Mamdani Wants To Tax The Rich. Hochul Holds All The Cards.
ALBANY, New York — An insurgent left led by New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is planning to pressure Gov. Kathy Hochul to raise taxes, but the moderate Democrat is holding all the cards.
Hochul is returning to Albany next year with a 20-point electoral win under her belt — a victory so broad it included the home county of her Republican foe, Nassau County Executive Bruce Blakeman. The governor is also sitting on a massive cash pile — an $8 billion surplus that will act as a cushion against an economic downturn.
Her leverage extends straight into City Hall. Mamdani, a democratic socialist, may be a global political celebrity, but much of his agenda depends on a governor with broad control over how the state will spend more than $250 billion next year. Their alliance has already steered state money toward shoring up the city’s finances.
That relationship will be tested when Hochul, whose congenial personality masks a stubborn streak, pursues a maximalist agenda of her own while Mamdani and his allies try to persuade her that taxing the rich will help her achieve what she wants. Their strongest argument is a promise she shares with the mayor: expanding free child care.
Hochul has suggested since Election Day that she’s open to striking a deal on taxes, albeit on her own terms. She showed what that can look like this year when she agreed to a surcharge on expensive second homes, which let Mamdani claim a tax-the-rich victory without securing the broader income tax increases he wants.
“She 100 percent has the most power she’s ever had or is going to have,” said Jay Martin, a strategist who ran a pro-Hochul super PAC this year. “The left is going to run into the Albany infrastructure and the reality of her power. No real substantive legislation happens outside the budget. Her power and her leverage is infinite.”
Tax-the-rich advocates are prodding a skeptical governor with planned demonstrations around the state in the coming months. They plan to leverage the swelling ranks of the socialists in Albany, who are set to nearly double their numbers in the Democratic-dominated state Legislature. And, perhaps most crucially, they are framing their persuasion campaign around Hochul’s signature policy to significantly expand free child care as a way to cement herself as a consequential governor.
Yet Hochul, once derided as a weak governor with little sway over a recalcitrant Legislature, is now poised to have far greater influence than she has in years past by dint of her victory — a win that few in her party expected would be a landslide.
Her forthcoming budget proposal — with expected plans to confront New York’s long-standing construction woes as well as how she will bolster long-term funding for her signature child care issue — will have national implications for Democrats trying to defuse intraparty tensions.
The looming tax debate will test how Democrats turn their midterm victories into policies that address voters’ affordability concerns. How Hochul navigates this moment as she prepares to begin her second full term will define her governorship in the years to come. A bruising battle with the left and Mamdani over taxes stands to hamper her agenda. Agreeing to an increase would put her at odds with an already anxious business community staunchly opposed to higher tax rates.
“Second term Kathy Hochul has said she would like to be third term Kathy Hochul,” said Michael Kink, executive director of the advocacy group Strong Economy For All. “She’s also recognizing there’s a drive and an energy around populist politics and a huge part of that is taxing the rich and paying for things every working person needs.”
Hochul’s office touted her child care efforts while pledging to do more on the issue next year.
"Few expenses weigh more heavily on working people than childcare," spokesperson Jen Goodman said in a statement. "After four years of historic investments and expanding access, Governor Hochul is determined to put the overwhelming support she earned from New Yorkers to work, making universal childcare a reality for families across the state."
Mamdani spokesperson Dora Pekec said in a statement that the mayor is focused on addressing affordability with Hochul.
“The midterm election results overwhelmingly showed that working people want urgent action to lower costs, and the Mayor looks forward to working alongside the Governor to deliver on that for New Yorkers," she said.
Hochul took office five years ago in the aftermath of Andrew Cuomo’s scandal-induced resignation. She struggled early on to use her new office’s immense power. The Democratic-dominated state Senate rejected her pick to lead the state’s highest court. Lawmakers approved their own pay raises — a measure governors can use to extract policy concessions — without any strings attached by Hochul.
