Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

The Vibes Are Bad For Chuck Schumer

Card image cap


After being elected to the Senate in 1998, Chuck Schumer didn’t want to work out in the Capitol Hill gym reserved for senators. 

He had used the House gym for nearly two decades as a representative for Brooklyn and, in public, he said that he saw it as a productive environment for recruiting House Democrats to run for Senate. But in private, he also told friends and colleagues that he preferred the House facility because of the youthful vibes.

The senators exercised with medicine balls — something he saw as a sign of old age and approaching retirement, according to a person who heard those remarks and was granted anonymity to relay them.

His House gym habits didn’t last. It’s been years since the veteran New York Democrat switched over to exercising in the Senate gym, where he can still be spotted using his flip phone, another relic of a bygone era. 

In fact, a lot has changed even if his phone hasn’t. Now it is Schumer who faces the same question he used to ponder for the aging senators he once watched from afar: Is it almost time for retirement? 


gettyimages-674205610.jpg

Schumer’s current Senate term expires in 2028, and interviews with Democrats in New York and Washington suggest that moment could mark the end of Schumer’s accomplished career one way or another. Some believe he will retire, and others are urging him to. Otherwise, they warn, he risks a bruising, potentially career-ending primary.

New York City Council member Gale Brewer, a former Manhattan borough president who has known and worked with Schumer for decades, said she remains “a big fan” of him and “how much he has done for New York.”

But Brewer, 75, said she, for one, isn’t running for any more elected offices when her Council term expires in 2029 and added of Schumer, “We’re the same age, and I know how hard it is to keep going.” 

Others are blunter.

“No way he sticks around,” said one Democratic consultant who has worked for top lawmakers on Capitol Hill for years and who was granted anonymity to speak candidly. “If anybody around him loves him, they’ll convince him to retire before AOC embarrasses him. The world has passed him by.”

Such sentiment is not universal; Schumer still has plenty of supporters in the party, including those who aren’t convinced he’ll hit the exits. But the notion that his time in office will wind down in the next two years is shared by many in Democratic politics, albeit mostly in private, to avoid getting crosswise with a powerful politician or ruining personal relationships.

Even those closest to him do not seem sure he seeks another term.

“We’ll see what Chuck will do. We’re still figuring it out,” Schumer’s wife, Iris Weinshall, told a New York elected official before the midterm elections when asked about her husband’s 2028 plans. 

The official, who was granted anonymity to discuss the private conversation, said Weinshall’s remark was surprising, especially given her role as a longtime political sounding board for her husband.

“That she was sort of equivocating to me seemed remarkable,” the official told POLITICO Magazine. “If he was all in, she would not have said that.”

A Schumer spokesperson denied Weinshall made the remark about her husband’s 2028 plans.

In a statement responding to questions about his future, Schumer touted his record of delivering for New York.

“New York is in my heart and soul — I’m a Brooklyn boy, and son of an exterminator who made it all the way to the leadership of the U.S. Senate. I love this state and I love New Yorkers. That is why — no matter where I was in leadership over the years, and particularly amid crises — I made sure to deliver for New York, from securing the billions to rebuild downtown after the 9/11 terror attacks, to delivering the $62 billion in the aftermath of Hurricane Sandy, to protecting our upstate, downstate workforce and our transit systems, as well as our cultural institutions, like Broadway, during Covid,” Schumer said.

“We have a great delegation, strong, diverse and teeming with talent,” he added. “I work hard. I care. I listen. I deliver — for workers, for farmers, for families, for seniors. The formula of working hard and delivering big time for New York will always remain the center of all I do.”

Asked separately Wednesday if he would consider announcing that he won’t run in 2028 to help shore up support for a leadership battle he is expected to win, Schumer said, “I’m focused on 2027 and delivering for the American people.”

The pressure on Schumer to craft his departure from politics is a stunning development considering Democrats are poised to hold a whopping 56-seat Senate majority next year — in large part thanks to him. For all the “past-his-prime” jabs he’s endured, it was Schumer who helped recruit successful candidates in North Carolina and Ohio and Alaska and beyond. The national environment was obviously a huge drag on President Donald Trump and the GOP, but it was Schumer, his supporters note, who charted the course to sweep a series of red states and bring the once-longshot majority into being.

“Chuck Schumer is the master of the Senate. He shows no signs of slowing down,” Rep. Ritchie Torres (D-N.Y.), whose name has also been floated as a potential Schumer successor, said when asked about pressure on the senator to retire. “He could easily serve another term, and deservedly so. When you succeed as a leader, you should be rewarded.”

Several other New York Democrats reached out with praise for Schumer after POLITICO Magazine asked his office for comment, including James Skoufis, a state senator who represents parts of the Hudson Valley and predicted that “his poll numbers will bounce back among Democrats and he’ll be well positioned to run for reelection if he chooses to.”

