Grumpy Old Buckeye: Nitpicking Ohio State’s 28-19 Win Over Northwestern
Welcome back to the column that is always more comfortable being critical after wins than losses. It’s been a minute.
The Buckeyes returned to the win column in a game that was every bit as annoying and messy as expected when the Northwestern Wildcats came to town. I must admit, I spent more time this week yelling at the in-game broadcast team than the team on the field, but there were plenty of things to yell at the Buckeyes, too.
Let’s get into it.
Leveling up the embarrassing play
When things aren’t going well, there’s little reason to go find new ways to look bad, but the Buckeyes managed that at the start of Saturday’s game.
After a promising start — with a defensive stop and competent ball movement down the field — Ohio State entered the red zone, which is a figurative term, as there is no actual color red on the field anywhere that would indicate the team should stop.
Luke Fahey dropped back to pass and Northwestern brought pressure. As a result, the true freshman rushed his thr0w, firing downfield to Chris Henry Jr. about a split second too early. Henry came out of his break and turned to look for the ball, only to see (up close) that it had already arrived, and in fact, was in the process of hitting him in the face.
That would have been embarrassment enough, but the ball bounced high into the air and made for an easy interception. To add insult to injury, the Buckeyes didn’t even line up correctly on the play, getting flagged for illegal formation.
The Wildcats wisely turned down the penalty and kept the ball.
Finish the job
Ohio State’s defense was ferocious on first and second downs, especially early in the game, but there are few things as annoying in watching a football game as when players jump around and celebrate stops on those downs like they’d just stuffed a fourth-down to win the game.
Northwestern converted three consecutive third downs on its second drive, with the first two having to cover eight yards each. Third-and-long situations are supposed to be where good defenses thrive.
On the third set of downs, Ohio State missed a sack on first down that ended up in a completed pass that gained seven yards and set up a short third down.
Good defenses do not let the 46th-ranked team in third-down conversions connect on three in a row to put the game’s first points on the board. However, since that’s what Ohio State’s defense did, I can only conclude this defense has some work to do, even though third down defense got better (mostly) in the second half.
Cavalcade of dumb
The following is just a quick, bullet-form section of things that made me yell out loud at my television. To recap those:
- On the second offensive drive, Ohio State center Carson Hinzmann was flagged for a false start. This was not his first of the season. You can understand why a tackle worried about a pass rusher or a guard concrned about having to pull on a play might move early. The guy with the football in his hand to start the play shouldn’t be doing that.
- Ohio State trailed after the first quarter solely because Jeremiah Smith ran into Bo Jackson, his own teammate, who was failing to block downfield. Smith in the open field is a cheat code, and that play has to go for six points. It’s not a good look for your running back to not be executing a block or for your star wide receiver to simply run into said running back.
- Zion Grady made another third-and-long Northwestern conversion even worse with an egregious facemask on the man blocking him, adding 15 more yards to the end of the play. Grady should buy Kenyatta Jackson dinner, because the latter then made three consecutive plays, including a sack, to force the field goal that Grady helped set up.
Grow up, already!
Ohio State fans are spoiled, and most of us know it.
The Buckeyes have had so much good quarterback play over recent years that we’ve forgotten what growing pains look like. Even when C.J. Stroud had a few vocal non-ball-knowers calling for his benching early in his career, you could see that things would come together sooner rather than later.
Fahey is showing us what real growing pains look like.
Too many passes are seemingly unnecessarily inaccurate, and he loses his footwork too often, meaning he can complete three straight passes and still look terrible on the fourth.
One of his worst throws of Saturday’s game came at the start of the second half. Arthur Smith and Ryan Day called for a shot down the field and Jeremiah Smith had beaten double coverage.
Any throw leading the Big Ten’s new all-time leading receiver in [insert ALL OF THE categories here] would result in a touchdown. Instead, it came much closer to being an interception than a completed pass.
Fahey’s throws all day were of inconsistent. In the second half, he threw a poor pass intended for Smith on second-and-10 that the receiver — who would normally catch it — couldn’t go down and get, but there was no reason to throw it so low.
Fahey then sent another poor pass on third down toward Smith that forced him to jump, and he somehow managed to get the call that he stayed in bounds, although it looked for all the world like a double clutch. Later, Fahey threw another pass that was too flat and Smith couldn’t get his foot down in the end zone near the sideline, when a throw to the back pylon would have been a sure six points.
