Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

Trump’s China Charm Offensive Runs Into A Spy Scandal, Trade Pressure

Card image cap


President Donald Trump’s chummy approach to negotiations with Chinese leader Xi Jinping will face a new kind of test when they meet this week as Congress and administration insiders demand accountability for the Nvidia spying scandal and failure to make good on trade commitments.

Trump’s encounter with Xi in Shenzhen, China, is their third of four meetings planned for 2026. The expectations are low, given the two previous meetings were high on pomp and short on commitments.

Trump has described his relationship with Xi as “a truly great friendship” and has praised him as a "great leader."

“Trump wants the pomp of a presidential welcome and a chance to prove his rapport with Xi can keep the rivalry in check,” said Craig Singleton, a former national security official across Democratic and Republican administrations. Trump sees value in sustaining the “managed stalemate” between the two countries, he said.

Both Trump and Xi have tried to downplay the spy scandal embroiling chipmaker Nvidia ahead of Thursday’s summit, which is taking place on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation leaders’ meeting. U.S. officials say now-former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s relationship with an alleged Chinese intelligence operative likely won’t make the agenda.

“I don’t expect the president to raise it — the Alice Huang issue,” a senior administration official told reporters press briefing ahead of the summit.

The White House did not respond to follow-up questions for this story.

But it — and the larger trade disputes it has sparked — still could overshadow the meeting.

“This scandal will be in the room even if semiconductors aren’t discussed,” said Ker Gibbs, a former president of the American Chamber of Commerce in Shanghai who has regular contact with Chinese officials. “Any concession on technology exports would look like a gift to Beijing at the worst possible moment, especially with Democrats taking control of Congress in January and promising investigations.”

And U.S. lawmakers are pushing for action on tech exports following the revelations about Huang.

Members of Congress including Rep. John Moolenaar (R-Mich.), chair of the House Select Committee on the Chinese Communist Party, and Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) are urging Republican congressional leaders to pass three long-stalled bills that would tighten restrictions on tech exports to China. Rep. Michael McCaul (R-Texas) took to X to call for an immediate pause on all advanced chip exports to China “until we get to the bottom of this incident.” Senate Banking Chair Tim Scott (R-S.C.) plans to haul Huang and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick onto the Hill next month for a grilling on the spy scandal and its implications for national security.

Even if these moves don’t push Trump to address Nvidia, it does highlight the extent to which he is out of step with many back in Washington.

“The bromance will look bad just days after a spy scandal,” Gibbs said. “Expect fewer smiles for the cameras and more pressure to show results.”

Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Mao Ning dismissed lawmakers’ concerns as “a pretext for imposing technology restrictions” in a briefing last week.

Administration officials insist, meanwhile, that Trump plans to address China’s inaction on pledges it has made to buy a raft of Boeing aircraft, import more U.S. agricultural products and lift restrictions on exports of critical minerals to U.S. companies.

The meeting is expected to be “a stock taking” of Beijing’s compliance with trade commitments it has made in prior meetings, a second senior administration official said in the same briefing. Reporters agreed to grant the officials anonymity as a condition of attending the briefing.

Trump, the official said, will make rare earth minerals a key focus.

Beijing is failing to supply rare earths “at the pace and at the level that we would like to be receiving them,” the official said. “We really want to focus minds among our counterparts in China on compliance with this, and I expect the president will raise it with President Xi.”

Those shortfalls have drawn warnings from U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer, who urged China earlier this month to take “concrete actions,” and Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, who told Chinese Vice Premier He Lifeng in a call earlier this month that the administration expects Beijing to “fully and immediately” honor its trade commitments.

China’s foot-dragging has happened despite Trump’s monthslong charm offensive aimed to cajole Xi into closer cooperation. That has included delaying a $14 billion arms sale to Taiwan in May — a concession that violated decades of U.S. policy toward the island — and Xi’s opulent state visit to Washington in September.

Those efforts yielded little more than an extension to January of an agreement that caps tariffs at the double-digit level and a vague commitment to a dialogue on artificial intelligence.

And even if Trump were to press Xi more aggressively on the trade deals, he may find he has limited options.

“The U.S. just doesn't have the leverage to force China to comply right now,” said Emily Kilcrease, a former deputy assistant U.S. trade representative during Trump's first term and under former President Joe Biden. “They can have all the summits they want, but until they figure out the leverage piece, that fundamental challenge doesn't go anywhere.”

Beijing is signaling that it won’t budge anytime soon.

A Chinese Commerce Ministry spokesperson told reporters earlier this month that those promised agricultural buys won’t happen until Beijing and Washington finalize a deal to reduce tariffs on $30 billion in “nonsensitive” imports. Neither Beijing nor Washington have said when that might happen.

Both countries have a vested interest in limiting frictions during the Shenzhen meeting in order to pave the way for an extension of the U.S.-China trade truce that will expire Jan. 10. That kept tariffs at the double-digit level and lifted the ban on rare earth exports that Beijing imposed last year.

But Beijing may be unwilling to consider any longer-term deals, given Trump’s lame-duck status.

China’s leadership “can read a calendar just like anyone else can,” said Mark Lambert, former deputy assistant secretary of State for China and Taiwan under Biden. “Xi knows getting a bilateral deal with the Americans is hard and that any deal that Trump does likely will not stick if there's a Democratic administration to follow in 2028.”