Yet rather than celebrating his and the party’s success, a growing number of Democrats are speaking out against Schumer nationally, and he faces a challenge to lead the caucus from Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen. At a time of what should be great triumph, Schumer is being forced to confront his own weaknesses and the uncertainty about his future.

The skepticism facing Schumer back home and in Washington is two-fold. Sometimes the resistance is ideological, coming from those on the left who believe he is too moderate and won’t fight Trump aggressively enough.

Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont, a prominent voice on the left, said last week that he will not back Schumer’s bid no matter what. 

“I personally have known Chuck Schumer for over 30 years. And I like Chuck — nobody works harder than Chuck Schumer. But in my view the time is now for change, and I will not be supporting Chuck to be reelected as the Democratic leader,” Sanders told reporters.

There are also centrists who say new leadership is needed to chart a path forward for the party. The more moderate Democratic Sen. Elissa Slotkin of Michigan, who has 2028 ambitions, said she was “seeking change” and a plan from any party leader on how they would approach the first 100 days of the new majority.

Schumer was once considered one of the nation’s preeminent political strategists, both in Washington and New York. But at 75 years old and in a fast-changing ideological, political and media environment, his once formidable tactics may no longer work.

In private, some Democratic senators say they’d feel more comfortable publicly backing Schumer’s bid to become majority leader again if he agrees to retire in 2028, both because of his age and his wavering standing in the party, according to a person who has spoken with several of Schumer’s colleagues and was granted anonymity to divulge the sensitive conversations. 

“It would be his swan song,” the person said of such a scenario.

Two other people who’ve also spoken directly with senators and were similarly granted anonymity pointed to the lack of clarity about Schumer’s 2028 plans as one factor some members have weighed ahead of the leadership election set for Dec. 1.

Adam Jentleson, a top aide to former Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid and sometime Schumer critic, similarly encouraged Schumer to “go out with grace” and announce a plan to retire at the end of his term upon his election as leader.

No senators have publicly floated a majority leader deal involving a retirement commitment from Schumer, and it’s unlikely anyone will do so before Democrats pick their next leader — especially with Schumer boasting he has the votes to defeat Van Hollen.

A Democratic aide, granted anonymity to speak candidly, said there would be no benefit for senators to publicly make such a demand of Schumer because he wouldn’t agree to it and it wouldn’t satisfy the progressive base, which has long called for a change in caucus leadership and is unlikely to settle for a half-measure.

Several senators have already publicly vowed to support Schumer, and even more, offered anonymity given the sensitivity of the leadership race, have told POLITICO Magazine they intend to support him. Sen. John Hickenlooper (D-Colo.), who is publicly neutral, said Monday that he doesn’t believe Schumer’s 2028 thinking is a factor. Van Hollen, asked if Schumer needed to provide more clarity, said only, “That’s a decision for him.”

With Schumer expected to win the leadership battle, many Democrats view the skirmish as a messy distraction for the party at a time when they should be focused on crafting their agenda for 2027 and projecting a ready-to-go image to voters. It’s “Dems in disarray” all over again — it’s a cliché for a reason — but the outcome matters not just for Schumer and his legacy but for how Democrats move forward.


ap23263773149614.jpg

Meanwhile, his calculations for 2028 are even more fraught. 

If he doesn’t retire that year, he’s all but certain to face a primary challenge from the left, potentially from Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who’s widely popular in New York and is in the process of deciding whether to run for reelection, the Senate or the White House in 2028. In little-noticed remarks late last month, Sanders told MS NOW that he would back Ocasio-Cortez if she ran against Schumer in a 2028 primary. A spokesperson for Ocasio-Cortez declined to comment this week.

Another Senate Democratic aide, granted anonymity to speak candidly, said Schumer should not let the party’s 2026 success influence his reelection calculation: “2028 is just as hard as it was before.”

The Brooklyn-born senator may not be inclined to go quietly into the night, particularly after the Democratic wave that washed over the nation in the midterms. If Democrats keep both chambers of Congress and win the presidency in two years, he’d be relinquishing power right as he’d get a historic chance to make law and further cement his legacy.  And Schumer knows all too well how difficult it can be to convince an aging politician to walk away.

But if he runs for reelection and wins in 2028, Schumer would be 84 at the end of his next term, three years older than former President Joe Biden when he dropped out of the 2024 presidential race amid pressure from fellow Democrats — including Schumer.

Addressing Biden that summer at his Delaware beach house, Schumer told him that by continuing his campaign as voters doubted his vigor, he was putting his own legacy — among other things — at grave risk.

