below 55°F outside and 62°F overnight.

We agreed to turn the heat on for just ten minutes before bed when the outside temp is in the 30s or lower. She turned it off before the ten minutes were up. Her explanation was that the thermostat dial was set above 60, but we've both acknowledged that the dial is inaccurate, and the heat doesn't even activate until it's set to approximately 65.

I've offered to pay a larger share of the heating bill and ordered a space heater for my bedroom.

my questions are legal, if you have legal answers I am wondering about the following:

  • Do NYC's heating requirements have any bearing on disputes between roommates when the central heating system works but one occupant repeatedly turns it off? We are on a joint lease, but I know that the requirements apply only to landlords.
  • Does a tenant have any enforceable right to use central heat to maintain the city's minimum indoor temperatures over another tenant's objections?
  • What remedies, if any, are available if a roommate continues interfering with the heat? Would this be a landlord issue, a housing-code issue, or a civil dispute between tenants?

I'm not looking for advice about wearing more layers, exercising, or moving somewhere warmer. I'm already addressing the insulation issue with building management. I'm trying to understand my legal rights and options if my roommate continues preventing me from heating our shared apartment.

submitted by /u/Few_Avocado_1749
[link] [comments]