Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

Someone Scraped My Car While Driving It W/o My Permission; Do I Have To Pay??

Card image cap

Location: Los Angeles, California

I share a tandem parking spot with person A. We each have a spare key to the other's car so we can move them to get in and out of the spot. I gave A my spare only for that purpose.

On 10/10/26, A’s roommate, “B,” moved my car to get to A’s car without asking me, and scraped the entire right side against a pole. B texted me the same day (quote from text ss): "I take full responsibility for the accident and am more than happy to pay for the damage or fully reimburse you." She also offered to take the car to get quotes and recommended me a specific body shop that would have reasonable pricing

I took it to that body shop a few days ago (got busy with work and school). The estimate was about 4000 for dents and scratches on both right-side doors, the molding, a handle, and the mirror. The car is at the shop now.

I told B the quote two days ago and her answer was that she'd cover the estimate but had to check with her parents. Her dad then asked whether I could go through insurance, with her paying my deductible. I said no because I don't want a claim on my record or a higher premium for something I didn't cause. She replied with (I’m guessing her dad told her to say this): “I’m sorry, this was an accident and insurance should cover it” and that most policies have accident forgiveness. I don't know whether mine does.

I have screenshots of her texts, photos of the damage, and will have an itemized invoice.

My questions:
Is M's written offer to pay enforceable? Can I take her to small claims if she backs out? (We’re both over 18)
Does giving my keys to L for the tandem spot count as permission for M to drive? Does that affect whether my insurance would be primary?
Can her family require me to file a claim? Do I have to report this to my insurer if I don't file?
The shop can hold my car until I pay. Should I pay and then pursue M, or get her to pay the shop first?

I haven't signed anything or agreed to go through insurance. Please help I’m lowkey stressed out and can’t pay 4k. I also know that she’s well off and can likely afford it (her initial response before her dad responded was “I should be okay to cover the estimate, I have to check with my parents because I won’t be able to do it myself”)

ALSO I’m leasing the car if that changes anything

submitted by /u/Big_Skirt2880
[link] [comments]