The Generational Change Debate Has Reached The Congressional Black Caucus
The Congressional Black Caucus has long served as the top champion for House Democrats’ strict seniority system, beating back multiple attempts to encourage turnover in the top party echelon.
Now the calls for generational change inside the party are coming from within its own ranks.
Several long-tenured Black committee leaders are looking to get their gavels back when Democrats retake the majority in January. They include Rep. Bennie Thompson of Mississippi, who is 78; Rep. Bobby Scott of Virginia, who is 79; and Rep. Maxine Waters of California, who is 88. All have served at least a decade atop their respective committees — Homeland Security, Education and Workforce, and Financial Services.
But many newer and some senior members are saying they’re open to supporting term limits, defying a longstanding CBC position in favor of seniority that defenders say has been the cornerstone of Black power on Capitol Hill. Multiple committee leaders are facing insurgent challengers, with Scott staring down a contest with a fellow CBC member, Rep. Jahana Hayes of Connecticut.
“Debate is always a good thing,” Rep. Shomari Figures of Alabama said in an interview, acknowledging the difference of opinions in the caucus. “CBC looks a lot different now than it did 10 years ago, let alone 20 or 30 years ago.”
The newly emerging divisions inside the CBC on the term-limits issue come at a moment of triumph for the powerful caucus. Its ranks will swell to more than 60 members next year after Black candidates defied Republican attempts to eliminate minority-majority districts with mid-cycle redistricting.
The debate is expected to play out over the next two weeks ahead of a caucus rules vote in early December. Rep. Susie Lee of Nevada is proposing to establish a four-term limit on committee leadership, which would force Scott, Thompson and Waters out of their posts after the coming Congress unless they seek a waiver. The same would be true for Rep. Gregory Meeks of New York, who leads Democrats on Foreign Affairs.
The evolving perspectives inside the CBC are one reason, many observers say, that a Democratic term limits proposal could actually be adopted this year. Republicans have had a three-term limit for their committee leaders in place for more than 30 years, though waivers have been granted in some circumstances allowing members to serve longer.
Meeks, a former CBC chair, and Rep. Yvette Clarke of New York, the current chair, oppose committee term limits, evoking well-known and previously effective arguments that minority members can find it harder to pull key levers of internal power — such as fundraising — and that seniority is an effective equalizer.
“I think the voters make the determination on term limits,” Rep. Jim Clyburn of South Carolina said in an interview. “I think that we have to protect seniority in this place.”
Clyburn, for years the highest-ranking Black leader in Congress, has also noted in the past that Black lawmakers of his generation had to work harder to get elected to office, meaning they often started later in their careers than their white counterparts.
But that seniority principle no longer enjoys near-universal agreement in the caucus ranks. In a sign of the sea change, CBC member and presumptive speaker Hakeem Jeffries is letting the term-limits debate play out, last week calling it “the right conversation to have.”
“Like anything else, members of the CBC have different ideas,” said Rep. Troy Carter of Louisiana, who is running unopposed to lead the caucus next year. “We're not a monolith, and we encourage people to have their own thoughts and ideas.”
For all the clout it affords the most veteran Democrats, the seniority system can seem daunting to younger members who face the prospect of having to serve a decade or more before winning a gavel on a choice committee. And some new and existing CBC members are speaking out.
“I think it should be considered,” Rep.-elect La Shawn Ford of Illinois said in an interview about term limits for committee leaders. “You do want experienced people on leading committees, but I don't think that it should be the only factor that determines a chair vote.”
The internal debate has been dramatically underscored by Hayes’ run against Scott for the top job on the Education and Workforce Committee, which is likely to be renamed Education and Labor under Democratic control.
“I understand why CBC had long-held positions because things had not been fair for a very long time,” Hayes said in an interview. But, she added, “the caucus is getting bigger and bigger, and people come with different backgrounds and different perspectives.“
Clarke said the CBC is unlikely to wade into the Hayes vs. Scott race, explaining that the caucus doesn’t typically endorse in committee chair contests. (Rep. Suzanne Bonamici of Oregon, who is not a member of the CBC, is also running for the Education gavel and has vowed to serve no more than four years).
But last month, Clarke issued a statement of support for Waters, who is seeking an eighth term leading Democrats on the Financial Services Committee against a bid from Rep. Sean Casten of Illinois. She said the CBC is “unwavering in its support” of the longtime leader.
At least one CBC member, Rep. Shontel Brown of Ohio, is running for a vacant role atop the Agriculture Committee against the more senior Rep. Jim Costa of California. A second, Rep. Don Davis of North Carolina, has talked to colleagues about running.
While the debate is breaking down on perhaps predictable generational lines, there are some complications to that narrative.
Rep.-elect Melat Kiros of Colorado said in an interview she is supporting Waters’ bid to remain atop the Financial Services panel past her 90th birthday, while also saying “term limits are important so that we can start building the bench.”
“I think term limits are important, and I think it's also important that we make sure that we're still seeing representation on a lot of these different committees,” she said.
Some longtime members, meanwhile, are at least open to a debate.
Rep. Bonnie Watson Coleman of New Jersey is retiring after 12 years in the House. Much of that she spent on the Appropriations Committee, where she never even led a subcommittee. (She did chair a Homeland Security subcommittee at one point.)
“I see both sides — I really see the value of institutional knowledge and experience,” she said, pointing to Thompson’s service atop Homeland Security and the Jan. 6 select committee.
But she pointed to two younger members — Reps. Jamie Raskin of Maryland and Robert Garcia of California — who beat out more seasoned members to take over the Judiciary and Oversight panels, respectively.
“It kind of works out sometimes,” she said.
Popular Products
-
Fake Pregnancy Test$61.56$30.78 -
Anti-Slip Safety Handle for Elderly S...$57.56$28.78 -
Toe Corrector Orthotics$41.56$20.78 -
Waterproof Trauma Medical First Aid Kit$169.56$84.78 -
Rescue Zip Stitch Kit$109.56$54.78