Dems Crash Elon Musk’s Texas Honeymoon
Elon Musk’s regrets about spending hundreds of millions of dollars to unsuccessfully back Republicans could be getting deeper in Texas, the epicenter of his sprawling tech empire.
The Democrats set to paint the state blue, or at least purple — incoming Gov. Gina Hinojosa, Attorney General Nathan Johnson, and Land Commissioner Benjamin Flores — are prepared to level new scrutiny on businesses the world’s richest man brought to the Lone Star State with Republican help. At stake are deals for SpaceX rocket launches, new data center construction and a potential mega merger of Tesla and SpaceX. Hinojosa expressed a willingness to work alongside Musk, but said “it just needs to be on terms that are good for Texans.”
Democrats say they don’t have a “vendetta” against Musk and only want to make sure his companies aren’t skirting the law.
“We’re not against businesses,” Flores said of his Democratic colleagues preparing to take office. “But I am for transparency, processes — the rule of law.”
Johnson was more direct.
“Elon Musk will be held to the same standards as everyone else. Perhaps that’s a shift,” he said in a statement. “My job as attorney general is to uphold the law, protect consumers, and ensure fair competition, without bias or preference, and that’s what I’m going to do.”
Musk, SpaceX and Tesla did not respond to requests for comment.
It’s a delicate dance for a party that doesn’t want to be seen as hindering economic development after taking power for the first time in more than 20 years, especially after seeing Musk flee solidly blue California, where he started his companies, citing political reasons.
The overarching debate over Musk’s businesses — and the expansion of big tech — is raising concerns from Texans in both parties.
Residents and policymakers are especially upset about SpaceX’s plan to jump from 25 rocket launches a year to as many as 456, a move the Federal Aviation Administration must approve. Residents have criticized the launches for shutting down a nearby public beach in Boca Chica, in addition to raising concerns about effects on local wildlife, water quality and damaging the foundations of surrounding homes — worries that would only increase with more launches.
Flores has already pledged to use his General Land Office to ask Johnson to reexamine the constitutionality of the law SpaceX uses to close the public beach for its launches. Republicans passed the law in 2013 to lure Musk’s company to Texas to build a spaceport.
Musk’s proposed $24 billion data center in Brownsville, which includes a natural gas power plant, will also face scrutiny. The project has an array of environmental permitting and tax deals in the works, as Democrats and Republicans alike rethink the state’s relationship with data centers.
The project received an air pollution permit on Monday just days after the state lifted a temporary pause on data center-related permitting. The approval notably conflicts with Hinojosa's stance that the state should pause all data center permitting until it implements laws that “protect Texans.”
When the blue wave initially hit Texas in November, Musk joked that “Data centers in space looking pretty appealing right now.” The comment came after he spent nearly $500 million backing Republican candidates in Texas and across the nation, many of whom ultimately lost. That includes $5 million for Greg Abbott’s failed gubernatorial campaign and $10 million for Attorney General Ken Paxton’s failed run for U.S. Senate.
But he struck a more conciliatory tone Wednesday, expressing optimism about the incoming Democratic leadership while saying he felt “pretty foolish” over how much he spent on the election.
“The new governor, actually, I think, is going to be quite moderate,” Musk said at the New York Times’ DealBook Summit. “I don't think she's sort of a far-left governor. And based on everything I've heard about her, I think things will be fine in Texas with Gina as governor.”
Flores said he doesn’t want an adversarial relationship with Musk or SpaceX, but is asking for the company to be more open about its plans with the state and locals.
“I’m a perfectly reasonable person,” Flores said. “Show me what the plan is, but don’t piecemeal it, and work with the community.”
“When there’s a data center, rocket launches, or an amusement park, I want to make sure the community has input in the process.”
Johnson, for his part, has made it clear he will have a different tone than Paxton, a staunch Musk ally. Notably, the newly elected attorney general vowed to examine any potential merger between SpaceX and Tesla due to the risks of corporate concentration.
“I don’t have a vendetta against Elon Musk, although he’s been such an ass with his money and his rhetoric, he would deserve it,” Johnson said in an interview with Texas Monthly. “I just don’t believe in vendettas.”
Musk indicated Wednesday that SpaceX and Tesla could be “better together” because of the overlapping work both are doing on AI models, robots and advanced chips.
The proposed data center, part of SpaceX’s plans to exponentially boost its computing power for artificial intelligence development, has drawn local pushback despite the company’s estimates it will create some 3,000 construction jobs and more than 500 permanent jobs.
Cameron County commissioners narrowly voted Tuesday against advancing a proposal to give SpaceX a tax break for the project, leaving a deal worth billions of dollars in savings “dead in the water.” The decision came as some residents opposed offering tax incentives to a wealthy corporation that is already building on 444 acres of land outside of Brownsville.
The city of Starbase annexed that property, an enclave in Cameron County where many SpaceX employees live. That city is separately considering granting SpaceX tax breaks for the data center.
Meanwhile, state lawmakers on both sides are already proposing legislation to roll back subsidies provided to data center builders. Even the state Senate, which is still under GOP control, has joined House Democrats in proposing legislation to repeal Texas’ longstanding tax exemption for large-scale data centers — SB 293, filed by Finance Committee Chair Joan Huffman, a Houston Republican.
Additionally, Democratic Rep. Oziel Ochoa Jr., who flipped a GOP seat earlier this month, filed a bill that would prevent Boca Chica State Park, which is adjacent to SpaceX’s operations, from being sold, leased or made available for private, commercial or industrial development.
SpaceX publicly maintains that while the company is seeking to buy land near its rocket launch facility, the parcel doesn’t include Texas coastline, and would ultimately help “create more recreational opportunities for Texans.”
Hinojosa notably has been hesitant about land deals with SpaceX and is fighting to protect access to beaches, which are “enshrined in our Texas constitution as being free and open to the people of Texas.”
“We can have a strong working relationship with Elon Musk and his companies, but it has to be on our terms,” Hinojosa said in a post-election interview with CNN. “It cannot be just running over the people of Texas, and that's what changes now that I will be governor.”
Although incoming Democrats are promising to closely examine Musk’s operations, Nathan Jensen, a leading scholar on economic development incentives at the University of Texas in Austin, doesn’t expect them to pull the rug out from under the tech billionaire or his companies.
More scrutiny of data center development was likely to come regardless of who won the election in Texas, Jensen said. And Democrats in the state appear to be taking a centrist position on economic development and job creation, criteria that could bode well for SpaceX and Tesla.
“I think the Democrats are quite savvy to not have a bad reputation in business here in Texas,” Jensen said. “There’s no way they want to drive companies away.”