Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

Mamdani Releases Long-awaited Plan To Close Rikers Island

Card image cap


NEW YORK — Mayor Zohran Mamdani released a long-awaited plan Friday to close Rikers Island and open four new borough-based jails — a lofty goal championed for seven years by criminal justice advocates that has morphed into a slow-motion legal, financial and logistical nightmare for the city.

As POLITICO first reported last week, Mamdani is proposing to push back the legal deadline to close Rikers Island from August 2027 to the end of 2032, a recognition of extensive delays in constructing the new jails that has come with billions of dollars in cost overruns.

The mayor’s plan also outlines strategies to reduce the current jail population from 6,600 detainees — thousands beyond the capacity of the jails being built — to 4,100. Those initiatives rely heavily on entities like district attorney offices and the state court system that are beyond City Hall’s control, making them a risky proposition even as they are essential to pulling off the larger goal.

On the whole, however, the mayor’s plan marks the first serious recognition that the city is nowhere near able to meet the original deadline for shuttering the notoriously violent jail, where nine people have died so far this year from a variety of causes, and major action is needed. Implementing Mamdani’s plan will require passage of legislation from the City Council changing the legal closure deadline.

“Our city is safest when no New Yorker falls through the cracks, when our government refuses to accept failed approaches to public safety just because it’s always been done this way,” Mamdani said in a prerecorded video, appearing alongside Department of Correction Commissioner Stanley Richards. “We will work with the City Council, court partners, correctional staff and leaders at every level of government to make this a reality.”

The reasons for closing Rikers Island remain the same, even if Friday’s blueprint acknowledges a reality far afield from the atmosphere in 2019, when the Council and then-Mayor Bill de Blasio finalized plans to shutter the facility.

Officials still hope to reduce violence through new, modern facilities, cut down trial delays by housing detainees closer to the courts in which they’re to be tried and give detainees awaiting their court hearings better access to friends and families in the boroughs where they live.

The announcement also marks an evolution for the mayor, who opposed the 2019 plan because it did not go far enough in reducing incarceration in the city. Years later, he has shifted from “no new jails” to cleaning up a mess largely ignored by his predecessor as the city drifted toward an unworkable deadline that would have created a thicket of legal problems if Rikers remained open past its expiration date.

In a briefing with city officials Thursday evening, City Hall pointed to a suite of new initiatives and investments — totaling more than $300 million — designed to shrink the number of people in the city’s jail system, with an interim goal of hitting 5,500 people by the time the Brooklyn facility is set to open in 2029.

The city aims to fund better diversion programs designed to give prosecutors and judges more alternatives to incarceration for individuals awaiting trial. The city is also planning to build service and support hubs near courthouses to connect people accused of crimes with housing, transportation and behavioral health care services.

The Mamdani administration will also make it easier for people accused of crimes to stay out of Rikers by reactivating an online bail payment system, footing the bill for pretrial advocacy groups that will help bring bail appeals and upgrading electronic monitoring technology, making it a more attractive option for prosecutors, judges and defense attorneys.

In addition, the city plans to increase alternatives to incarceration like supervised and secure residential options and provide more social services to those getting out of Rikers to steer them away from reoffending.

The biggest challenge in culling the jail population, however, will be reducing trial delays that have only grown in the wake of the pandemic.

On the city’s end, they plan to work with the NYPD, FDNY and other agencies to produce discovery materials more quickly in criminal cases. The Mamdani administration also plans to create a Case Delay Task Force with the Office of Court Administration, district attorneys and the defense bar.

In a briefing Thursday night, the city’s close Rikers czar, Dana Kaplan, said that because the plan was developed in conjunction with many of these entities and there is a shared recognition that trial times need to come down, the city is uniquely positioned to make progress where it has failed in the past.