“If I were you,” he reportedly said, “I wouldn’t run, and I’m urging you not to run.”


gettyimages-1421123239.jpg


It wasn’t supposed to be like this. 


For much of his tenure in Congress, Schumer built a reputation for his savvy handle on the media and the kind of retail politics that won him strong approval ratings across the state. 

He became famous for his weekly Sunday press conferences in New York, at which he would highlight even the most parochial issues if they hit close to home for constituents, often receiving favorable coverage from the local tabloids in the process.

“In Chuck’s mind, representing people in Congress always boils down to, ‘What have you done for me lately?’ — with a giant emphasis on lately,” said Stu Loeser, Schumer’s former communications director and a longtime adviser. “That’s why he keeps driving himself and his staff to deliver local results in every part of the state, month after month, year after year.”

Schumer has also been a regular at college commencement ceremonies in New York and has made a point of traveling to each of New York’s 62 counties at least once a year, sometimes embarking to remote parts of upstate in the middle of snowstorms in order to make good on his commitment. He still makes these visits; the website tracking them is dubbed “Chuck Around New York.”

“God gave me a lot of energy,” Schumer said when he finished his 62-county tour in 2023, the 25th straight year of visiting every corner of the state. “Many people said that when I became majority leader, I wouldn’t have time for the 62 county tour, but even though I carry a bigger title in Washington and I now have to lead international trips on diplomacy, my favorite two titles will always be New York’s senator and a New Yorker.”

But Schumer has tamped down his weekly Sunday appearances. And in an age of social media, some see Schumer’s efforts at old-school pizzazz as stale.

“There’s an interesting echo to Cuomo,” said a New York City elected official, who was granted anonymity to speak candidly, referring to former New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, the one-time giant of state Democratic politics who lost the city’s 2025 mayoral race to upstart democratic socialist Zohran Mamdani.

“It’s the same syndrome which is that they came of age so young in the business — they’re each 50 years in and they just have not been able to pivot to the modern world,” the official said. “They both seem much older than they are now. It’s painful to watch.”

Certain key elements of the Cuomo comparison don’t hold up. Unlike Schumer, Cuomo was a magnet for controversy related to his personal behavior during his time in public office. He ultimately resigned as governor in 2021 after facing sexual misconduct accusations that he denies and launched his 2025 mayoral bid as an attempt at reestablishing himself.

Schumer didn’t offer any endorsement during the mayoral race, not even after Mamdani beat Cuomo in the Democratic primary. He then declined to say who he voted for in the general election when Cuomo also ran unsuccessfully as an independent. Mamdani seemed to return the favor last week.

At a news conference in Brooklyn, the mayor — who has endorsed fellow New York Democrat Hakeem Jeffries for House speaker — declined to offer support for Schumer’s majority leader bid in the wake of Van Hollen’s announcement.

Asked directly if he thinks Schumer deserves another term as majority leader, he said the American people showed in the midterm elections that “they want Democratic leadership across the board that will deliver material improvements for the working class,” adding, “I care less about who it is and I care more about what they do with that power.”

Notably, Van Hollen endorsed Mamdani in the 2025 mayoral race after he won the primary and criticized Democrats in Congress who stayed on the sidelines.

The Democratic Party that Schumer rose through the ranks isn’t what it used to be, particularly in New York City, with an ascendant left wing, led by Mamdani, becoming increasingly influential.

In this past June’s congressional primaries, three Mamdani-endorsed leftists defeated more entrenched Democrats, including two incumbents, after riding a wave of anti-establishment sentiment that has coursed through the city. 

With her national star power, fundraising clout and command of social media, Ocasio-Cortez would clearly be a formidable primary opponent to Schumer. Her recent trips to upstate New York and embrace of the Buffalo Bills signal she knows she’ll need to transcend her NYC roots if she runs statewide — and are the exact kind of political maneuvers that Schumer himself would appreciate.

But it’s not just Ocasio-Cortez waiting in the wings. 

New York City Council member Chi Ossé, a democratic socialist who toyed briefly with challenging Jeffries this year, has expressed interest in a potential run against Schumer, especially if Ocasio-Cortez opts to run for president.


20260806patryan14.jpg

And upstate New York Rep. Pat Ryan, an ally of both Ocasio-Cortez and Schumer, has openly said he’s considering a 2028 run, though he’s seen as unlikely to get in if Schumer seeks reelection. 

In a statement to POLITICO Magazine, Ryan said Schumer deserves credit for this month’s midterm romp. 

“Two years ago Leader Schumer said he was fighting to flip the Senate when no one thought it was possible. On [Election Day], he delivered on that incredible promise,” Ryan said. “Whatever he chooses to do next, there’s no question he has set our party up for success when it comes to delivering the change voters are demanding.” 

