Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

Why Christianity Explains Our Deepest Longings

Card image cap

Throughout church history, God has raised up faithful voices to speak the gospel to each generation.

The apostle Paul traveled through much of the known world, preaching in synagogues and public settings. In Athens, he used the questions the culture was asking as a platform from which to proclaim the gospel. Similarly, Augustine, Anselm, Blaise Pascal, C. S. Lewis, Tim Keller, and many others helped readers see Christianity’s coherence amid the questions and assumptions of their times. Through his online ministry, Truth Unites, Gavin Ortlund fills that sort of role in our cultural moment.

In Why Christianity Makes Sense: A Book About Jesus, the Mysteries of the World, and the Longings in Your Heart, Ortlund offers an accessible defense of the faith for readers unsure whether Christianity can withstand serious examination. It’s also a useful tool for discipling believers bombarded with hard questions about Christianity on the internet. Ortlund’s goal is to show “why it makes sense to be a Christian” (xiii).

Ortlund’s particular strength is that he recognizes our questions aren’t merely intellectual. They arise from deeper longings for meaning, purpose, and transcendence.

Unknown God

In Athens, Paul thoughtfully noticed an altar established “to the unknown god” (Acts 17:23). He didn’t mock them for it. Every generation builds an altar of its own. Augustine called it the restless heart; Lewis called it Sehnsucht, the longing that joy itself cannot satisfy. Keller called the traces it leaves behind clues. Ortlund has a name for it: “the ache.”

Ortlund doesn’t begin with a technical exposition of the ache but by showing it’s the desire behind every altar to every unknown god. He asks, “Are you genuinely curious about what life means—why you’re here, and what it’s all for?” (xi). The ache is the restless longing for the transcendent that we can’t put into words.

Just as hunger implies we live in a world where food is meant to fuel our bodies, so the desire for meaning points to the existence of something that will satisfy that desire. So many counterfeits promise to satisfy our desire for God. Many people have learned to deny any sense of longing for the divine or simply scroll past the question before it finishes loading in their minds.

Just as hunger implies we live in a world where food is meant to fuel our bodies, so the desire for meaning points to the existence of something that will satisfy that desire.

In a culture where the most shocking content on social media becomes boring, it’s worth drawing attention to Jesus’s radical claims. “He claimed to be the way, the truth, and the life,” notes Ortlund. “Muhammad taught the five pillars, Buddha spoke of enlightenment, Confucius pointed to the Way, but Jesus pointed to himself as the answer. In fact, Jesus claimed to be God” (104). The claim is preposterous, unless it’s true.

So Ortlund asks his readers to put on their thinking caps: “What if God is real, and Jesus is this God, showing up in history to reveal himself to us? Why not? Is it really all that much crazier than the alternatives?” (104). It’s not. And more importantly, the solution Jesus offers is the most complete answer to the ache. This message deserves to be proclaimed in public.

In the Marketplace

When Paul was in Athens, he “reasoned . . . in the marketplace” (Acts 17:17), the agora, which is where ideas were exchanged. Our modern agora is increasingly virtual, less of a town square and more like the comment section of a microvlog. Ortlund has excelled in this space, making hard things plain in his videos without making them small. His talent for public communication comes through in this book. For example, Ortlund tackles divine hiddenness:

Have you ever wondered why, if God is indeed real, his existence isn’t completely obvious? Why are religious matters so ambiguous? Wouldn’t a loving God want to make things clear to us? (176)

It’s an intuitive argument that undermines the sense that the ache is a longing that can be fulfilled by God. There are people who have really been yearning for truth whose “years of unanswered prayers have stacked up” (177). It can be hard to explain why their search hasn’t been more fruitful.

Yet we don’t have to invent answers on our own. Ortlund draws from historical sources like Pascal to argue that “partial revelation of God is a necessary feature of Christian theology.” Ortlund continues, “This is the drama of the gospel: A God who sneaks into his creation as one person within it, but who came in a manger amidst the donkeys rather than with fanfare and trumpets” (178). God has given us enough evidence of his existence; we just don’t always believe it.

Our biggest problem isn’t ignorance; it’s sin. So even if everything that could be known about God was as plain as day, we might still hate him in our pride. Thus, Ortlund concludes, “A true relationship with God requires humility, which is better served by diligent searching in a partial revelation” (184). Hiddenness, with the Christian God, is an invitation to be found. Ortlund’s gift is making this complex argument clear and compelling in a few pages that a teenager can read on his phone.

Some Believed

Paul had to preach in Athens because his audience had never heard of the gospel. After he told the crowd about Jesus’s resurrection, some mocked, some asked to hear more, but some believed.

Our biggest problem isn’t ignorance; it’s sin.

Our job isn’t to make people believe but to present the truth to them in an intelligible way. Ortlund shows Christians how to do that in Why Christianity Makes Sense, which is a reader-accessible highlight reel of his more academically geared book, Why God Makes Sense in a World That Doesn’t.

This book is an ideal resource to put in the hands of a college student, away from home and all that’s familiar. It will help people seeking God to know him better—or maybe for the first time. The reflection questions at the end of each chapter make it suitable for personal study or within a small-group environment.

Why Christianity Makes Sense offers a compelling argument that Christianity explains the condition of both the world and the human heart.