Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

The Doctors Who Built Assisted Dying Just Issued A Warning (is Your Parent Safe?)

Card image cap

In October 2026, two University of Toronto psychiatrists who helped build Canada’s assisted-dying system published an extraordinary WARNING in the New York Times. Dr. Gary Rodin and Dr. Madeline Li wrote that Canada’s program is “no longer an option of last resort,” that it has grown 16-fold in eight years to roughly 5% of all deaths, and that people now seek it amid poverty and loneliness. A grandmother in her 70s approved for assisted death after she could no longer cook Sunday dinner, until counseling helped her see her family valued who she was, not what she did.

As a caregiving researcher, I want to be clear about my lens. This is an argument about incentives, and what happens to older adults, people with dementia, and the seriously ill when the cheapest option is also the easiest one to access.

WHAT YOU’LL LEARN
- The stark cost gap that quietly shapes how our system treats the frail and sick
- Why the doctors who built Canada’s MAID system are now sounding the alarm
- The “two doors” problem: how real choice disappears when good care is locked behind cost
- Why this is as much about elder-care economics as it is about ethics
- Concrete steps to protect your loved ones and your family’s savings

CHAPTERS
0:00 The $300 versus $77,000 problem
4:42 The confession no one expected: the October 2026 NYT warning
6:30 “No longer an option of last resort”
7:30 The grandmother approved after she couldn’t cook
9:00 How the law expanded beyond terminal illness
10:30 Why the economics point one way
12:00 What this means for dementia and serious illness
13:30 How to protect your loved ones and savings
15:00 The bottom line: fix door B, do not just open door A

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
What is MAID (medical assistance in dying)? It is a legal process in which a clinician helps end a patient’s life under defined eligibility rules. Canada legalized it in 2016, and several US states allow it under “medical aid in dying” or “death with dignity” laws.

What did the New York Times op-ed actually say? In October 2026, Dr. Gary Rodin and Dr. Madeline Li, University of Toronto psychiatrists who helped implement Canada’s MAID framework and support it in principle, warned that the system has expanded too far and too fast, is “no longer an option of last resort,” and sometimes approves people who should instead be offered more support.

Is this video against assisted dying for the terminally ill? No. The argument is not about removing choice from dying patients. It is that when affordable, dignified long-term care is hard to access, a cheap and easy assisted-death option can become a default rather than a free choice, especially for the poor, lonely, and disabled.

Why is the cost comparison so important? Because incentives shape systems. If ending a life costs an insurer a few hundred dollars while years of supportive care costs tens of thousands, there is a built-in pressure that can quietly disadvantage older and seriously ill people unless strong safeguards exist.

SOURCES & REFERENCES
1) Gary Rodin and Madeline Li, “We Implemented Canada’s Assisted Dying Law. We’re Concerned,” The New York Times, October 2026.
2) Canadian government MAID annual reporting on growth and eligibility; the 2021 removal of the “reasonably foreseeable death” requirement.
3) Published data on long-term and home-care costs versus end-of-life medication costs.
4) Background on US “medical aid in dying” and “death with dignity” laws.

This is a heavy, deeply personal topic, and thoughtful people land in different places on it. If it gave you a new way to think about the economics behind the headlines, like the video and share it with one person who cares about how we treat our elders. Tell me in the comments where you land.

If you or someone you know is struggling or in crisis, please reach out. In the US, call or text 988 for the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline.

ABOUT
Neal K. Shah is a Johns Hopkins- and NIH-funded caregiving researcher and CEO of CareYaya, and has helped thousands of families navigate aging, dementia, and serious illness. This channel breaks down the news affecting families and caregivers.

DISCLAIMER: Educational, policy-analysis, and commentary only; reflects my analysis and opinion as a researcher, not a clinician. Not medical, legal, or financial advice.

#AssistedDying #MAID #ElderCare