Australia’s Transparency Watchdog Orders New Search For Afghanistan Killing Documents
CANBERRA — Australia’s transparency watchdog has ordered the Defence Department to conduct a new and more detailed search for documents related to the killing of two Afghans in 2012, finding its initial attempts fell short of its legal requirements.
Two days after three Australian troops were murdered by an Afghan recruit they were training in August 2012, SAS soldiers conducted a nighttime operation in Sola, Afghanistan, in which two Afghans were shot dead.
The killings have been the subject of intense media scrutiny, with a leaked 2012 Defence report concluding the soldiers did not breach the rules of engagement. Then-Afghan President Hamid Karzai condemned the killings. SBS News later traveled to the village to speak with locals who described them as executions.
In 2017, the Australian Broadcasting Corporation reported that an internal “communications pack” attached to the report — including media talking points — called for the report to be kept private to protect Australia’s “national interest.”
In 2023, former Australian soldier and war crimes researcher Chris Elliott launched a series of freedom of information requests seeking access to the “communications pack” and internal correspondence related to it.
Defence rejected Elliott’s requests in 2024, claiming it had taken “all reasonable steps” to find the documents and they did not exist. Elliott told POLITICO he believes the department is engaged in a "cover up."
In a ruling seen by POLITICO, Justin Lodge, acting general manager of the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner,said Defence had excluded emails related to the communications pack in its initial search.
“I am not satisfied that the Department has met its onus to demonstrate it took all reasonable steps to search for documents in scope of the request,” Lodge wrote.
Defence provided Lodge with evidence of the searches it had conducted, and revealed it had found some additional documents despite initially claiming it could find nothing within scope.
Elliott told POLITICO that the existence of the communications pack showed senior officials in the department were “attentive” to SAS controversies and “actively massaging the public relations responses in real time.”
“The messaging was constantly drafted and redrafted as events unfolded, so it is extraordinary that Defence claimed this material didn’t exist, only to ‘find’ some of it later,” he said.
Lodge has given Defence until Dec. 13 to demonstrate it has conducted an adequate search for relevant documents, or inform him that it will appeal his decision to the Administrative Review Tribunal. The OAIC can pursue civil penalties against entities which do not comply with its orders.
Defence did not immediately reply to POLITICO’s request for comment.
The Aug. 31 2012 incident in Sola occurred as elite Australian soldiers hunted for an Afghan, known as Hekmatullah, who had murdered three Australian troops two days prior.
Australian soldiers said that during the Sola incident an Afghan was wrestled to the ground by an SAS trooper, and shot after he allegedly attempted to grab an Australian’s weapon. They said the second man was shot after he was allegedly spotted speaking on a radio as an Australian helicopter approached, and “maneuvering to gain tactical advantage” while failing to comply with orders to stop.
In 2020, the A report into alleged war crimes in Afghanistan, The Brereton Report, found credible evidence of 39 murders carried out by elite Australian forces between 2009 and 2012.
Popular Products
-
Fake Pregnancy Test$61.56$30.78 -
Anti-Slip Safety Handle for Elderly S...$57.56$28.78 -
Toe Corrector Orthotics$41.56$20.78 -
Waterproof Trauma Medical First Aid Kit$169.56$84.78 -
Rescue Zip Stitch Kit$109.56$54.78