After a penalty forced Ohio State into a first-and-19 situation later in the second half, Fahey threw a terrible pass behind Nate Roberts that should have picked up a good chunk of yardage. Fahey then threw maybe his worst pass of the day on the ensuing third-and-12 after breaking free of the pocket.
Hopefully, these are throws that go away with more experience and more work on mechanics. Fahey has a gun, but right now his bullets can (and do) go anywhere.
Cavalcade of dumb, part II
Before we move on, here’s another set of things that made me yell impolite things at my television. Ready!?
- Just moments after Fahey badly missed Jeremiah Smith to start the second half, Henry dropped a sure touchdown pass on a deep ball down the left.
- Henry’s drop was followed by a terrible punt and even worse punt coverage, meaning that scapegoating the special teams coach did not make things better. Northwestern then decided to throw to a tight end that was completely invisible to the secondary most of the afternoon to set up an eventual touchdown (following another third-down conversion by the Wildcats).
- That Wildcats touchdown was followed by another bad special teams play, as three different Buckeyes struggled to pick up the knuckleball kickoff, forcing the offense to start in poor field position again.
- An Austin Siereveld penalty for a block in the back that was nowhere near necessary erased a good pickup on an end around — one of the Buckeyes’ most inventive play calls of the day therefore did not end up working out (but it should have).
I must invent a new category for what Legend Bey did
I don’t think anything I’ve written in this column over the decade(-ish) I’ve been writing it for various outlets has enraged me more than Legend Bey making a nice play and then taunting the Northwestern sideline afterward, completely undoing all the good he previously did.
After a decent pickup of nine yards, Bey was pushed out in front of the Wildcats’ bench. He thought it would be a good idea to celebrate this monumental achievement in sports by getting in the face of the entire opposing team.
Instead of a second-and-1 play, the Buckeyes then faced a second-and-16 situation. Fahey got sacked on the next play and the Buckeyes eventually punted.
Wait, I take all of the above in this section back, because it led to the best special teams play of the season — a Northwestern muffed punt.
Cavalcade of dumb, part III
Sigh. Just… sigh.
- Devin Sanchez somehow managed to get hit in the back with a punt late in the third quarter. Braydon Brus recovered for Northwestern to extend a drive that had just gone three-and-out and had gained only one yard. The defense did well to force another three-and-out after the muffed punt, but Brandon Inniss fair caught it at the OSU 10-yard line, which turned out to be minus-33 yards from where the Buckeyes should have started their next offensive possession.
- Kenyatta Jackson roughed the quarterback by hitting him in the facemask with both hands after the ball had clearly been thrown. That turned what would have been a third-and-long situation into a Northwestern first down.
- Isaiah West turned a conservative play call designed to put the game away into hope for the Wildcats with one of the worst fumbles you’ll ever see. Not only did the game situation require two hands on the football to protect it — at all costs, even at the cost of yardage — but the Wildcats weren’t even trying to strip it away on the play. He simply carried it too nonchalantly and it came out after routine contact. The Wildcats were almost out of time, but the turnover game them a chance.
- Ohio State’s defense again determined that tight ends are not eligible recievers that require any attention whatsoever, allowing Luke Dehnicke to pick up 41 yards to set up the final Northwestern score. That touchdown came on fourth-and-10 and the last play of the game, but it was still annoying.
That’ll do it for another week.
The Buckeyes got a win, but it was far from pretty, and nowhere near as comfortable as it could have been if even half of the preventable things above hadn’t happened. No team is perfect, and this team is more not perfect than most Ohio State squads we’ve seen in recent years.
It’s not all on the quarterback injury, but there are times when one wonders how Tavien St. Clair must look in practice if this is what we’re seeing on the field — correctable mistakes or not.
Next up is a trip to Lincoln to play the Nebraska Cornhuskers in a game that could be every bit as annoying and messy as Saturday’s win over Northwestern was.
The game kicks off at noon because of course it kicks off at noon.
Popular Products
-
Table Tennis Rubber Cleaner Spray – 1...$28.99$19.78 -
Tennis Racket Dampener 2-Pack Shock A...$34.99$23.78 -
Adjustable Elbow Brace Support Strap ...$40.99$27.78 -
Electronic String Tension Calibrator ...$41.56$20.78 -
Portable Alloy Stringing Clamp for Ra...$119.56$59.78