Bluenami Blues: New Anti-zionism And The Democratic Party

Photo by Nhan Hoang
In the midst of widespread leftish euphoria over the midterm elections, I’m sure I’m not alone in feeling an inescapable sense of dread.
We have, after all, seen this show before. In 2008, Obama and the Democrats won an overwhelming victory, capturing the presidency and a veto-proof majority of both houses of Congress, swept in on promises to end an unpopular war, fix an economic crisis created by predatory speculation, and provide health care for all. Then, too, the press and pundits proclaimed that the Republican Party was in such a shambles it was difficult to see how it could ever recover.
We all know how that ended: the Iraq and Afghanistan wars were surged and a few others added, the economic crisis was fixed by bailing out the banksters and evicting the homeowners, and the promise of public universal health care was turned into a Heritage-Foundation boondoggle of subsidies for the profits of capitalist health insurance companies and their ever-increasing premiums — all of which paved the way for the rejection of the Democrats and the rise of Trumpism, with its false promises.
One would have to be extremely naïve not to suspect that the current Democratic wave—with the same promises and even with a charismatic, Obama-analog frontman (Abdul El Sayed)—will come crashing down on the hopes of those who elected it, with what, in the historical context, will be an even more chilling and disastrous effect.
What is there that’s different, that offers any more hope of a substantively progressive outcome, in the present iteration?
Interloper
There is one thing that’s very different, that represents a sudden and radical change in the Democratic Party constituency, and the whole nation, that would change the world for the better, and is worthy of political support. That is the emergence of an anti-Zionist political movement which has made anti-Zionist discourse and anti-Zionist candidates visible, respectable, unavoidable, and electorally victorious In a way that was unimaginable just a few years ago.
To be sure, I am not saying that the Democratic Party has become, or that the few insurgent figures like El Sayed will make it, anti-Zionist. The Democratic Party is not controlled by its “progressive” politicians or its constituency. The Democratic and Republican Parties, and the entire political-media cohort of the US, remain absolutely, unconditionally committed to the support of Israel and the Zionist project. We have to be clear-eyed and recognize, with Ali Abunimah, that Israel won this election, as it has all previous in our lifetimes.
But “Israel’s” margin of victory is shrinking fast. AIPAC could boast that it had 331 AIPAC-sponsored congressional representatives in 2024. As of November 4th this year, with some counts incomplete, AIPAC said that “over 234 pro-Israel Democrats and Republicans won their elections in the midterms.” And Responsible Statecraft reports that, while 70% of AIPAC money went to candidates who won in the 2022 midterms, rising to 87% in 2024, that number dropped dramatically to 34% in 2026. AIPAC and its affiliates are burning enormous amounts of cash—$16 billion in Michigan alone—in failed attempts to stop the freefall of support for Israel.
Even CNN reports that, “The general electorate has turned against it [Israel]. This is not just a left issue. It’s an American issue.” Israel’s net favorability in polls now runs from -10 to -23. Since 2018, it’s gone from +51 to -16, a 67-point shift. Pointedly, 55% of Americans now want to reduce or end military support for Israel. “The consensus has shifted…Israel is now seen negatively.”
Thanks to the live-streamed horror of Gaza, masses of Americans learned that Zionism, which has survived on indispensable US financial and political support for 78 years, is a vicious, genocidal, settler-colonial enterprise that deliberately murders and mutilates children at scale.
Thanks to the Iran war, which, because of the surprising military power of Iran, imposed significant concrete costs on the average American and promises to be another of the seemingly pointless “forever wars” Trump promised to end, Americans have roundly rejected going to war on behalf of Israel. Dissident voices on the left and right have now identified the pernicious effect of Zionism’s ubiquitous influence and tenacious purchase on American politics. A critical mass of Americans have come to see how much blood and treasure we’ve wasted on Zionism’s wars, and how costly and detrimental to the nation that has become.
So, the constituency of the country as a whole and, decisively (and probably irreversibly), of the Democratic Party, is rapidly and radically turning against Israel, if not fully anti-Zionist. A politician’s stance on Israel and Zionism has become, as it should be, a deal-breaking issue for most Democrats, and many other voters.
Credit must go to smart, outspoken candidates like Zohran Mamdani and Abdul El-Syed for helping enable this unprecedented transformation of US politics.
Because I think there is nothing more important than ending US sponsorship for Zionism, and thereby hastening its disappearance from the world, I think increasing the presence of Anti-Zionist discourse and policies in one of our major political parties and its aligned media merits political support. Having a figure like El Sayed in the US Senate— someone who has been, and has a good chance of continuing to be, strong on this issue—advances that cause, no matter what his many other faults may be. The hope of long-committed anti-Zionists is that the presence of such politicians will sharpen the contradictions within the Democratic Party, and will accelerate the party’s final rejection of Israel and Zionism.
The much more likely alternative—virtually certain, given its institutional character—is that the Democratic Party will do its smothering-embrace thing, trying to squeeze anti-Zionism back into its proper, liberal-Zionist, two-state mold.
