Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

Senedd Smart Glasses Row Puts Spotlight On Westminster Security Fears

Card image cap

A ROW over a Reform UK politician using smart glasses to deliver a speech in the Senedd has intensified a wider debate over whether increasingly powerful wearable devices should be restricted inside Britain’s parliaments.

Jason O’Connell, the Reform MS for Pontypridd Cynon Merthyr, used smart glasses to assist his contribution during a Senedd debate on Wales’ 20mph default speed limit on September 30.

Members became suspicious after Mr O’Connell delivered a lengthy, statistics-heavy contribution without repeatedly looking down at written notes.

Several MSs said they believed text could be seen moving across his lenses, prompting questions over whether the glasses were being used as a miniature teleprompter.

Reform UK subsequently indicated that the technology had been used to assist his contribution, arguing that politicians already routinely read speeches from mobile phones and tablets.

There is no suggestion that Mr O’Connell used the glasses to film or secretly record anyone.

But the episode has exposed a much wider question facing politicians in Cardiff Bay and Westminster: what happens when apparently ordinary spectacles can potentially combine an autocue, camera, microphone, communications device and artificial intelligence?

The Senedd is now working “at pace” on guidance covering their use.

For the time being, Llywydd Huw Irranca-Davies has determined that smart glasses may be used as a teleprompter in the Senedd chamber provided a Member gives advance notice.

Existing restrictions on unauthorised filming and recording remain in place.

The issue has also reached Westminster, where Liberal Democrats have urged Commons Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle to take action over smart glasses on the parliamentary estate.

Their concerns centre particularly on increasingly discreet camera-enabled devices, which can look similar to conventional spectacles while potentially taking photographs or recording video.

But Westminster was already examining the technology before the Senedd controversy.

On September 15, Lord Ponsonby of Shulbrede confirmed that Parliament was carrying out a specific review into camera-, microphone- and AI-enabled smart glasses.

He said the work was considering their implications for physical and information security, privacy, data protection and accessibility, as well as whether further guidance was required.

Recording through such devices is not permitted without appropriate authorisation.

Concerns have also been raised elsewhere in Parliament.

During Commons questions on September 9, Labour MP Dame Meg Hillier asked ministers about the effect of camera-enabled smart glasses on women’s privacy.

Women and Equalities Minister Bridget Phillipson acknowledged that covert filming through smart glasses could create serious privacy concerns, while pointing out that existing criminal offences including voyeurism already apply to some of their most harmful uses.

The debate presents lawmakers with a difficult distinction.

Politicians have always used prepared speeches, briefing notes, researchers, tablets and laptops.

Using spectacles merely to display a prepared script could therefore be regarded as little more than a modern autocue.

But the technology is rapidly becoming capable of far more.

Some smart glasses can incorporate cameras and microphones, communicate with external devices and use artificial intelligence to process information.

That creates questions extending far beyond whether a politician should be allowed to read a speech from their lenses.

If an AI system were capable of listening to a debate, searching information and feeding suggested responses to a politician in real time, the assistance could be virtually invisible to everyone else in the chamber.

It raises the prospect of parliaments eventually having to distinguish between using technology to display prepared words and using it to provide live external assistance.

There are also substantial security implications.

MPs and MSs routinely attend meetings involving confidential constituent information, sensitive documents and private discussions.

A wearable device capable of discreetly capturing images, audio or data could therefore present risks considerably greater than those posed by a traditional mobile phone.

Any outright ban would nevertheless have to take account of legitimate accessibility requirements, including people who may rely upon wearable technology because of disabilities or visual impairment.

Mr O’Connell has appeared unfazed by the controversy.

After the row emerged, he posted a photograph of himself wearing oversized pink novelty spectacles while supporting a breast cancer charity, joking that he was trialling “some new glasses for the chamber”.

The humour, however, masks a serious problem for parliamentary authorities.

For centuries, legislatures have established rules governing cameras, recording devices, written notes and communications technology.

Smart glasses potentially combine all of them in something worn on a politician’s face.

The immediate controversy may be about whether one MS read his speech from his spectacles.

The longer-term question is considerably more difficult.

As AI becomes increasingly integrated into wearable technology, politicians may eventually have to decide not merely whether such devices can be worn inside parliament — but whether colleagues and the public should be told exactly what those devices are doing for the person wearing them.