Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

Fantasy Football Rankings: 5 Most Polarizing Players For Week 11

Card image cap

We have five Yahoo rankers every week, and this column will look at four of the buzziest names of the week. I'm looking for players where there is real disagreement, and I'm using a little something called "coefficient of variation" to help me find just that. These rankings will be tinkered all the way until kickoff, so please check back in on our weekly rankings pages and Sunday AM sit/start show for the absolute latest.

These blurbs are also in The Blueprint, which is my weekly rankings and analysis column. The RB version is out on Wednesdays, while the WR version and the QB/TE/K/DEF version are each out on Thursdays before Thursday Night Football.

Player

My Positional Rank

Yahoo Consensus

Highest

Lowest

Colston Loveland

TE1

TE4

1

8

Patrick Mahomes

QB6

QB5

3

7

Bucky Irving

RB7

RB10

5

14

DeVonta Smith

WR25

WR27

20

42

Tetairoa McMillan

WR17

WR15

11

17

Colston Loveland (vs. NO) - 50.5 proj. yards

Loveland is the TE5 on TE3 usage since Week 6, when Caleb Williams returned. In his last 10 games together dating back to late in his rookie season, Loveland is averaging 11.4 half PPR points on 13.2 expected points, making him a fringe elite TE1. The true elites have disappeared with Brock Bowers healthy and the Cardinals projected for 12.5 points, so Loveland has a real case to take over as the short-term TE1 overall.

The Saints defense ranks sixth in half PPR points allowed to TEs at 13.1 per game, and they don't have the LB/S play to worry about. Harold Fannin Jr. had one of the best reps of the season against them in Week 9, and Isaiah Likely hung 99-1 on them over their last month of games. Chicago enters as 11.5-point home favorites with an implied team total of 30 points (fourth).

Patrick Mahomes (vs. ARI) - 20.4 proj. points

Mahomes exploded for 348 yards and five passing touchdowns against Atlanta in Week 10, bringing his season-long baseline up to QB6 (20.8 PPG). He has delivered +0.15 EPA per dropback (QB9) across his nine starts while chipping in 11.1 rushing yards per game (28th). I can make the case that the return of Rashee Rice and the addition of Josh Downs have the pass game in the best spot of the year right now.

Plus, the Cardinals defense can't stop anyone, allowing the third-most fantasy points to QBs this season. Matthew Stafford turned in three scores despite missing his top receivers last week, and Dak Prescott (QB11), Bo Nix (QB3) and Jared Goff (QB4) have all lit it up since September. It's not a surprise to see the Chiefs projected for 28.5 points (sixth). They won't have Kenneth Walker (groin), which could mean additional throwing production on the margins.

Bucky Irving (at DET) - 85.5 proj. total yards

This assumes Jalon Daniels is back at QB with Baker Mayfield (foot) picking up a new injury during the bye week. The Bucs are likely going to be extremely run-heavy, as they've been for the past two months with the OL smoking defenses up front. Irving has been the RB7 on RB11 usage this season, with 21.0+ half PPR points in 4 of 5 recent games. He's averaged 22.2 carries during that stretch, with games against pretty easy opponents. That's too big to fail, especially given how slippery he is on tape.

The Lions are a pass funnel typically, but the losses of LB Jack Campbell, EDGE Aidan Hutchinson and CB D.J. Reed (questionable) make them fairly bad in both phases. They still have some DTs to worry about, but the Bucs should be able to run it here, despite the spreadsheets suggesting otherwise. Tampa Bay will attempt to bleed out the clock as 7-point road dogs with a team total of 18.25 points (21st). Irving should absorb a lot of that team total.

Tetairoa McMillan (vs. BAL) - 63.5 proj. receiving yards

McMillan is averaging 8.2 half PPR points on 11.7 expected points in his eight games with Jalen Coker this year. Over the past month against a more difficult schedule, he's the WR53 on WR25 usage. He hasn't been getting as open of late, and then Bryce Young has missed him up the sideline a bit too often. He's still handling 24% of targets in an offense that leans pass-first in neutral situations, but the alpha WR1 traits haven't fully blossomed in his second season. He's a very good, not elite, WR to me.

The Ravens sent home podcaster Marlon Humphrey, not that he was very good in coverage this year. He'll battle with CB1 Nate Wiggins, who is much lighter but much faster than McMillan. There will be some 50/50 balls that he needs to come down with to win this individual matchup. Tre' Harris (WR24), Parker Washington (WR19), DJ Moore (WR13) and Tee Higgins (WR2) were able to do just that this past month against them. The Panthers are 2.5-point home favorites with an implied team total of 23.5 points (12th).

DeVonta Smith (vs. PIT) - 48.5 proj. receiving yards

Smith is expected to return after a pair of injuries have derailed his 2026 season. Since 2025, Smith is the WR21 on WR25 usage. While he doesn't have A.J. Brown to compete with, he also plays in a bottom-5 offense now. It's hard to calibrate all of the moving pieces, so Smith is a boom-bust WR3 until we have a better clue for how Joe Milton is going to fit in with Smith.

On top of that, the Steelers have an excellent DL that can spoil the entire game. Philly only has a 17.5-point team total, and I totally get it.