That is, after all, where most of even the most “progressive” Democratic politicians fit.
We can’t forget that most of even the most “progressive” blue-wave Democratic politicians are decidedly notanti-Zionist. They are two-state “liberal Zionists” who have ridden the wave of disgust over the Gaza genocide with denunciations of the “right-wing Israeli government,” and the wave of disgust over the Iran war with promises to end it—because it’s failing and raising Americans’ cost of living. If the party cannot coopt and divert the anti-Zionist insurgents—and there’s not much room here for “co-optatiion” that won’t be recognized as betrayal—it will suppress and reject them tout court.
I and other leftists think that the choice between co-optive betrayal and Demexit is what the new cohort of anti-Zionist progressive Democrats will face, and very soon. The battle over the leadership of Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffires—absolute Zionists who have spent three years enabling the genocidal child slaughter in Gaza—is the battle over whether there will be an end to financial and military aid to Israel, and to the Democratic Party’s unyielding support of the Zionist colonial project. The anti-Zionist insurgents, many of whom have already bent the knee to Schumer and/or Jeffries, and the million+ signers of petitions opposing their leadership, will discover that neither the shrewd strategies of inside-gamers nor the booming voice of the overwhelming majority of constituents who despise the diabolical duo will budge the Democratic Party from its commitment to “Israel forever.” Even if mass popular protest prods the party to replace one or both of the leaders, it will be with a less aggressive, but no less definite, Zionist—like the J-Street-funded Chris Van Hollen, who supports a two-state solution and opposes the BDS movement.
Van Hollen and others may insist that the Democratic Party must put an end to the Iran war by simply defunding it on December 11th and walking away. But that would mean accepting the undeniable defeat of Israel and the United States and the victory of the Islamic Republic of Iran, firmly establishing Iran as the dominant state in the region. Besides, despite their equally arrogant assumptions, it is no longer up to the Democrats, any more than Trump, to decide when the conflict USrael started will end. Here are Iran’s conditions:
I hope anybody who thinks that the Democratic Party—blue-waved and all, under Schumer, Van Hollen, Jeffries, or whomever—is going to accept, and force Israel to accept, those conditions, or that Iran is going forget about them because “Democrats good,” is cozy in their blue heaven. Blue-wave Democrats will have to discover, as Trump has, the new truth that they, as Americans, don’t rule the world anymore. The anti-Zionist and “progressive” Dems will have to discover, once again, that neither they nor the party’s constituency do, or ever will, run the party, and those who do will never just walk away and allow Israeli or the Zionist project to be defeated—especially in what Israel correctly considers an existential conflict with Iran. The only thing the Democratic Party will walk away from here is the anti-Zionism of its own constituents.
Let’s recognize, too, that even the most anti-Zionist of blue-wave “progressive” Democrats are not anti-war or anti-imperialist. Is there one of the blue wave riders calling for the immediate, unconditional release of Maduro and Celia? Promising to end the neo-colonial control of Venezuela and its oil? To explicitly renounce the Monroe/Donroe doctrine and reverse Trump’s actions? Fully and permanently lift the blockade of Cuba?
PEP—Progressive Except Palestine—may be coming to a welcome end. PEI—Progressive Except Imperialism—Is still alive and kicking.
Although he thinks “we probably shouldn’t be fighting wars we don’t know how to get out of,” El-Sayed, who will “never…defend the Iranian regime,” is “glad” the Ayatollah—“a terrible person,” killed along with his wife, daughter, granddaughter, and other family members—is dead. And, despite all the blue-wave concern about “affordability” vs. foreign wars we can’t get out of, he joins most (or all?) of his CIA-NATO-anti-authoritarian-dictator (Putin, Maduro, Castro, et. al.) Democratic colleagues in supporting military aid to, and continuing “involvement” in, Zelensky’s US/NATO proxy war “righteous struggle” in Ukraine.
So, we are to believe the Democratic Party, which has defined itself as the stalwart sponsor and defender of Israel for eight decades, will not allow Ukraine to be defeated, but will allow Israel to.
The result of this election is not going to be that the imperialist, Zionist American regime accepts defeat in Iran (or in Ukraine). It may very well encourage the imperialist, Zionist American regime to defeat Iran quickly before it loses the chance, with Zionist Democrats hoping that Trump does it before they have to.
At any rate, the fight of the continued Zionist character of the Democratic Party starts now, and will end up rather quickly with the submission of some progressive anti-Zionists and the exit of others, along with a huge chunk of the constituency (because I hope, and think, this time, that a lot of people are too disgusted with the Zionism and its enablers)—i.e., the party breaking up. Which is fine by me.
And the genocide will continue.
I know, I know, anything is theoretically possible. I support those who fight the good fight and will be glad to be proved wrong. They can call me when they turn the Democratic Party anti-Zionist, or when they’re ready to fight the good fight on more favorable ground.
The post Bluenami Blues: New Anti-Zionism and the Democratic Party appeared first on CounterPunch.org.