Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

Nih Asks If Fauci Secretly Wrote Paper That Dismissed Covid Lab Leak Theory

Card image cap


National Institutes of Health leaders may have been more involved in the influential March 2020 paper that sought to end debate about Covid’s origins than they’ve let on, according to Jay Bhattacharya, the lockdown critic who succeeded them atop the government’s health research agency.

The paper attributed to five leading virologists, but not then-top NIH officials Anthony Fauci and Francis Collins, led news organizations and public health experts to dismiss evidence that pointed to a lab leak.

Bhattacharya in a Wednesday letter to the editors of Nature Medicine suggests that Fauci and Collins may have written the paper, and asks the editors to investigate the paper’s authorship, correct the record or retract it. It’s the latest salvo in the now-years-long campaign by critics of the Covid response and Republicans to discredit Fauci.

“The NIH is presenting the question of whether the byline and acknowledgments accurately reflect the individuals who contributed substantively to the conception, drafting, revision, or publication of the manuscript,” Bhattacharya wrote.

In August, a Senate committee led by Kentucky Republican Rand Paul voted to hold Fauci in contempt for his refusal to testify before it on Covid’s origins. The panel then asked the Justice Department to prosecute him. It has not done so.

Fauci and Collins did not immediately respond to requests for comment. Nature Medicine declined to comment pending receipt of the letter.

The dispute over the article and its authorship has become a proxy for broader fights over whether the pandemic originated in a lab in Wuhan, China or came directly from nature and whether U.S. officials exerted undue influence to stamp out debate.

Bhattacharya’s letter cites congressional investigative findings showing Fauci and Collins were included in communications related to “The Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2” paper and were sent drafts. It also cites the involvement of Jeremy Farrar, a biologist who was advising the British government at the time, in organizing a Feb. 1, 2020 meeting where concerns about the Covid origin were discussed. The meeting was the starting point for the drafting of the article. Farrar later provided comments and helped facilitate the paper’s publication. Farrar did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Bhattacharya wants the Nature Medicine editors to provide within 30 days a planned scope of their review and a timetable.

“The proximal origin” paper’s listed authors were Kristian Andersen, Andrew Rambaut, W. Ian Lipkin, Edward Holmes and Robert F. Garry.

Andersen is a professor in the department of immunology and microbiology at Scripps Research. Rambaut teaches at the School of Biological Sciences at the University of Edinburgh in the United Kingdom. Lipkin is an epidemiologist and professor at Columbia University in New York. Holmes is an evolutionary biologist and a professor at the University of Sydney in Australia. Garry is a professor at the Tulane University School of Medicine.

The article said a lab origin of the pandemic was not plausible, based on the virus features, which existed in related viruses in nature.

The CIA, FBI and the Department of Energy have since assessed with a low or moderate level of confidence that the pandemic likely started as a result of a lab leak. The Office of the Director of National Intelligence has also described the Covid origin as a lab leak, but the declassified documents it published this summer did not reveal any new substantial evidence about it.

Congress passed legislation in 2023 requiring the Biden administration to release all intelligence related to the pandemic’s origins. The 10-page document it released that June did not provide evidence supporting either a lab leak or natural origin.

German media reports have said the country’s foreign intelligence service assessed as early as 2020 that a laboratory accident in Wuhan was the likely origin of the pandemic. The German government has declined to publicly confirm the reported assessment.

Most congressional Republicans believe a lab leak occurred. Some of them, led by Paul, have tried to have Fauci, who led for decades the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, an NIH division, held in contempt of Congress and jailed.

Paul’s Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee voted on party lines to hold Fauci in contempt in August after the longtime government scientist refused to testify before it, citing his right to avoid self-incrimination. The full Senate never voted on it.

Fauci said he wasn’t covering anything up and was exercising his 5th Amendment rights because Paul was hellbent on prosecuting him. Former President Joe Biden gave Fauci a preemptive pardon before leaving office in January 2025.

Polls show most Americans now believe a lab leak was the likely origin of the pandemic, but there is still no scientific consensus. Some virologists argue that it started when an infected animal passed on the virus to people, most likely at a live animal market in Wuhan, while others argue that it likely came from a lab in that city that was researching coronaviruses.

Fauci’s NIAID funded research on coronavirus at the Wuhan lab, but Fauci, other NIH officials and the recipients of the research funding have argued that the experiments conducted with that money could not have led to the development of the virus that sparked the Covid pandemic. The U.S. research group that received that funding, EcoHealth Alliance, was barred from receiving further government funding by the Biden administration in 2024 for failing to adhere to oversight protocols.

Researchers who’ve long believed a lab leak was more likely the pandemic’s cause have already requested Nature Medicine retract the study.

Conversations among the authors of “The proximal origin” article published by the nonprofit group U.S. Right to Know and the House Oversight and Accountability Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic revealed that some of them initially thought the virus could have come from a lab.

When the subcommittee questioned two of the authors — Andersen and Garry — about it in a 2023 hearing, they said their position evolved when presented with new evidence showing some of the characteristics the coronavirus shared with similar viruses found in nature.

“This is not a flip-flop. This is simply the scientific process,” Andersen told lawmakers at the time.

Fauci told the subcommittee in a June 2024 hearing that Andersen sent him drafts of the article but that he didn’t edit it.

The NIH has said in the past that Collins was not an author and did not weigh in on the content.

Republican and Democratic lawmakers in Congress have released dueling reports into Collins and Fauci’s involvement in the paper and the origins of the virus. In July 2023, House Republicans on the Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic released a 55-page report accusing Collins and Fauci of exerting undue influence on the paper in order to “kill the lab leak theory” and “avoid blaming China for the Covid-19 pandemic.” That same month, House Democrats released a report disproving those allegations.

Bhattacharya, a former Stanford professor of medicine, is among the Covid contrarians elevated to senior roles in the Trump administration. In October 2020, he co-authored the Great Barrington Declaration, the manifesto that spurred a movement against Covid lockdowns, alongside Martin Kulldorff, a former Harvard professor who now serves in a senior role at the Health Department, and Oxford professor Sunetra Gupta. Prior to his appointment to NIH, Bhattacharya had served on the board of Biosafety Now, a nonprofit focused on lab-generated pandemics.

In an October 2020 email after the publication of the Great Barrington Declaration, Collins told Fauci that the proposal to end lockdowns from “three fringe epidemiologists” was getting a lot of attention and required “a quick and devastating published take down of its premises.”

Bhattacharya has long argued that the scientific establishment censored him and other Covid response critics. In 2024, the Supreme Court ruled against him and other plaintiffs who’d accused the Biden administration of coercing Twitter, Facebook and other social media sites to censor them.

The Telegraph’s Sarah Knapton contributed to this report.

Tim Röhn is the senior editor of the Axel Springer Global Reporters Network.