Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

Usmnt Rondo: Did Mauricio Pochettino Get The Best Out Of Christian Pulisic, Is The Pep Guardiola Dream Over - And Who Benefits From A New Boss?

Card image cap

USMNT Rondo GFX - GOAL

As Mauricio Pochettino prepares to depart, GOAL debates his USMNT legacy, Christian Pulisic’s next chapter and whether Pep Guardiola is really out of reach.

The picture is now a little bit clearer.

With Mauricio Pochettino still USMNT manager but not really, there is now a sense of what the program could look like in the days after he leaves.For one, it has been reported that Pep Guardiola, supposedly a top target to replace Poch, is off the market - citing the need to take a year off from management.

And fair play, Pep. That's allowed. So, what now? Well, there are still a few other names in the mix (B.J. Callaghan, anyone?) And outside of that, Poch still has one more fixture to worry about. Sure, the U.S. made easy work of Haiti in the first leg of their Nations League quarterfinal. But there's another game to follow, too.

Since these are the final days of Poch's era, what do we make of them? What of his tenure as a whole? And, if Guardiola truly is off the market, where do the U.S. turn now? GOAL writers break it all down in another edition of... the Rondo.

What was Pochettino's biggest win?

Pochettino and the USMNT battered Paraguay in their World Cup opener - Getty Images Sport
Pochettino and the USMNT battered Paraguay in their World Cup opener

Tom Hindle: The first 40 or so minutes of the World Cup opener against Paraguay. Was anyone expecting that? The vibes were so, so strange coming into that match. The U.S. hadn't looked all that great. Poch ball was not in full effect. It was a case of 'just win the game, PLEASE!' But the manner in which it happened? Wow. Sadly, it peaked there.

Ryan Tolmich: It's easy to forget given all that happened after but, man, were the vibes high post-Australia. The way that team played in front of that rabid Seattle crowd was something special, and it's something that captured the hearts of diehards and casuals alike. That match, for many, was such a high and, despite the rollercoaster that came after, it was the climax.

Alex Labidou: Let’s go with the World Cup opener against Paraguay. It was Pochettino’s vision brought to life: swashbuckling football, sharp execution and an attack that seemed to get almost everything right. The USMNT have made so many gains over the past three decades, but there was something different about watching them dictate a World Cup game that way. Yes, it ultimately unraveled against Belgium in the knockout stages, but that opener gave America permission to dream bigger about its national team.

What was his biggest loss?

The loss to Belgium in the last 16 of the World Cup is perhaps the defining image of the Pochettino era - Getty Images Sport
The loss to Belgium in the last 16 of the World Cup is perhaps the defining image of the Pochettino era

TH: Belgium was bad, obviously. The U.S. capitulated there. Yes, things felt somewhat out of his control - the Folarin Balogun drama got Belgium fired the hell up (which probably says more about American politics than it does their soccer manager). Still, Poch was hired to win those kinds of games. Needless to say, he did not.

RT: Anything other than Belgium here is silly. That was the game that he was ultimately hired to win and, not only did he not win it, but the USMNT were thoroughly beaten, to put it kindly. Does that negate all of the good work leading up to it? No, but it was a major letdown in a summer that looked like it could have gone differently.

AL: The 2025 Nations League was a setback, but Pochettino learned from it, and plenty of positives followed. So this journalist is going with a player instead: Christian Pulisic. He had good games under Pochettino, but the partnership never consistently reached the heights many anticipated. Pochettino deserves credit for finding other players to step up, but too often, America’s best player looked ordinary under the outgoing manager. That feels like a missed opportunity.

Who improved the most during his era?

Berhalter became a key player under Pochettino  - Getty Images Sport
Berhalter became a key player under Pochettino

TH: Alex Freeman. More than anything, the former Orlando City lad needed a bit of trust. Well, how about you rate him so much that you move your locked-in starting right back to right wing to make it happen? Yup.

RT: Take your pick! So many players were able to benefit from the Pochettino era, whether they were veterans or newcomers. If we have to pick one, it has to be Sebastian Berhalter. His own father, Gregg, said he never would have called him up if he were head coach to avoid nepotism allegations, but Pochettino did, and the USMNT were better for it. Berhalter blossomed during his year-and-a-half under the Argentine, and he has repeatedly credited Pochettino for changing his life. Ultimately, that's all a player can ask for: a chance and an opportunity for life-changing moments.