Schumer has vowed to use his newfound majority to take on Trump, whom he recently dubbed “the most [expletive] corrupt, not only president, but leader, in America we have ever had.”

Perhaps his comments were an effort to persuade skeptical Democratic partisans that he is ready for battle; progressives have long criticized Schumer for not going far enough in standing up to the president. Many are still furious with him for helping advance a GOP government funding bill early last year and then failing to stop centrist members of his caucus from joining Republicans in November 2025 to end a federal shutdown without reversing the president’s health care cuts.

“It’s time to put an end to this era of failed Dem leadership,” Ossé wrote last year on X after a deal was reached.

The party’s left flank has also panned Schumer for his support of Israel at a moment when Democrats hold increasingly negative views of the longtime U.S. ally in the Middle East. (At the same time, more moderate Democrats back in his home state view Schumer skeptically because they feel he has catered too much to the left, with some Jewish Democrats in New York still taking issue with his decision to call for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s ouster in 2024.)

Regardless, if Schumer runs for reelection, he is likely to be in for a brutal fight. His approval rating among New Yorkers sank to 36% in a September poll from Quinnipiac University, with Democrats rating him more favorably, at 56%. Ocasio-Cortez, meanwhile, had stronger support among Democrats and all New Yorkers.


ap26274126516164.jpg


In Washington, there’s already plenty of speculation about who could succeed Schumer atop the Senate Democratic caucus if he retires in 2028.


Sen. Brian Schatz (D-Hawaii), a Schumer ally who is expected to take the No. 2 leadership slot, is viewed as interested and in the mix, but other Democratic senators could jump into the race. A Schumer retirement would also have a major impact on the Senate Democratic campaign arm and other allied political groups, where he’s had a tight grip and been a major fundraising force for years. 

“I support Chuck,” Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, his fellow New Yorker who chairs the Senate Democratic campaign arm, said in an interview about whether she is urging Schumer to run again. “But obviously all of his decisions are his own.” 

There are no signs internally that Schumer — known for being in constant contact with his caucus — is loosening his grip. Since the midterms, Schumer has been talking with sitting senators and meeting with the incoming freshmen to discuss their priorities. While standing next to Schumer last week, Sen. Ruben Gallego (D-Ariz.) jokingly jabbed at that constant outreach, saying that sometimes “I am called to the office more than I want to be called to the office.”

Even as he’s yet to formally dispatch Van Hollen, Schumer laid out the toplines of a 2027 agenda to his caucus during a closed-door meeting last week as he solicited feedback from senators. Part of Schumer’s strategy is intended to spotlight the very same members who will have to figure out how to move the caucus forward if he decides to retire; he frequently compares his job as leader to that of the maestro of an orchestra.

It doesn’t mean that Schumer is stepping off the stage — his affinity for the media can only be suppressed so much — but he wants rank-and-file members, ranging from committee chairs down to freshmen, to be the face of legislation and other pieces of the caucus’ agenda. Perhaps it’s him beginning to pass the torch, but it could also just be the politically savvy thing to do.

Schumer has been around so long that his decades-long record of political success is often overlooked. He had to topple an incumbent to get to the Senate in the first place. Before he helped deliver Democrats the Senate majority in 2026, he did it in 2006 and again in 2020.

Leading the caucus, whether in the minority or the majority, is a different skill set, and critics have their ammunition. But it’s also true that he helped deliver sweeping pieces of trillion-dollar legislation under Biden with the barest of Senate vote margins. Schumer may not be eager to leave the stage or think that he’s so easily replaceable.

There’s no reason to think Schumer isn’t currently healthy enough to do the job, but he’s also turning 76 later this month. He’s watched colleagues in the Senate quickly decline as they’ve confronted health issues in their later years, and the Biden implosion has sparked a demand among Democrats to move away from an American gerontocracy.

The reality of the political climate may be too much, even for someone like Schumer.

“He knows that if he ran again, he would lose renomination,” progressive pollster Adam Carlson recently wrote on X. “Which is why I — and essentially everyone that works in Democratic politics in New York across the ideological spectrum — would be absolutely stunned if he runs for re-election.”


ap26266610635548.jpg

Others are less convinced that he will seize the opportunity to go out on top and fear he might try for one last, ill-fated run.

Three New York City elected officials with histories of supporting Schumer, who were granted anonymity to speak freely about him, all independently of each other said they’re “praying” he doesn’t seek reelection.

Two of them voiced concern that Schumer would be crushed by Ocasio-Cortez or any other progressive Democrat who opts to challenge him.

The third elected official worried about what a competitive primary run would do to Schumer, both physically and to his legacy.

“I just think he would have such a miserable time,” the person said. “His bones must ache.”