Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

‘an Absolute Nightmare’ — Trump’s Trilateral With Xi And Putin Spooks Allies

Card image cap


President Donald Trump’s love of the deal is inspiring fears among U.S. allies about his historic meeting Thursday with Chinese leader Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin.

European and Asian officials and diplomats say they worry that Trump’s penchant for unilateral foreign policy moves — such as abducting Venezuela’s President Nicolás Maduro, waging war on Iran and threatening regime change in Cuba — raises the risk of Trump endorsing initiatives that support Putin’s ambitions over Ukrainian territory and Xi’s claims to Taiwan.

At this particular moment, they see danger in the combination of Trump’s affinity for the two authoritarian leaders — he frequently praises Putin as a “genius,” Xi as a “brilliant man” — and his weakened position at home following Republicans’ midterm losses.

That, they fear, may embolden Putin and Xi to pitch approaches to Ukraine and Taiwan that Trump can claim as a diplomatic win. The three are holding their first-ever joint meeting in Shenzhen, China, a discussion that the White House said last week would focus on possible reductions in the countries’ nuclear arsenals.

“Oh, it's Ukraine all over,” said a European diplomat about the meeting’s outcomes. EU members share “the fear of one’s president's zeal to strike any kind of deal just to make up for an electoral defeat.”

The diplomat, and others, were granted anonymity due to the sensitivity of their comments.

As for Asia, a trilateral in which Xi pitches Trump on his vision of “the future of Taiwan” — compelling the self-ruled island to submit to Chinese rule — “would be an absolute nightmare,” said a Washington-based Asian diplomat. The three leaders “give the impression that they are deciding the future of the world order, almost as if they were the leaders of the world.”

The White House didn’t respond to a request for comment.

In May, Trump said his “very good relationship” with Xi has meant “everything” in the president’s ability to make deals and solve problems “that somebody else would have done very badly with.” Trump has said he has a “good relationship” with Putin but added “it only matters if we get things done,” in reference to the president’s desire to end Russia’s war on Ukraine.

European officials have worried since the trilateral announcement that the three leaders would agree to a plan to carve up Ukraine that heavily favors Russia, without any input from Kyiv. Xi has supported Russia’s war against Ukraine through exports of components essential to Moscow’s military. Trump and Putin have both said Ukraine will be a topic of discussion.

Trump has a track record of foreign policy initiatives that have favored Moscow’s and Beijing’s interests over those of longtime allies. Trump has repeatedly blamed Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zeleneskyy for Russia’s war on Ukraine — and has threatened to end arms shipments to Kyiv. He also upended decades of U.S. policy toward Taiwan in May by delaying a $14 billion weapons sale to the self-governing island.

U.S. allies’ fears “that he's going to trade their interests in discussions with Russia and China” are justified, said Zack Cooper, a former national security official in the George W. Bush administration. “Trump seems to believe in this great man theory that he and Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping are the world's three great leaders and that together, they can solve the world's problems.”

Democratic members of the House Select Committee on China are also concerned where that dealmaking will lead.

“The security of Taiwan’s people must under no circumstance be a bargaining chip,” the committee members said in a statement Wednesday. “Similarly, the future of Ukraine must not be discussed without Ukrainians at the table.”

Trump told reporters Monday before departing for Asia that his meeting with Xi and Putin would focus on reducing their respective nuclear arsenals, the Iran war and what he quipped was “my favorite subject: Ukraine.” Moscow and Beijing have already shown an unwillingness to give ground on their strategic stockpiles or use their influence with Tehran to pressure the regime. That means any deals struck in the talks are likely to be in other areas.

Xi is likely to “push hard to try to make the moratorium on Taiwan arms sales permanent,” said Ker Gibbs, former president of the American Chamber of Commerce in Shanghai, who is in regular contact with Chinese officials.

Xi and Putin have a number of issues where their interests align, and that’s where allies kept outside of the meeting worry they could most successfully pressure Trump.

For example, Beijing has depicted Japan as hell-bent on "neo-militarism" that is destabilizing the region.

“Putin is largely sympathetic to that narrative, and so I imagine that Xi Jinping will put that forward and try to paint Japanese Prime Minister [Sanae] Takaichi as a provocateur that the three parties should work together to rein in,” said David Sacks, a former political-military official at the U.S. diplomatic outpost in Taiwan.

The Japanese embassy didn’t respond to a request for comment.

Trump may be keen for a high-profile breakthrough in the trilateral that he can market as a win during an Asian diplomatic spree that so far has yielded minimal results. Beside signing a long-pending trade deal with Thailand on the sidelines of the U.S.-ASEAN Special Summit in Manila Tuesday and touting a “new and completely different Trade Deal with the Philippines” on Truth Social on Wednesday, Trump hasn’t broken any new diplomatic ground.

“Trump comes from the New York real estate world, where you get rewarded by dealing with the big player in the market, and that's how he conducts foreign policy, " argued John Erath, former national security council deputy director for European affairs in the first Trump administration. “He deals with Russia and China, the big players in this particular market, and he tells the small players that they're going to have to take what he can come up with.”

Moscow and Beijing are already touting potentially momentous outcomes from the trilateral.

The summit “is of groundbreaking significance,” Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Mao Ning said Monday.” Russian presidential aide Yury Ushakov said the meeting will be “a showstopper,” according to Russia’s TASS news agency.

Those expressions of state-backed enthusiasm may be part of Xi and Putin’s tactical toolbox ahead of the trilateral, according to Thomas Countryman, assistant secretary of State for international security and nonproliferation in the Obama administration.

“That kind of rhetoric — to say we are going to have the most historic conference in the world in the last 80 years — that appeals to a person like Trump," Countryman said. “Pumping up the meeting’s significance may prompt Trump to accept whatever they are trying to shove down his throat.”

Daniella Cheslow contributed to this report.