AL: Alex Freeman is the easy choice, but he hadn’t earned a cap before Pochettino arrived. If we’re talking about someone who was already part of the picture under Gregg Berhalter, give me Chris Richards. The potential was always there. Under Pochettino, he became a leader.

Pep has reportedly said 'no'. What does that mean for the USMNT?

With Guardiola reportedly off the market, the U.S. will have to look elsewhere for their next head coach - AFP
With Guardiola reportedly off the market, the U.S. will have to look elsewhere for their next head coach

TH: Well, duh. If Pochettino was bigger than the U.S. job, then what would that make Pep? Guardiola is the best manager on the planet, but that does not mean he is the right one for the U.S. job. Give it to B.J. Callaghan and move on.

RT: No surprise. Guardiola is a long shot, at best, and every single star would need to align to make that hire happen. At the moment, there are several stars seemingly out of line, both on the timeline side and on Guardiola's side. That's a bummer, particularly for those of us who follow this team regularly, but there are still plenty of other options to build on the foundation Pochettino laid.



AL: The Telegraph’s reporting deserves to be taken seriously, but if Guardiola is willing to hear U.S. Soccer out, I wouldn’t completely close the door. I can see a scenario where the U.S. hires an interim and waits for the former Manchester City boss. But there’s also a legitimate question about fit. His exacting demands and occasionally prickly personality might clash with the U.S.’s generally kumbaya vibes and a young team still finding itself. That said, Pep is still box office. Let’s see how this shakes out.

Who impressed during Leg 1 of the Haiti Nations League tie?

TH: Hell of a game from Julian Hall, who looks like the real deal when he wants to be. Does he have the raw quality of Folarin Balogun? Nope. But he's a really talented footballer who, if allowed to grow, could give the U.S. plenty of options up front for years to come.

RT: It shouldn't need to be said, but it does: Christian Pulisic. Given how his summer ended, Pulisic has emerged as something of a target for those looking to assign blame. It's harsh and largely unfair, especially when you factor in all of the things Pulisic can, and so often does, do. He did that again in the first leg, which is a good reminder of how good he is and what he means, both to this program and to the actual players around him.

AL: Ironically, Pulisic. Maybe there’s some excitement about a fresh start, or maybe he wanted to remind Pochettino and U.S. fans of his best after a disappointing summer. Whatever the motivation, this was vintage Pulisic: dangerous, decisive and capable of changing a game in a hurry. The national team needs more of that, especially with World Cup qualifying to navigate this time around.

Which player might benefit the most from a new manager?

Yunus Musah fell out of the first team setup during Pochettino's tenure. - Getty Images Sport
Yunus Musah fell out of the first team setup during Pochettino's tenure.

TH: Yunus Musah is one you'd think. He looked like the pick of the bunch back in 2022, and he's a really handy midfield runner, if used right, with plenty of technical quality about him, too. That's not to say that the U.S. have to go back to the McKennie-Adams-Musah midfield trio. But there's certainly a footballer there to work with.

HOWEVER, whoever the next manager is should give the keys to Cavan Sullivan and let it all unfold from there. He's the real beneficiary.

RT: It remains to be seen, but the position to watch is the midfield. Berhalter went with McKennie - Musah - Adams. Pochettino went with McKennie- Tillman - Adams. Meanwhile, there's a large group of both rising stars and talented veterans in that fight, too, and any one of them could become a preferred player for the next coach. Musah, Berhalter, Santi Castaneda, Jack McGlynn, Adri Mehmeti, Aidan Morris, Johnny Cardoso - take your pick of which guy could be a key cog in the next USMNT midfield.

AL: It depends on who the next manager is, but Yunus Musah and Joe Scally could be two of the biggest beneficiaries. Both are playing regularly in Europe, with Musah finding his footing again at Milan and Scally making an impact in Germany. Both are also outside the current USMNT squad due to decisions that reportedly backfired. A new manager offers a fresh chance to prove themselves, and on talent, both deserve to be in the mix.