She successfully recalibrated after those early struggles.
The governor forced through changes that narrowed the scope of a politically controversial cashless bail law. She prodded lawmakers into delaying provisions of a costly climate law. And just this past year, Hochul was able to win over legislators with car insurance law changes that were opposed by the state’s influential trial lawyers.
She was able to do all of this through the state’s budget process, which grants governors outsized power. Governors propose and draft the tax-and-spend bills, which can also include policy proposals that have little fiscal impact, but are often priorities for the chief executive.
Now Hochul is preparing to use that power again.
In recent days, the governor has raised interest in changing the Scaffold Law, a century-old liability provision that holds owners and construction firms responsible for “gravity-related” injuries at building sites. The law has long been blamed by insurance companies and the broader construction industry for making New York one of the most expensive states to build in.
Unions and Hochul’s foes at the New York State Trial Lawyers Association are preparing to dig in to fight any proposal she makes to change the law, arguing that doing so will make workers — especially immigrants working in the construction industry — less safe.
Those arguments, as well as the collapse of a building in Brooklyn that killed 10 people, hasn’t deterred the governor.
“I have no patience for anything that’s standing in our way in making New York state be more affordable, have more energy, have more housing and ultimately have more child care,” Hochul told reporters this week.
She's also signaling plans to confront New York’s intractable education bureaucracy and wants to exert control over the State Education Department — launching a battle with state lawmakers loathe to hand the chief executive more power.
Tax-the-rich advocates, meanwhile, are prodding Hochul to raise taxes on the state’s wealthiest residents as well as its largest corporations — a central plank in Mamdani’s mayoral platform a year ago. They argue that in order to fully fund universal child care — a service that may cost as much as $14 billion — taxes will have to be raised.
“Kathy Hochul’s legacy will be determined by what she’s able to accomplish,” said Jasmine Gripper, director of the New York Working Families Party. “Voters clearly showed their frustration with Republicans. But what you also saw is that we want more. Voters have sent her a message. We’re sending you back to Albany, but what we want is housing, health care, child care and taxing the ultra rich.”
Mamdani was a forceful surrogate for Hochul’s reelection bid, campaigning alongside her in the final weeks while also blasting her Republican critics. But with the campaign over, the mayor needs the governor’s approval to help fund his costly agenda.
Hochul already provided a visible boost during Mamdani’s first year, sending him state aid to help smooth out New York City’s finances and handing him a victory by backing the second-home tax. That levy enabled the mayor to claim a win by declaring “we’re taxing the rich.”
“The only thing that allowed Zohran Mamdani to have a good first year, when you take out the Knicks, take out the snowstorm, was the governor,” said Tusk Strategies President Chris Coffey. “If she cuts a deal with the mayor where she’s funding his child care stuff, it’s hard to see him being too upset with her. If he’s not upset with her, then it really does neutralize the potential opposition.”
Hochul was reluctant in her reelection year to raise income taxes, the major revenue driver for the state government. She has insisted that raising taxes for ideological reasons is not feasible. Yet since securing a second full term, Hochul has left the door open when asked about a potential tax hike.
“If we need more, we’ll find a path,” she said earlier this month.
Revenue from a frothy stock market has handed Hochul a cash cushion that tax hike opponents have cited when questioning the need to raise rates.
Influential business organizations are again lining up to oppose efforts to raise taxes, warning it would have a chilling effect on companies planning to invest in the state. Those groups, including the Hochul-allied Partnership for New York City, have echoed much of what the governor has said: Taxes shouldn’t be raised simply to fulfill a political imperative.
Hochul has presented herself as a moderate bulwark to the state’s private sector, telling them she can restrain the hard left within her own party.
“Taxing somebody for an ideological reason for the sake of taxing them, it’s not about finding a solution, it’s about being punitive,” Partnership for New York City President Steve Fulop said. “We’re willing to find solutions and be at the table, but when the far left does that it creates a trust gap that’s difficult to overcome.”