Film Study: The Lions’ Defense Is Alim Mcneill’s Now
The Detroit Lions played arguably their most complete game on both offense and defense as they took care of business against the New England Patriots in Munich, Germany. With the victory, Dan Campbell’s Lions sit atop of the NFC North at 7-2 with a five-game win streak.
All is not beer and pretzels, however, as Aidan Hutchinson has officially been diagnosed with a torn ACL in his right knee, ending his 2026 season. Zooming out for a moment looking at Hutchinson’s injury and recovery prognosis, the reporting indicates that the injury is only the ACL with no other damage to the knee, such as the meniscus. ACL injuries that also include meniscus damage have a different recovery process. For example, Green Bay Packers Micah Parsons not only tore his ACL, but also required full repair of both his medial and lateral menisci. As a result, Parsons was non-weight-bearing for two months after surgery. Conversely, an ACL repair without meniscus damage can allow for weight-bearing and strength rehabilitation to begin almost immediately, most typically walking without crutches within a few weeks.
For further context, Alim McNeill tore his ACL and also required full meniscus repair. McNeill’s performance in 2025 was never quite up to his normal standard. But 2026 has been a different story, finally feeling like his old self again. It’s a good thing, too, because without both Hutchinson and Jack Campbell, McNeill is now the face of this Lions front seven.
He’s more than ready for that spotlight. In fact, it’s time he finally start getting more recognition.
Alim McNeill – most underrated IDL in the NFL? In the running…
— chris long (@JOEL9ONE) November 15, 2026
And it is not just his play, but McNeill was also selected by his teammates as a first-time team captain this season. The other defensive captains this season? You guessed it: Jack Campbell and Aidan Hutchinson.
A lot is about to be put on the shoulders of McNeill. If you ask him, he believes this defensive line still has the pieces to compete more than in past seasons.
Alim McNeill said the Lions different is much more equipped to handle the loss of Aidan Hutchinson than it was in 2024.
— Brad Galli (@BradGalli) November 15, 2026
"It's completely different," he said. "We went, what, 15-2? So we had a good year. This d-line is different. This defense is a lot different. I feel like it's… pic.twitter.com/16QWRUIKOs
The goal of this film study was to look at how McNeill is currently impacting the game and whether his play can lead this defense through the adversity that has been handed to it.
Forcing double teams
Before all of the flash and recognition of quarterback sacks, the fundamental calling for a defensive tackle is to be an unselfish teammate. Dirty work in the trenches is the name of the game.
The first play shown below is right before Hutchinson’s injury on the first drive of the game for the Patriots’ offense. Despite Hutchinson’s clear star power and track record, the Patriots still opted to double team McNeill, leaving Hutchinson, Skyler Gill-Howard, and DJ Wonnum with one-on-one matchups. While McNeill draws both the center and left guard, Gill-Howard wins his matchup with an inside swim move through the A-gap. Pressure is quickly applied to quarterback Drake Maye, resulting in an incomplete pass in the redzone.

Next, the double team is manufactured with an inside pass rush stunt. Below, McNeil starts presnap between as a 1-technique in the A-gap, while Gill-Howard starts as a 4i-technique on the same side B-gap. At the snap, Alim drives the outside shoulder of the center to initiate contact and continues into the left guard. This is intentional as Gill-Howard loops behind McNeill through the remaining natural alley left by the preoccupied center. The result, again, is a quick pressure and an incomplete pass.

Run game disruptor
Forcing double teams is not only critical to change the math of protection calls in pass rush, but also in the run game. The first run play spotlighted below is one I found particularly impressive.
McNeill is lined up presnap in the field-side B-gap as a 4i-technique, shading over the inside shoulder of the left tackle. On the snap, Patriots run a duo-scheme run concept, where both the left tackle and left guard double team McNeill with a combination block to until one peels off to block a second-level defender. In this case, McNeill stands up the double team, anchoring at the line of scrimmage without being displaced nor does he allow the left guard to freely glide to the second-level linebacker. Unfortunately, Lions cornerback Ennis Rakestraw is unable to make the tackle filling the C-gap. The front-seven and Alim McNeill, however, did their job.

Next, I wanted to point out the athleticism displayed by McNeill on this outside zone run play to the boundary. In the outside zone scheme, the left guard will attempt to reach block McNeill, who is lined up as a 3-technique in the B-gap. Alim is able to maintain leverage on the outside shoulder of the left guard and disengages quickly to force the running back to bounce the run outside. This is absolutely a difference making play in the run game.

Pass rush pressure
To close out, I’ve clipped three pass rush snaps featuring McNeill’s impact. First and foremost, his sack with a clean speed rush and rip through the left guard’s outside shoulder. What I find notable on this play is the freedom given to Alim to choose his rush. Late in the cadence, Alim changes his presnap alignment from the A-gap to a wider 4-technique over the left tackle. This creates almost an EDGE rusher’s natural pass rush angle through the guard.

Second, Alim flashes a swim move from a similar 4-technique alignment with a B-gap rush. Unfortunately, McNeill loses his footing through the rush, but still is able to force quarterback Danny DeVito off his spot and up into the pocket, right into the looping Derrick Moore for a sack.

Last is my favorite rush of the three. Now, the result of the play was not positive as DeVito is able to step up and scramble for a big gain. But the impressive play here from McNeill is how he is able to not only play the unselfish role of the pick-player in the designed stunt, but also split the double team to create pressure. Look closely how McNeill both presses vertically on the left guard’s inside shoulder while still punching through the center. Consequently, McNeill and Gill-Howard occupy all three interior offensive linemen while both players significantly crush the pocket.

It’s all about perspective
Over the course of the next week and likely the rest of the season, the prevailing narrative will be that the losses of Hutchinson and Campbell will be too much for the Lions to overcome defensively. I’d counter that by suggesting it is the wrong perspective.
The defense should not be measured relative to what it has lost, but by what it still has. What the Lions still have are blue chip playmakers in Alim McNeill and Brian Branch. What the Lions still have are at least stout run stoppers in Tyleik Williams and EDGE defenders in DJ Wonnum and Derrick Moore. Rookie defensive tackle Skyler Gill-Howard flashed all over this film study as a dynamic interior pass rusher paired with McNeill. The linebacker unit of Derrick Barnes, Malcolm Rodriguez, and Trevor Nowaske have been reliable in Campbell’s absence. Kerby Joseph’s return and impact is still to be determined, but there are signs of optimism. And finally, the perceived weakest link of the cornerback room has dramatically shown improvement over the past five games, coinciding with schematic shifts and situationally rotating personnel.
It’s hard not to look at that group and say it looks much different on paper than the Chicago Bears’ defense. Yet, the narratives surrounding each unit are dramatically different. The Bears added Jeffrey Simmons. The Lions lost Campbell and Hutchinson. Don’t tell the naysayers, but in that small sample size of Weeks 8-10, the Bears defense is fifth in EPA/play and third in success rate, while the Lions defense is sixth in EPA/play and fourth in success rate, per SumerSports.
It’s Week 11 and there is a lot more football to be played and a lot more adversity to challenge all 32 teams. The Lions have already proven they can get back up after getting knocked down. They sure as hell can still be the last ones standing.
Popular Products
-
Portable Foldable Table Tennis Set wi...$506.99$353.78 -
Oversized Giant Tennis Ball$40.99$27.78 -
Tennis Racket Lead Tape - 20Pcs$51.56$25.78 -
Silicone Tennis Racket Balance Weight...$34.99$23.78 -
Portable Pickleball Set with Net, 4 P...$363.99$253.78