The Democratic Divide Is Smaller Than You Think
Democrats just won power on the strength of a big backlash to President Donald Trump. There’s lots of talk now that the party’s activist left will overread the results and overreach with plans for a big expansion of government and a tighter leash on corporations and the rich.
As if on cue, one would-be Democratic presidential contender gave a speech Monday afternoon calling business leaders “pathetic” for not doing more to stand up to Trump policies. He urged the elimination of lucrative tax preferences for private-equity firms and investors, and the imposition of higher inheritance taxes on people transferring fortunes to their children. This politician proposed expensive new entitlements like free tuition for students who come from families making less than $200,000 annually. There was also an appeal to reverse punitive immigration policies with big cuts to federal immigration enforcement and a reform bill that would give a path to citizenship for undocumented residents. Cumulatively, the speech read like a manifesto not simply for repealing the Trump years, but several decades of conservative orthodoxy.
There’s a problem, however, with this particular contribution to the "Overreaching Left" narrative. The speech was delivered by Rahm Emanuel — the former Chicago mayor and Obama chief of staff who has fashioned a long career as a centrist and mistrusts his party’s activists on the left as much as they mistrust him.
Emanuel’s address at Carnegie Mellon University is part of an ongoing head-down, horns-out campaign to charge his way into the top-tier presidential contention — despite a widespread perception that he lacks the requisite ideological and generational profile to lead the party in 2028.
Whether he’s successful in changing those perceptions likely won’t be known for another year or so. For now, however, the speech is an arresting sign of the times, suggesting that the supposedly wide gulf between left and center in the Democratic Party may be a bit overblown.
All through 2026, as self-described democratic socialists knocked out incumbents in primaries in New York and elsewhere, and centrist groups like Third Way scolded the left for potentially endangering the party’s midterm prospects, commentary about the Democrats intramural tensions made it seem the party somehow is facing an intractable knot. The tensions aren’t imaginary. But it could be they represent a loose and highly tractable knot.
It’s not so much that Emanuel is self-consciously swinging left or trying to cultivate a less combative persona. He still believes large government deficits are a problem even though many in both parties long ago stopped caring, and in his Monday speech he took aim at “a wing of my party [that] thinks the problem with capitalism is capitalism.” He complained that the Democratic Party as a whole has “allowed Trump to occupy so much of our brain that we have become intellectually lazy and politically timid. We’ve spent so much of our time arguing over how to divide the pie that we forgot how to grow it.”
The implied argument of Emanuel’s address is that abstract philosophical arguments about government and free enterprise can be transcended by concrete policy specifics. In this light, there may be many who want to go further than he does — more robust public spending or more coercive policies on the rich — but these are matters of degree rather than of first principles.
That’s different than the internal debates facing the Republican Party in its post-Trump future, in which the GOP’s different wings have not easily reconcilable philosophies on free trade, the Iran and Ukraine wars, the value of the NATO alliance, how closely to align with Israel and so on.
On the Democratic side, the more infected pressure points tend to be on cultural and identity politics issues. But even avatars of the left like Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez said last summer that the early “Woke 1” movement went too far, and new stars like Texas Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa said after the election that she is not interested in cultural issues but things that affect the everyday economic lives of her voters.
Emanuel sees this as fertile ground, not by renouncing capitalism but making it swallow stiff medicine. “Corruption is a cancer at capitalism’s core,” he said, citing the Trump administration’s “pay to play” ethos in transacting with wealthy interests who want to win favors or avoid punishment is. Among his proposed reforms: A broad ban on stock trading or playing futures markets by all government employees and mandatory “blind trusts” for government appointees with over a million dollars in assets. He also backed what he called the “Jared Kushner rule,” which prohibits accepting gifts or investment dollars while in office and for two years afterward.
On taxes, he said the practice of wealthy families borrowing against their equity to cover living expenses tax-free should be banned, as should preferential treatment for capital gains. He wants them taxed the same as ordinary income and wants the elimination of the so-called carried interest provision, which gives lucrative advantages to private-equity transactions.
On education, he said Trump’s “GOP walked away from public schools,” while Democrats were complicit in “shutter[ing] school for too long during the pandemic.” While affordability takes the emphasis at the college level, tougher standards — like longer school days, more rigorous curriculums and crackdown on absenteeism — are the answer at younger levels, he argued.
On energy, he said the country must produce much more from all sources with government incentives in some cases, and he wants a tax on big tech companies, as huge energy consumers must be taxed to pay for needed improvements to the electrical grid.
Emanuel has said he doesn’t know if he can win the nomination but wants to win “the ideas primary.” This speech suggests that contest might be less divisive — and possibly more substantive — than seemed likely before the decisive shift in power earlier this month.
Popular Products
-
Put Me Down Funny Toilet Seat Sticker$33.56$16.78 -
Stainless Steel Tongue Scrapers$33.56$16.78 -
Stylish Blue Light Blocking Glasses$85.56$42.78 -
Adjustable Ankle Tension Rope$53.56$26.78 -
Electronic Bidet Toilet Seat$981.56$490.78