Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

Europe’s Middle Powers Mobilize — Without Trump

Card image cap


HALIFAX, Nova Scotia — Europe and its allies are devising a new strategy to fill the void left by America's retreat from the world stage: Band together in mini-alliances to do what the U.S. won't.

The effort aims to carry out Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney’s call for “middle powers” to unite amid a shifting global order. It crystallized this weekend at the annual security forum of global leaders on Canada’s Atlantic coast, where officials advanced an alphabet soup of multinational coalitions that range from bolstering NATO’s Arctic edge to advancing rare earth mining.

More than a dozen European nations represented at the forum pointed to a future without the U.S. at the forefront — even if the solution still appeared vague and uncertain.

“This is middle powers trying to keep the system alive, and eventually also improve it,” said Norwegian Foreign Minister Espen Barth Eide. “We can't make everything an issue about what we hear from Washington today. The rest of us had to go on with our lives.”

Officials said they welcome help from the U.S., whose economic and military might is not easily replaceable. But the absence of Pentagon or State Department officials, once a mainstay at the conference, was a telling symbol of the administration’s priorities. The Defense Department last year banned employees from participating in think tank conferences, and specifically emphasized the Halifax forum.

Allies, worried about President Donald Trump’s unpredictability and seeming alignment with Russia, feel compelled to take some kind of action. They are pushing forward without their longtime security guarantor, launching various subgroups in and around NATO and EU umbrellas.

A German-led Maritime Security Partnership will cooperate on Arctic security. A five-nation Nordic Defence Cooperation in Scandinavia will focus on realigning road networks and troop movements to fend off a Russian invasion. Another cluster of nations is planning to build a sixth-generation fighter jet to replace America’s F-35 fighter jet. Canadian Defense Minister David McGuinty even noted that Ottawa had signed 22 new trade and defense deals in the past 18 months.

The dizzying pace left some officials struggling to figure out who was doing what.

“We have so many coalitions,” said one European official, granted anonymity to discuss sensitive military matters. “It’s hard to keep track.”

The shift is driven partly by the U.S. push away from funding Ukraine’s military, concerns about a possible removal of some American troops from Europe, and scar tissue after prolonged tariff battles with Trump.

“We're trying to find different groups for different purposes,” the European official said.

The White House did not respond to a request for comment.

Allies of the administration framed the shift as a positive sign, with Europe and Canada stepping up to support themselves. Sen. Mike Rounds (R-S.D.), the lone Republican lawmaker to attend the Halifax forum, said it made sense for allies to be “in a better position” to pick up the slack where the U.S. can’t.

But the array of coalitions is already leading to confusion, even among European officials used to red tape, thousand-page zoning bids, and detailed environmental regulations.

The EU’s “partners for multilateralism” pact extends from the 27-nation bloc to Canada, Brazil, India, Australia, and Kenya. The Franco-German-Spanish effort to create a sixth-generation fighter jet has been scrapped in favor of a British, Japanese and Italian variant that now also includes Canada. European officials can’t figure out what to call a new partnership with Norway and Canada.

It’s also not clear how many of these coalitions will produce a substantive replacement to the U.S. Some of the new alliances already face growing pains and coordination problems.

Dutch Procurement Minister Derk Boswijk said his government has reached out to Sweden, Norway and Denmark to discuss a new proposal for a “coalition of the doing,” focused on digitization, the integration of AI into battle management systems and rare earth mining.

Sweden hasn’t heard of the initiative, said the European official.

But the European official also downplayed the risk that multiple coalitions could bog down decisionmaking, arguing that the new groups would only deepen preexisting alliances.

“It's a kind of variable geometry,” the official said. “It's better that it is happening than what the alternative would be.”

The plans might be a rebuttal to Trump, but they take a page from his playbook: it’s easier to get business done around a smaller table.

“The pie is so big we can all get something from it,” said Boswijk. “What frustrated me the most is that so much time is wasted competing with each other. We do not have the luxury.”

Democrats at the forum blamed Europe’s multilateral distancing squarely on Trump’s combative approach to allies.

“How can we be surprised as Americans if Europeans take their own interests into account and begin to explore other options?” said Sen. Chris Coons (D-Del.), who is likely taking over as Senate Foreign Relations Committee chair in the next Congress. “We can't blame Europe.”

Democrats' laundry list of agenda items come January make it unlikely lawmakers will tackle allies’ priorities with any alacrity. And, even then, it’s not clear they will suddenly return to the fold.

“No one is saying: ‘Get back to us when you have your shit together,’” said Sen. Andy Kim (D-N.J.). “They understand that things are going to be challenging even two years from now.”