Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

Chuck Schumer’s Best Exit Is On His Own Terms

Card image cap


Sen. Chuck Schumer may not need to state the obvious — that he plans to retire in 2028 — to claim the votes needed to lead his caucus again. But he should anyway.

Schumer finds himself in an awkward position ahead of his leadership election next month. He doesn’t want to immediately make himself a lame duck, but he’d smooth his path back to being majority leader one more time if he assured his colleagues they were only signing a two-year lease.

It would be agonizing for any hard-charging politician. But to assign an end date is especially excruciating for somebody who’s only known elected office since he was a 23-year-old Harvard graduate, when he became the youngest New York assemblymember since Theodore Roosevelt.

That’s exactly what Schumer should do, though, for the good of his party, his caucus and his own legacy.

The soon-to-be 76-year-old had gone to the then-81-year-old Joe Biden in the summer of 2024 to say it was time to go. He can now choose the course he and so many in his party now wish Biden had taken before the former president’s disastrous attempt to cling to power.

Democrats, if you hadn’t noticed, have craved generational change ever since. And, as you definitely noticed, they just won a smashing midterm victory and are poised to claim 56 Senate seats.

The latter leaves Schumer poised to enjoy the spoils of victory and reclaim his post atop the Democratic caucus.

But the hunger for new blood has left some Democratic lawmakers more grudging than grateful — willing to reward Schumer but with hopes that he’ll use the next Congress to serve as a bridge. And, unlike with Biden, to actually mean it.

By being candid about his intentions, Schumer can tamp down his party’s factional fights, which began in the form of Sen. Chris Van Hollen’s challenge two weeks after the midterms. Even if he easily dispatches Van Hollen next month, questions about Schumer’s future will linger over Democrats in New York, Washington and beyond through 2027.

Why would he invite that when his party could be exercising its new clout, whether it’s trying to fulfill its election promises or hold President Donald Trump, speaking of elderly politicians, to account?

Which raises the core reason why Schumer is reluctant to reveal his plans: He doesn’t want to voluntarily deprive himself of political capital. But how would he tangibly have less influence in the next Congress if he said this was his final term, as so many of his colleagues and Senate watchers know it to be?

It’s not as though Trump’s final two years, with Stephen Miller running the West Wing, augur a season of fruitful lawmaking. It’s more likely that Schumer will spend his final months leading the Senate through another Trump impeachment trial, a solemn role that will consume his time and attention and could be a career capstone that elevates him in history beyond skilled party tactician and camera-chasing pol.

But on the matter of raw politics and, well, Schumer’s insecurity: With Democrats likely to hold the Senate for years to come, what donor would dodge his flip-phone calls? Every major contributor, whether a Democrat or switch-hitting type, will want to stay in the good graces of a party that could be closer to 60 seats than 55 after the next election.

Now, would that mean Schumer may have to further empower lieutenants? Perhaps.

But Kirsten Gillibrand, his fellow New Yorker and the DSCC chair, incoming Whip Brian Schatz and future DSCC chair and resistance fundraiser extraordinaire Adam Schiff shouldn’t be mere understudies any longer. They should be developing donor relationships, building caucus management chops and generally learning how to fill the considerable vacuum Schumer will leave after two decades as a Senate leader. Let them start doing the work and claiming some credit.

Put another way, Schumer can say he’ll share power more in the next Congress, but he’d show it by declaring his intentions to step down in 2028.

He’d put his caucus first.

Yet there are more selfish reasons for Schumer to be honest about his plans — and the sooner the better.

As one of his longtime friends told me, with evident sadness, it will look like he’s being chased out by the left if he waits well into the new year. By then, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez may have jumped into the New York Senate race.

Schumer should do this on his terms.

The best time would’ve been the week after the midterms, when his newly expanded flock gathered in Washington and their leader could have taken a victory lap. But the second best time is now.

Schumer’s walk-off now is a 56-seat majority few in either party dared dream of a year ago. He can expand it in 2028 without having to worry about his own reelection.

That means Democrats will almost certainly have a grip on power in the capital into the next decade. Trump can’t replace a Supreme Court justice. Any vacancy will wait for the next Democratic president.

That’s a better legacy than refusing to bow to the obvious and being tempted to claim one last term, in or out of leadership. Schumer may believe there’s precedent to follow: He’s aware that Robert Byrd voluntarily gave up his leadership role in 1989 to claim a committee gavel. But Byrd was five years younger then than Schumer is now. And Democratic politics today are light years different.

Even flirting with another term would tempt a very different walk-off for Schumer. In short: He’d be heckled or shouted down entirely at most any public rally he attempted to have in his beloved New York City. His party has moved on.

Charles Ellis Schumer will not go down in history with Theodore Roosevelt, let alone Franklin. But he also shouldn’t be remembered in part for how it all ended, as Biden will.

Watching the video of Schumer strolling, hunched over, across the Capitol plaza this week, I couldn’t help but consider the cruel irony.

He was a young man in a hurry — well into middle age. He was the butt of jokes about how dangerous it was to stand between him and a camera. He was obsessive about print coverage, too, charming every new generation of The New York Times Hill reporters and haranguing them and their editors about his print quote and photo placement. He was a striver who put in 18 years in the House, coming in with Ronald Reagan’s election, before finally winning a Senate seat in 1998 — only to labor for another decade in the shadow of Daniel Patrick Moynihan and then Hillary Rodham Clinton.

But now, as that video showed, he wasn’t running to the lens but better off evading its glare.

It won’t get better.

Schumer knows that. It’s just time he admits it and writes his own ending.