Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

How The White House Lost Faith In Sean Cairncross

Card image cap


After the White House abruptly announced that National Cyber Director Sean Cairncross would step down, the president offered a more succinct explanation to reporters on Friday: “I didn’t think that person was good enough.”

Cairncross has served as the national cyber director since his Senate confirmation last summer, when Democratic lawmakers grilled him about his lack of cyber expertise. At the time, the former top Republican National Committee official and CEO of the Millennium Challenge Corporation pledged to “surround myself with smart people to make sure the right people are in the right place to do the jobs and take their advice.”

But Cairncross soon found himself at the center of the administration’s response to increasingly powerful artificial intelligence models this spring, which some U.S. and industry officials felt he wasn't equipped to handle. One U.S. official said at the time that Cairncross and his understaffed office “are a little bit over their head.”

On Thursday, his lack of experience, coupled with the recent loss of one of his close Cabinet-level allies, former White House Chief of Staff Susie Wiles, caught up with him.

“It has been the honor of a lifetime to serve President Donald J. Trump,” Cairncross said in a statement Thursday evening. ”I leave my role as Director of Cyber incredibly proud of our work to strengthen America’s cybersecurity, protect our critical infrastructure, confront foreign threats, and position America to lead the world in Super Intelligence,” referencing the administration’s preferred term for AI.

A person familiar with Cairncross’s thinking told POLITICO that “he resigned” and was not fired. This person also rebutted concerns about Cairncross’ inexperience. “The president nominated him, he was Senate-confirmed, and was in the job for a year and a half.”

Cairncross did not immediately respond to a request for comment. A spokesperson for Wiles declined to comment.

POLITICO spoke with four people familiar with Cairncross’ tenure, which they described as rocky. Many in Washington were initially willing to give him a chance, and some hoped that his close relationship to Republican leadership would earn him Trump’s ear.

“Cairncross was completely unqualified and was given a lot of grace from the Hill and industry from the start,” said one senior administration official, who, like the others in this story, was granted anonymity to speak candidly about Cairncross’ leadership. “As soon as Susie’s departure was announced, his clock was ticking.”

As one industry source familiar with the situation put it: “Stephen Miller is cleaning house of all Susie’s people.” He described Cairncross as “well-liked enough but not in Miller’s camp.”

A White House official, granted anonymity to discuss private conversations, told POLITICO Friday that “searching for a new head of the ONCD was one of the first things Stephen did as Chief of Staff. At the start of his first week, he began to run a replacement search behind the scenes.” They did not comment on whether Cairncross resigned or not.

Cairncross secured several major wins over the last 15 months. His office’s crowning achievement was releasing a national cyber strategy in March that laid out the administration’s priorities for enhancing the nation’s digital resilience, including boosting its offensive cyber operations.

He also helped shape an executive order on AI, signed by Trump in June, that asks AI labs to voluntarily submit new models to the federal government for testing before public release, and spearheaded a program that provides free cybersecurity services to water utilities in Texas after nationwide cyberattacks earlier this year.

But his work on the executive order this past summer exposed gaps in his cyber knowledge, frustrating those around him. Some worried that the administration’s slow response to AI, at a time when competition with China was growing, made the U.S. lose its edge.

Cairncross and his office had few “technical people” left to rely on after a series of cuts trimmed the office down, said the cybersecurity official.

“The office has been reduced to no more than 25 current staff, with no more than 10 political appointees, mostly junior,” the current senior administration official added, a significant reduction from prior staffing under President Joe Biden.

Wiles chose Cairncross to lead discussions around how the government would respond to AI earlier this year after AI giant Anthropic announced its most powerful model, Mythos, could find bugs and launch cyberattacks across operating systems at an unseen speed and scale. Anthropic launched Project Glasswing, a program that gave select companies and organizations special access to the unreleased Mythos to familiarize themselves with it before it launched to the public.

Cairncross assembled working groups to safely integrate the technology into critical systems, though his approach was not always well received by his government and industry collaborators.

According to the cybersecurity official, the White House’s actions “completely squandered the lead Anthropic tried to give us with Glasswing.”

Anthropic did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

A series of outages across the federal government and private systems this past week left the administration scrambling to unify its messaging, and ONCD was noticeably absent from public statements. While officials have stressed that the technical issues — which led to a nationwide ground stop and disruptions to classified internal systems, among others — are likely unrelated and not caused by cyberattacks, they have raised concerns that AI is further straining the nation’s cyber defenses.

“Shit’s hitting the fan,” said the cybersecurity official. “I’m certain he’s been getting asked a lot of questions over the last week that he is just not able to answer.”

The White House announced late Thursday night that Kirsten Davies, the Pentagon’s chief information officer, will take over as interim national cyber director.

Her selection suggests Trump may be taking the White House’s cybersecurity response more seriously. Davies glided through her nomination process for the Pentagon role, and she has extensive cyber experience at companies including Unilever, Hewlett-Packard and Siemens.

“Our nation stands in the crossroad of analog, digital, and quantum technologies, our American way of living increasingly interconnected,” Davies tweeted Thursday night. “Our opportunity is to dominate the cyber landscape for generations to come … but only if we modernize and drive resilience into the foundations our great nation runs on, as well as build cyber talent for our future.”

The White House did not respond to a request for comment on whether Davies will be nominated to serve in the role permanently. Trump only has until Jan. 3 to get a nominee cleared through the Senate before Democrats take control.

Some Senate Democrats hope the White House puts someone with stronger cyber credentials in the national cyber director seat.

“Sean Cairncross was a political hack without a lick of cybersecurity experience,” Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) said on the Senate floor Friday. “Instead of another politically connected crony, we should have hardworking, career cybersecurity experts take the lead.”

John Sakellariadis, Brendan Bordelon, Owen Dahlkamp, Sophia Cai and William Steakin contributed reporting.