‘nobody's Untouchable Anymore’: Prediction Markets Feel Heat From Trump Administration.
A top Wall Street regulator has lifted the prediction markets to new heights this year. Now, he’s sending them another message: You need to fall in line.
Commodity Futures Trading Commission Chair Michael Selig has championed and defended the upstart industry since taking over the financial market regulator last December, drawing backlash and even lawsuits from some major Wall Street players. Yet the CFTC is now conducting separate probes into Kalshi and Polymarket, the two dominant platforms, suggesting that Selig is stepping up his oversight. At the same time, Democrats are vowing to scrutinize the industry when they take over Congress in January.
The CFTC’s investigations are seen as a signal to the industry that nobody has a free pass to ignore market rules — not even those closely connected to the White House, according to half a dozen people close to the agency. Some of the people questioned how far the CFTC is willing to go, citing its general support for the industry. But others said the agency could be looking to manage its image and combat the idea that the companies are untouchable. Kalshi and Polymarket have counted Donald Trump Jr. as an adviser, though Kalshi said Thursday that he has left the company by mutual agreement, citing his involvement with rival Polymarket.
“No regulator ever wants the perception to be that the industry runs the agency,” said a financial industry executive close to the CFTC, who, like the others, was granted anonymity to speak candidly. “It wouldn’t shock me if, privately, the CFTC is saying these are great for us because we need to send a message.”
The CFTC’s investigations underscore the suddenly shifting environment that new financial players like the prediction markets and cryptocurrency companies are being forced to navigate as corporate America faces a reckoning in the nation’s capital. Democrats are promising tougher corporate oversight, and even the Trump administration is being forced to distance itself from K Street amid criticism that it’s gone too far in bowing to industry.
“In the bold new world starting [in the] first Monday in January, nobody's untouchable anymore,” said Rep. Frank Lucas, an Oklahoma Republican who sits on the House Agriculture Committee, which has jurisdiction over the derivatives regulator.
CFTC spokesperson Zach Fulton said the agency’s enforcement work “knows no bounds.”
“We are focused on preventing fraud, abuse, and insider trading across the entire derivatives ecosystem, regardless of the market or political jurisdiction,” Fulton said in a statement. “Our actions have spanned Democratic and Republican states alike, as well as crypto markets, traditional commodities, prediction markets, and beyond. We will pursue misconduct wherever it occurs.”
Kalshi and Polymarket have been under investigation by the CFTC for months. In Kalshi’s case, which POLITICO was first to report last week, the agency is looking into the launch of dozens of new products by the company and recently warned it of potential charges. Kalshi has said the possible charges relate to a “procedural error.”
Polymarket is facing a broad investigationthat partly relates to a 2022 settlement deal with the CFTC that required the company to close off its platform to U.S. users.
To Kalshi, the investigations don’t mark a vibe shift. John Bivona, the company’s head of federal government relations, said the prediction market giant has disagreed plenty with the CFTC over the last year — on new products, court orders and walling off its platform. But he attributes it all to the agency “doing their job.”
“Their job is to be a discerning organization,” Bivona said. “That’s what they’ve got to do.”
A Polymarket spokesperson said the company is in consistent communication with the CFTC and proactively works “with regulators and law enforcement to protect the quality and integrity of our markets.”
The prediction markets still appear to wield lots of sway at the CFTC, where Selig is the lone member of what Congress set up as a five-person, bipartisan commission. (On Thursday, President Donald Trump nominated a pair of Senate staffers to join him as commissioners.)
Selig, in the face of staunch opposition from some of the financial world’s biggest names like GOP megadonor Ken Griffin’s Citadel Securities, recently green-lit a new type of risky financial product tied to U.S. stocks. Kalshi quickly jumped at the chance to begin offering such so-called perpetual futures. But a group representing Citadel Securities, the stock exchange operator Cboe Global Markets and several others promptly sued over the approvals.
The CFTC has also continued to back Kalshi and Polymarket, among other prediction markets, in their legal fight against Democratic and Republican state officials who say they are violating long-standing gambling laws. And just last week, Selig touted the markets’ forecasting chops and value as sophisticated financial products at a conference in Miami.
The probes are landing just as the prediction markets are drawing bipartisan scrutiny on Capitol Hill, including from top Democratic lawmakers who have named them as top oversight targets.
While the CFTC’s clampdown marks a sign of the shifting winds around the prediction markets, it’s not a surprise. The agency has been ratcheting up scrutiny on the platforms for months: In July, it told prediction market operators to avoid using overly broad language when alerting regulators about new products.
Elizabeth Davis, a former CFTC attorney, said the agency’s embrace of prediction markets has created a question in the financial industry about whether it is giving certain companies “more loyalty” over others. But the CFTC’s investigations show “they’re going to police these markets just like they do any other,” she said.
“I wouldn’t mistake a pro-technology bent from the regulator for a laissez-faire approach to market regulation,” said a prediction market industry official, who was granted anonymity to speak freely.
An industry attorney said, “I’ll believe it when I see it.”
"These cases could be a way for them to counter the narrative that the CFTC is 100% aligned with Kalshi and Polymarket,” the attorney said. “But only if they bring enforcement actions that are meaningful."
Popular Products
-
Classic Oversized Teddy Bear$23.78 -
Gem's Ballet Natural Garnet Gemstone ...$171.56$85.78 -
Butt Lifting Body Shaper Shorts$95.56$47.78 -
Slimming Waist Trainer & Thigh Trimmer$67.56$33.78 -
Realistic Fake Poop Prank Toys$99.56$49.78