Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

2 Scandals Divide Australia — And Threaten Its Sense Of Self

Card image cap


CANBERRA — Australia is arguing over what its national heroes owe the country.

Alleged war crimes by Australian soldiers in Afghanistan and the 2018 cricket ball-tampering scandal carry radically different stakes, yet both have challenged Australians' sense of self and left the same questions hanging: who knew, who was held accountable and how much truth is needed to allow the country to move on?

Years after each set of issues surfaced, the core tensions remain unresolved. To many, the allegations that Australia could be involved in serious wrongdoing have caused cognitive dissonance, even distress, with the motives of those speaking out publicly questioned.

Each produced investigations that were similarly divisive, with responses ranging from claims of cover-ups to calls to move on from historic wrongdoing.

On the one side: a camp arguing reviews have been weaponized against individuals, granting others a free pass. On the other, a camp arguing that without forensically examining the wounds, Australia will not be able to heal.

Liberal frontbencher Andrew Hastie weighed in an interview with 2GB Radio Thursday: “Of all the people who've spoken thus far, I'm probably most sympathetic to Cam Bancroft, who suffered the most."

"He became the fall guy along with Steve Smith and Dave Warner," Hastie said, before connecting the cricket scandal to an ongoing court battle around Australian actions in Afghanistan. “Having lived something similar myself through the military, I'm conscious that the truth always comes out.”

Before entering parliament as a 32-year-old in 2015, Hastie toured Afghanistan as an elite SAS soldier, and has since spoken publicly about alleged crimes carried out in the regiment.

Testifying under subpoena in a defamation case launched by another SAS soldier accused of war crimes has come with a cost to Hastie. The far-right One Nation party, now regularly topping national opinion polls, has targeted Hastie in episodes of its popular "Please Explain" cartoon series.Hastie now requires extra security.

After Cricket Australia announced a private forum for players involved in the 2018 scandal to speak, former Australian team cricket player Usman Khawaja, whose autobiography sparked this week’s media firestorm, asked Wednesday: “We want to move on. The question is: will this allow us to?”

For decades, Australians have seen an idealized version of the national character in their soldiers and their cricketers, framing them as the embodiment of Australian values: toughness, a vague but culturally powerful sense of “mateship” and, above all, fairness.

“Being Captain of the Australian Cricket team … [is] the pinnacle almost of human achievement in Australia,” former prime minister John Howard said in 1997.

So revelations in 2018 that the team tampered with the ball during a tour of South Africa drew cultural and political revulsion.

“[To] the whole nation, who holds those who wear the Baggy Green up on a pedestal … this is a shocking disappointment,” then-prime minister Malcolm Turnbull told reporters.

Cricket Australia’s initial response to the outcry prompted a hasty and flawed investigation, producing a neat but unsatisfying conclusion: while the team had developed a corrosive win-at-all-costs mentality, only three players, including its most junior Cameron Bancroft, were responsible.

Bancroft was banned for nine months, while captain Steve Smith and vice captain David Warner were banned for a year.

Cricket Australia adopted 36 of 42 recommendations of a review carried out by the Ethics Centre. Since 2018, the team’s once-aggressive demeanor on the field has notably softened.

But pinning blame on the trio was never enough to satisfy a public, who suspected knowledge of the tampering plot was wider than Cricket Australia suggested.

“We still don’t know the truth about what actually happened at Sandpapergate,” retired cricket great Shane Warne said in 2022. “There are all sorts of whispers or rumors that we all have heard, and one day the truth will come out.”

With the scandal reopened, the public — and Australia's parliament — has divided into camps.

Some have praised the now-retired Khawaja as a whistleblower, and condemned for criticizing active players, putting their livelihoods at risk.

Cricket Australia’s refusal to reopen its original investigation this week, instead offering private talks between players, is backed by those eager to move on. What good would reopening old wounds do?

Others cannot identify with the national team until there has been full accountability. “The public want … the truth,” said David Warner, who was banned for a year for his role in the scandal, on Wednesday.

That contrast is materializing in Australian politics, where the major parties are keen to draw a line under the sand.

Deputy Prime Minister Richard Marles on Thursday declared the embattled Cummins not only a “great captain,” but also “a fantastic representative of our country."

Nationals MP Michael McCormack, who was deputy prime minister in 2018, said Wednesday: “It’s done. Move on.”

Sports Minister Anika Wells told POLITICO that Cummins “has addressed this extensively” and there “is a summer of cricket to look forward to.”

But Greens Leader David Shoebridge has called for legal protections for whistleblowers in sport, arguing they “carry all the risk, while administrators avoid accountability.”

Australians project meaning onto 11 men wearing white over summer, but it's the men and women in fighting overseas who embody the nation’s deepest ideas about service and sacrifice.

A landmark 2020 official report on alleged war crimes carried out in Afghanistan, concluding evidence of 39 murders carried out by the nation’s elite soldiers, produced a neat conclusion.

A “warrior culture” had been allowed to develop internally. The senior command bore “moral” though not legal responsibility for their alleged crimes.

But questions about the conduct of its troops spark a visceral reaction among many Australians. Again, assertions that an Australian institution had policed itself properly were met with skepticism. The charging of two relatively junior soldiers with war crimes, which both deny, is not enough to satiate that feeling.

Many believe a handful of individuals have been made to wear the consequences for systemic failures.

Others don’t want those systemic failures investigated, because it’s inconvenient to their sense of national identity.

There are widespread claims that the justice system has been weaponized against national heroes.

Other politicians are simply arguing that Australia cannot move on without a top-to-bottom reckoning.

Independent Sen. Jacqui Lambie, herself an army veteran, has accused senior Defence officials of “throwing their Diggers under the bus” and washing their hands of responsibility.

“It's one in, all in,” Lambie said in 2023. Shoebridge also wants the higher command to face scrutiny for what they knew, or should have known, about the alleged crimes of their subordinates.

Calls for another inquiry into the Afghanistan command are set to go nowhere. Australia’s major parties are both eager to move on, praising the Department of Defence for subjecting itself to scrutiny.

“Australia is a country which holds itself accountable,” Marles said in 2024, formally closing the government’s response to the inquiry. Marles stressed that cultural reform of the SAS is “ongoing and enduring.”

For many, internal changes developed and managed behind closed doors, without a full public reckoning, will not be enough.