Labor Pains Could Be Greens' Gains In Victoria
MELBOURNE — On the High Street of Northcote voters are concerned about the direction of Victorian politics.
But it's not crime or construction corruption that drives anger in Melbourne’s progressive inner north towards the Ben Carroll-led Labor Government. It’s federal Labor’s handling of the Gaza conflict, and a fine judgment call about which party of the left is best equipped to take on the rising far-right.
After 12 years of Labor government, the Coalition led by Jess Wilson is likely to ride a wave of discontent to government at the Nov. 28 poll — with or without support from One Nation — as conservative parties top polls in regional cities and suburban areas.
But in inner-Melbourne, the capital of a traditionally progressive state dubbed Australia’s Massachusetts by former conservative prime minister John Howard, voters are choosing between the parties of the left: Labor and the Greens.
In one Oct. 30 to Nov. 5 DemosAU/PremierNational poll with a sample size of 1,562 voters, Labor’s vote was down seven points, to 18%, and the Greens up three points, to 17%, putting them on the verge of the previously unthinkable — supplanting Labor as the dominant party of the left.
Despite the same poll showing the Liberal-Nationals ahead with 33% of the primary vote, and 56% of the two-party preferred, the Greens federal leader David Shoebridge posted on X that the “blunami is turning Green.”
“A massive community-powered Green wave is set to overtake Labor in the latest Victorian election polls. Money and greed might be a feature of politics, but people power can defeat them,” Shoebridge claimed.
At the 2022 election, the Greens won four lower house seats, all in inner-city Melbourne: Brunswick, Melbourne, Prahran and Richmond, although Prahran was later lost to the Liberals at a by-election triggered by MP Sam Hibbins’ resignation.
A clutch of seats in Melbourne’s north were knife-edge results, with Labor edging the Greens out, by as little as 0.2% in Northcote and 2% in Pascoe Vale and Preston.
In more than a dozen voter conversations in Northcote, locals cited their main issues as affordable housing, the adequacy of welfare, climate action, combating the rise of the far-right and parties’ stance on Palestine — an issue the Greens have capitalized on by more forcefully denouncing Israel’s military action in Gaza as a genocide.
Ash, who declined to share her family name, nominated Palestine, cost of living, refugee rights and the environment as her top issues. She said she will “probably vote for the Greens” and “wouldn’t say Labor” is best at handling these issues because “the major parties can be too similar.”
Eamonn Hayes said he would like to see free public transport, and has been turned off by some of Labor’s recent announcements aiming to get tougher on crime. “It’s a false flag, this focus on youth crime," rejecting Labor plans for more police. He said he has “beef with federal Labor” who he says are “puppets of the U.S.”

Cath Wangeman, from Thornbury, identifies as a gay woman, a “left voter,” who explained she will vote for whoever she judges the most humanitarian party. “I’m still undecided. I’ve always voted Labor." Wangeman is skeptical of candidates who vie for attention only in campaign season. "They’re all over you like a rash now, they weren’t doing that two months ago,” she said.
“For me it’s all about being kind and you can’t vote right and be kind at the same time.”
Mel, a doctor who works in the public health system, said her top issues are health funding, continuing major projects and “corruption, the Labor party sorting out their relationship with the unions.”
Mel, who lives in the eastern suburbs near the suburban rail loop under construction, said she is generally a Labor voter. She thinks the Greens have “good solutions” to many problems like better school funding but at times they can also offer “unrealistic policies,” including federal Greens' promising to reduce mortgage interest rates.
Alistair, from Northcote, likes the Greens and Labor but wants “realistic” action on climate change, suggesting “it’s easy as a minority party to promise the world.”
“I don’t warm to him [Ben Carroll] personally. He seems worthy and earnest, but he’s up against it, the corruption allegations [in relation to the infrastructure big build] … I can’t see Labor overcoming that legacy,” he said.
In Ben Carroll’s seat of Niddrie, in north-west Melbourne, left-wing voters face a similar dilemma.

Daniella said she is “concerned about the rise of the far-right in this country and this electorate,” accusing One Nation of “piling on immigrants, as if that’s the problem, with no real policy solutions.”
“I think it’s absolutely disgusting that the Liberal leader [Jess Wilson] has said she will preference One Nation. To even countenance [that], as a serious political party, is absolutely staggering to me.”
A Labor voter in her 20s and 30s, Daniella said she will vote for the Victorian Socialists first, Greens second, and Labor third. She cited Palestine and “the complete lack of honesty and transparency” on the Gaza conflict as a key driver of her vote.
“I would not vote for One Nation, ever,” said Sonya, another Niddrie local leaning toward Labor and the Greens as parties best suited to tackle the cost of living, low wages and the housing crisis. “But I did not like Albanese and Penny Wong supporting the war in Palestine,” she added.
Across the state, the polls bear out that Labor is in trouble: the Coalition is averaging 31% of the vote across the state, on track for majority government; One Nation is on 22%, narrowly ahead of Labor (21.8%), which is in third place; and the Greens have 14.5%.
The inner city contests are difficult to pick, though, with Labor and the Greens squabbling over whether they should have a tight preferencing alliance, or not. Typically the 85% to 90% of Labor and Greens' voters preference the other party ahead of the Coalition and One Nation.
But Labor’s decision to run an open ticket in Prahran will hurt the Greens’ chances of recapturing the seat. The Liberals’ decision to preference Labor over Greens in Northcote, Brunswick and Richmond could make the difference in those seats.
The Victorian election is an important series of litmus tests: for One Nation’s attempt to break through, Jess Wilson’s argument that only the Coalition can defeat Labor, and whether the Greens can profit from anti-major-party sentiment into the 2028 federal election.
Popular Products
-
Classic Oversized Teddy Bear$23.78 -
Gem's Ballet Natural Garnet Gemstone ...$171.56$85.78 -
Butt Lifting Body Shaper Shorts$95.56$47.78 -
Slimming Waist Trainer & Thigh Trimmer$67.56$33.78 -
Realistic Fake Poop Prank Toys$99.56$49.78