Senate Passes Landmark Permitting Deal
The Senate passed a sweeping permitting reform bill Thursday, delivering a victory for lawmakers who spent more than a year negotiating a bipartisan deal designed to make it easier to build large-scale infrastructure and energy projects.
The bill now moves to the House, setting up a pivotal test for Republican leaders who are hoping to advance it to the White House during the lame-duck session before Democrats take control of both chambers in January.
Nearly all Senate Republicans and a coalition of Democrats voted 62-33 to approve the legislation, which aims to curb laws that for decades have been wielded by environmental groups and states to hamper developers’ ability to build energy projects and other infrastructure, at a moment where AI-driven energy demand has been spiking.
The bill, S. 5653, is the most significant energy legislation to clear the Senate since the Inflation Reduction Act in 2022. Negotiated by Sens. Shelley Moore Capito (R-W.Va.), Mike Lee (R-Utah), Martin Heinrich (D-N.M.) and Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.), the measure would overhaul federal permitting rules by expanding federal authority over interstate electricity transmission, shortening deadlines for environmental reviews and limiting when projects can be challenged in court.
"I have spent years trying to achieve bipartisan compromise on legislation that gets our nation back to building, and the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act is the culmination of those efforts," Capito said.
The 14 Democrats who supported the bill argued that its transmission reforms and changes to the permitting process would be critical to expanding clean energy generation.
Negotiators were hopeful to have more amendment votes, including on a more-recent manager’s amendment that had provisions on data centers, but were stifled by Oregon Democratic Sens. Ron Wyden and Jeff Merkley. Merkley objected on the Senate floor Thursday night to efforts to proceed to a slate of amendment votes unless the Senate took a vote on an amendment to ban data centers on public lands, among other amendment votes.
Republicans, meanwhile, backed the bill's provisions aimed at unlocking permits for interstate natural gas pipelines and overhauling environmental laws they say have long slowed energy development. Sens. Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) and Mike Rounds (R-S.D.) voted against the legislation, citing its expansion of federal authority over transmission.
The White House has backed the bill and lobbied lawmakers to deliver it to President Donald Trump’s desk. The bill has attracted significant support from industry, business and labor groups, but opposition from environmental and tribal interests, along with the challenges of legislating during the lame duck, could complicate its path.
House uncertainties
Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) told POLITICO on Wednesday that he would try to pass the bill under suspension, a fast-track procedure that requires a two-thirds majority and bars floor amendments. If that effort fails, he said he would bring it up under a standard rules procedure requiring a simple majority.
“There's a lot of interest on this side to get [permitting reform] done, and I think it's bipartisan,” Johnson said. “It may be a suspension bill, but if not, we'll do it by rule.”
Whether a suspension vote succeeds will likely depend on Democratic support. Future Speaker Hakeem Jeffries has said “we certainly need to get permitting reform done,” but has not backed away from his position that the legislation “falls short” and needs changes to its National Environmental Policy Act and tribal provisions.
House Democrats remain divided over the legislation, with members balancing competing interests from supportive energy and business groups and opponents in the environmental and tribal communities. Senate Democrats who voted against the bill said it went too far in overhauling environmental regulations and lacked the backing of a majority of tribal groups.
Many House members had declined to take a position until the Senate produced a final version of the bill.
“It's a very difficult place for me because I have a 100% labor voting record,” said Rep. Debbie Dingell (D-Mich.). “But my husband wrote NEPA, clean water and endangered species … and I do think that those bills are written at a time, but there are things that we've got to be protecting.”
House Republican attendance could also become a factor. The chamber has already struggled to advance legislation in the lame duck amid a narrow majority, as some outgoing Republicans who lost their seats in November have been less inclined to return for votes.
Reporter Kelsey Brugger contributed.