Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

Islanders Look Far From Their Best In Overtime Loss To Jets That Slipped From Their Grasp

Card image cap

Winnipeg Jets' Cole Perfetti (91) celebrates his goal against New York Islanders goaltender Semyon Varlamov in Winnipeg, Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026.

WINNIPEG, Manitoba — Winning usually determines what most people see in a Rorschach test of a performance like what the Islanders put forward Thursday night. 

Plus, the loser point the NHL hands out after overtime defeats does not lend itself to clarity, but on a night like this, it felt sort of fitting. 

They were not terribly outplayed by the Jets, but the game the Islanders put forward at Canada Life Centre was far from their best. They took — then handed back — three one-goal leads before ultimately losing 4-3 on Josh Morrissey’s winner in the extra period. That is what you might call a missed opportunity, even as the Islanders extended a point streak to six games. 

9fd381fb49b1727b78b6f69277a4586c.jpg
Adam Pelech, Jean-Gabriel Pageau, Casey Cizikas, Anthony Duclair and Tony DeAngelo celebrate a goal in Winnipeg on Nov. 19, 2026. NHLI via Getty Images

“I thought our legs were probably a six [or] seven out of 10 tonight,” coach Pete DeBoer said, citing a travel schedule that has seen the Islanders crisscross the continent twice in a span of days. “… We maybe ran a little bit out of gas.” 

Six or seven out of 10 might apply not just to the Islanders’ legs but to this entire halting 61:58 of hockey. 

The Jets didn’t look so great either, making for a game that was suspenseful, but in which the mistakes felt more decisive than anything else. The 3-3 tie that carried into the third period came with both teams searching for their best. 

The third period was at least closer to that than the first 40 minutes, with better pace and tighter defense. Semyon Varlamov made the best two saves of his 18 on the night against Brayden Yager and Kyle Connor, but the Islanders failed to reward their goaltender before overtime. 

Then, in 3-on-3, Morrissey made them pay with a wrister that hit Varlamov’s glove before it landed in the back of the net. The moments in which the Islanders fumbled a second point, though, came long before that. 

“Obviously it’s frustrating,” captain Bo Horvat said of the repeated blown leads. “We need to be better in that sense. But at least get a point here on the road, definitely feels better than nothing.” 

7c7fce371f2b49332bceed5db37060f7.jpg
Winnipeg Jets’ Cole Perfetti (91) celebrates his goal against New York Islanders goaltender Semyon Varlamov in Winnipeg, Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026. John Woods/The Canadian Press via AP

Possibly worse than the loss itself was that the revolving door of injuries continued. Just three games after returning to the lineup, Ryan Pulock was helped down the tunnel at the end of the second period and missed the third. DeBoer didn’t have an update on his status afterward. 

While the defense did an admirable job down to five men in the third — “They’re getting used to it,” DeBoer joked — the Islanders didn’t create all that much offensively throughout the evening. 

This was one of Matthew Schaefer’s quieter games of the season so far, while from Victor Eklund on down, the forward group seemed to lose more battles than usual. The power play was messy in two chances, and though the Islanders dominated the Corsi at 5-on-5, their advantage whittled away when it came to shots on net and high-danger chances. 

23e750f7e9ccd34599efb552717d97e0.jpg
New York Islanders’ Tony DeAngelo plays the puck as Winnipeg Jets’ Dawson Mercer gives chase on Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026, in Winnipeg, Manitoba. NHLI via Getty Images

Two of the Islanders’ three goals came off egregious Winnipeg turnovers: Emil Heineman into an empty net after Nico Daws handed him the puck, and Kyle Palmieri after Dylan Samberg’s errant pass deep in his own end. 

The other — Anthony Duclair’s strike 2:35 into the match — was handed back just 31 seconds later when Morgan Barron deflected Samberg’s point shot. 

“I thought we tried to get some sustained offensive zone time, but we were kind of moving it around the outside,” Palmieri said. “We were having trouble penetrating into the really good scoring areas. I don’t know if that’s the way they were playing [or] what we need to be doing differently. I think overall it was a pretty close-checking game.” 

It all brought to mind a key distinction. 

The Islanders gave themselves a chance to win. They did not give themselves the best chance to win.